| 1. | This Game Throws Me for a Loop | Silent Hill Episode 1 | 424 | | Silent Hill
|
| 2. | THAT WAS NOT HERE BEFORE | Silent Hill Episode 3 | 268 | | Silent Hill
|
| 3. | TO THE MOON! | Kerbal Space Program Episode 5 | 218 | | Kerbal Space Program
|
| 4. | This Game Just Nonchalantly Deletes Characters! | Siren Episode 6 | 147 | | Siren
|
| 5. | I May Need A New Pair of Pants... | Cry of Fear Episode 1 | 133 | | Cry of Fear
|
| 6. | This Game is HAUNTING! | Silent Hill Episode 5 | 129 | | Silent Hill
|
| 7. | Why Is This In My Bedroom?! | I'm On Observation Duty 3 Episode 1 | 129 | | Observation
|
| 8. | She's Basically Mr. X | Haunting Ground Episode 5 | 127 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 9. | I Need Therapy... | Silent Hill Episode 4 | 125 | Show | Silent Hill
|
| 10. | Craziest Opening of Any Game | Parasite Eve Episode 1 | 115 | | Parasite Eve
|
| 11. | Something is wrong with this town... | Silent Hill Episode 2 | 100 | | Silent Hill
|
| 12. | Don't Ask Me What I'm Playing! | Random Games Episode 3 | 96 | |
|
| 13. | I Am Beginning To See The Silent Hill Ideas | Siren Episode 8 | 93 | | Silent Hill
|
| 14. | This Game Gets Very Dark Very Fast | Silent Hill 2 Episode 3 | 92 | | Silent Hill 2
|
| 15. | People Are Literally Melting! | Parasite Eve Episode 2 | 83 | | Parasite Eve
|
| 16. | This Is Why People Don't Trust Doctors | Siren Episode 12 | 82 | | Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
|
| 17. | I Cannot Get A Read On This Game! | Siren Episode 1 | 81 | | Siren
|
| 18. | I Knew That Prison Sucks But Holy S... | Silent Hill 4 Episode 4 | 79 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 19. | I'm Not Afraid of Jumpscares... | Fatal Frame Episode 1 | 77 | | Fatal Frame
|
| 20. | I Think I was Supposed to Prevent This Ritual... | Siren Episode 14 | 76 | | Siren
|
| 21. | We Put Our Hand In Places It Shouldn't Be... | Silent Hill 2 Episode 1 | 69 | | Silent Hill 2
|
| 22. | The Mother of God is Born! | Silent Hill Episode 6 | 66 | | Silent Hill
|
| 23. | You Think The Hulk Has Anger Issues? | The Suffering Episode 5 | 66 | | The Suffering
|
| 24. | There is So Much Messed Up Stuff Going On In This Castle | Haunting Ground Episode 4 | 65 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 25. | What the Heck Is Going On! | Cry of Fear Episode 2 | 64 | Show | Cry of Fear
|
| 26. | This Game is Over the Top Sometimes... | Parasite Eve Episode 3 | 62 | | Parasite Eve
|
| 27. | So Tourists Trust Me to Fly Them to Space... | Kerbal Space Program Episode 4 | 60 | | Kerbal Space Program
|
| 28. | What A Cool Name For A Game! | Eternal Darkness Episode 1 | 59 | | Eternal Darkness
|
| 29. | Losing Sanity Breaks The Fourth Wall | Eternal Darkness Episode 3 | 59 | | Eternal Darkness
|
| 30. | A Genuinely Different Kind of Horror | Haunting Ground Episode 1 | 58 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 31. | Something is Off With Heather... | Silent Hill 3 Episode 6 | 57 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 32. | Ruining My Pants Right Before I Get a New Pair For Christmas! | Random Games Episode 7 | 57 | |
|
| 33. | This Man Was Waiting Around The Corner... | I'm On Observation Duty 3 Episode 2 | 56 | | Observation
|
| 34. | Big People, Big Problems | Outlast Episode 1 | 54 | | Outlast
|
| 35. | This Game Did Me Dirty Right At The End! |I'm On Observation Duty 4 Episode 1 | 53 | | Observation
