| 1. | Joesby | 39,486 | My honest review of Moonstone Island | 11:00 |
| 2. | The Escapist | 33,409 | Moonstone Island | Review in 3 Minutes | 3:42 |
| 3. | Noisy Pixel | 11,269 | Moonstone Island Review - Farming, Dating, Relaxing | 7:26 |
| 4. | maz_zik | 8,274 | Moonstone Island REVIEW FOR DUDE's | 6:16 |
| 5. | Sallymumble | 8,209 | PERFECT Stardew Valley & Pokemon Crossover!? Moonstone Island Review | 7:35 |
| 6. | I Dream of Indie Games | 2,886 | Moonstone Island Review - A Fun Mix of Farming and Monster Collecting! | 7:48 |
| 7. | Shpeedle | 1,446 | A moonstone island review in 20 seconds or less #gamereviews | 0:17 |
| 8. | SwitchGems | 723 | MOONSTONE ISLAND (P)review 2023 | 4:01 |
| 9. | BB Steam Review | 606 | Moonstone Island Steam Review - He was banned! | 0:26 |
| 10. | MabiVsGames | 588 | Moonstone Island Review - IS IT WORTH PLAYING? | 10:34 |
| 11. | GrantTheGamer | 540 | Moonstone Island: The Perfect Blend of Stardew Valley and Pokemon? (Gameplay Review) | 24:16 |
| 12. | eyesonbee | 303 | Cozy Game Guide: Must-Try Recommendations for Autumn 2023 | 4:35 |
| 13. | Pawkt | 269 | Moonstone Island Review - STARDEW VALLEY REPLACEMENT!? | 3:02 |
| 14. | HyRool | 254 | A Fun Indie Pokémon + Stardew Valley Game? #shorts | 1:00 |
| 15. | MattXCore | 197 | Este Juego Es Una Joya Oculta | Primeras Impresiones y Review | Moonstone Island en Español | 2:37:16 |
| 16. | ZepDownTime | 178 | 【Review】Moonstone Island | 4:30 |
| 17. | JustDaZack | 170 | Moonstone Island – Creature Collector Farming Sim RPG | 1:08:25 |
| 18. | Indie Adventure | 165 | Moonstone Island: a Pokemon-like game, but with dating #indiegame #bestindiegames | 0:55 |
| 19. | Lexilynstar | 143 | An HONEST REVIEW Of Moonstone Island! | 5:12 |
| 20. | YourNerdGasm | 96 | Super-Fanta-Fi: Nancy Drew Season 2 Episode 13 "The Beacon of Moonstone Island" Review | 24:57 |
| 21. | Level With Us | 94 | Moonstone Island | Mini-Review | 17:07 |
| 22. | LBG Reviews | 85 | LBG Reviews | Moonstone Island | 9:46 |
| 23. | nyx_crossing_ | 18 | Moonstone Island Demo Review | 6:38 |