What differentiates us from the machines? | 5 perspectives | Penrose, Noble, Millar, Aaronson, Bach

Channel:

The Institute of Art and Ideas

Subscribers:

526,000

Published on January 24, 2025 8:12:18 PM ● Video Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvDIZM0hYXM

Duration: 0:00

45,312 views

1,141

Five leading thinkers, from different disciplines, share their perspectives on a question that becomes more pressing with each passing day: What, if anything, differentiates us from the machines?

#ai #consciousness #quantummechanics #psychoanalysis #biology #computerscience

Debates and talks featured:

Denis Noble on the symmetry of order and disorder (2024)
Watch for free on YouTube:
   • It's not all evolution: Denis Noble o...  

Scott Aaronson on consciousness and AI safety (2024)
Watch for free on YouTube:
   • OpenAI expert Scott Aaronson on consc...  

Roger Penrose on quantum mechanics and consciousness (2023)
Watch for free on YouTube:
   • Roger Penrose on quantum mechanics an...  

Isabel Millar: The psychology of AI (2023)
Watch on iai.tv with a free trial:
https://iai.tv/video/the-psychology-of-ai-isabel-millar?utm_source=YouTube

Joscha Bach: Consciousness, AI, and the pattern of reality (2024)
Watch on iai.tv with a free trial:
https://iai.tv/video/consciousness-ai-and-the-pattern-of-reality-with-joscha-bach?utm_source=YouTube

Dive into our full archive, including debates and solo talks from these five speakers.

Science channel: https://iai.tv/debates-and-talks?channel=philosophy:all

Philosophy channel: https://iai.tv/debates-and-talks?channel=philosophy:all

Watch more from:
Roger Penrose: https://iai.tv/home/speakers/roger-penrose?utm_source=YouTube

Isabel Millar: https://iai.tv/home/speakers/isabel-millar?utm_source=YouTube

Scott Aaronson: https://iai.tv/home/speakers/scott-aaronson?utm_source=YouTube

Joscha Bach: https://iai.tv/home/speakers/joscha-bach?utm_source=YouTube

Denis Noble: https://iai.tv/home/speakers/denis-noble?utm_source=YouTube

00:00 Introduction
00:53 Denis Noble: Stochasticity
05:13 Scott Aaronson on AI skeptics
07:44 Roger Penrose: The collapse of the wave function
15:31 Scott Aaronson on Roger Penrose
16:51 Scott Aaronson: Ephemerality
20:20 Joscha Bach on Roger Penrose
21:48 Roger Penrose on his critics
22:07 Isabel Millar: Embodiedness
22:57 Joscha Bach: Self-organisation
26:09 Isabel Millar on structures of meaning
27:50 Why AI won’t be humanlike for very long