|
| 36. | NEVER Ask Your Grandpa About The War! | PSVR 2 Cactus Cowboy Plants at War | 51 | |
|
| 37. | This Game Ain't Right | Fatal Frame Episode 2 | 48 | | Fatal Frame
|
| 38. | This Game's Puzzles Broke Me... | Siren Episode 7 | 48 | | Fortnite
|
| 39. | When The Corrupted World Gets Corrupted. | Silent Hill 3 Episode 7 | 46 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 40. | I Don't Feel Right About What We Did... | Haunting Ground Episode 7 | 46 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 41. | You Don't Want To Know What I Found In This Well. | Siren Episode 15 | 46 | | Siren
|
| 42. | Silent Hill Gets a Little Silly | Silent Hill 4 Episode 7 | 46 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 43. | We Revisit The Scene of the Crime | Silent HIll 4 Episode 8 | 45 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 44. | This Game Makes Me Uncomfortable Sometimes | Eternal Darkness Episode 4 | 44 | | Eternal Darkness
|
| 45. | I Keep Getting JUMPED | Haunting Ground Episode 3 | 44 | Show | Haunting Ground
|
| 46. | He's A Killing Machine! | Haunting Ground Episode 6 | 43 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 47. | I Can See Them In My House... | I'm On Observation Duty 2 Episode 1 | 43 | | Observation
|
| 48. | Creepiest Game of Its Time? | Cry of Fear Episode 6 | 42 | | Cry of Fear
|
| 49. | What's in The Box? | Silent Hill 2 Episode 2 | 41 | | Silent Hill 2
|
| 50. | It Took Me 8 Hours To Learn How To Play This Game | Siren Episode 11 | 41 | | Mass Effect: Andromeda
|
| 51. | I Forgot How Much I Love This Game! | Resident Evil 1 Remake Episode 1 | 41 | |
|
| 52. | I Think His Brother is Pissed...| Resident Evil 4 Remake Episode 7 | 40 | | Resident Evil 4
|
| 53. | These Monsters Creep Me Out! | Silent Hill Origins Episode 1 | 38 | | Silent Hill: Origins
|
| 54. | I Don't Know What to Expect Anymore | Eternal Darkness Episode 2 | 38 | | Eternal Darkness
|
| 55. | This Game Is PAIN! | Siren Episode 2 | 38 | | Siren
|
| 56. | I Saw This In My Backyard Cam... | I'm On Observation Duty Episode 1 | 37 | | Observation
|
| 57. | Don't Go For A Walk In The Park In The Middle of The Night | Cry of Fear Episode 4 | 36 | | Cry of Fear
|
| 58. | This Game Gets Even Darker | Fatal Frame Episode 3 | 35 | | Fatal Frame
|
| 59. | Our Stalker is Leaving Us Gifts... | Silent Hill 3 Episode 4 | 35 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 60. | Did We Stumble Into The Real Apartment 302?!? | Silent Hill 4 Episode 11 | 34 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 61. | Eileen is A Ruthless AI | Silent Hill 4 Episode 10 | 34 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 62. | WHAT HAPPENED TO HER FACE??? | Siren Episode 16 | 33 | | Siren
|
| 63. | Monster Nurses!? But This Isn't Silent Hill... | Siren Episode 9 | 33 | | Silent Hill
|
| 64. | We Watch That Special Video Tape We Made! | Silent Hill 2 Episode 4 | 33 | | Silent Hill 2
|
| 65. | Something Is Off With My Sister... | Fatal Frame 2 Episode 1 | 33 | | Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly
|
| 66. | THIS CASE IS FIRE! | LA Noire Episode 6 | 32 | | L.A. Noire
|
| 67. | That Ain't No Kid... | Silent Hill 4 Episode 5 | 32 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 68. | This Game Might Be Scarier Than The Original... | I'm On Observation Duty Episode 2 | 32 | | Observation
|
| 69. | Mike is a Badahh! | Eternal Darkness Episode 8 | 32 | | Eternal Darkness
|
| 70. | So This is What The Bloody Handprints Mean... | Silent Hill 4 Episode 2 | 31 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 71. | Getting Stalked By a Guy in a Trenchcoat | Silent Hill 3 Episode 1 | 31 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 72. | Turns Out That Demon Doors Should Be Left Alone... | Fatal Frame Episode 5 | 31 | | Fatal Frame
|
| 73. | I Promise No One Dies In This Episode. | Siren Episode 10 | 31 | | Fortnite
|
| 74. | I Ain't Afraid of No Ghosts...Oh Wait | Fatal Frame Episode 4 | 30 | | Fatal Frame
|
| 75. | There's Something In The Walls... | Amnesia the Bunker Episode 1 | 30 | | Amnesia: The Bunker
|
| 76. | I'm Being Bullied By Rats! | Amnesia the Bunker Episode 2 | 30 | | Amnesia: The Bunker
|
| 77. | Douglas is Actually A Really Cool Character! | Silent Hill 3 Episode 5 | 29 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 78. | Sightjacking Is an Invasion of Privacy! | Siren Episode 3 | 28 | | Fortnite
|
| 79. | I Cannot Believe The Potty Mouth On These People | The Suffering Episode 1 | 28 | | The Suffering
|
| 80. | It's Pandora's Box Except It's Satan's Box | Random Games Episode 1 | 28 | | Pandora's Box
|
| 81. | We Finally Unlock The Door... | Silent Hill 4 Episode 12 | 28 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 82. | The Best Doggo In Any Video Game! | Haunting Ground Episode 2 | 27 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 83. | I Think Closing The Hell Portal Failed. | Fatal Frame 2 Episode 3 | 27 | | Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly
|
| 84. | I Don't Trust The White Light | Siren Episode 13 | 27 | | Siren
|
| 85. | Maybe I'm The Crazy One, IDK Anymore | Haunting Ground Episode 8 | 26 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 86. | Please Believe Me When I Say This Game is Unpredictable! | Deadly Premonition Episode 11 | 26 | Show | Deadly Premonition
|
| 87. | So We Get in the Stalker's Car... | Silent Hill 3 Episode 3 | 26 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 88. | Raincoat Killer Claims Another Victim! | Deadly Premonition Episode 6 | 26 | | Deadly Premonition
|
| 89. | Life Insurance... More Like Death Assurance | LA Noire Episode 4 | 25 | | L.A. Noire
|
| 90. | This Hit Close To Home...Literally | Silent Hill 4 Episode 6 | 25 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
| 91. | Anime Man Just Doesn't Know When To Quit! | Haunting Ground Episode 10 | 25 | | Haunting Ground
|
| 92. | This is Why I Don't Like Subways... | Silent Hill 3 Episode 2 | 24 | | Silent Hill 3
|
| 93. | Your Co Worker Called In Sick... Again... | Random Games Episode 2 | 24 | |
|
| 94. | The Final Boss Is Literally A Baby!? | Parasite Eve Episode 7 | 24 | | Parasite Eve
|
| 95. | Welcome to Cold Blooded Murder and Full Blown Nudity! | LA Noire Episode 7 | 24 | | L.A. Noire
|
| 96. | We Interrogate Phelps' Wife! | LA Noire Episode 20 | 23 | Let's Play | L.A. Noire
|
| 97. | No One Is Safe From This Safe... | The Evil WIthin Episode 5 | 23 | | The Evil Within
|
| 98. | Even The Helpful Ghosts Are Scary | Fatal Frame Episode 6 | 23 | Let's Play | Fatal Frame
|
| 99. | Ashley is Sick of My Insults! | Resident Evil 4 Remake Episode 13 | 23 | | Resident Evil 4
|
| 100. | This Giant Hole Just Appears In Your Bathroom... | Silent Hill 4 The Room Episode 1 | 23 | | Silent Hill 4: The Room
|
