| 1. | Call of Cthulhu | 3,322,460 | 5.98% | 74 | 14:14:09 |
| 2. | American McGee's Alice | 2,083,278 | 3.75% | 89 | 17:57:35 |
| 3. | F.E.A.R. | 2,055,169 | 3.70% | 142 | 1:02:21:53 |
| 4. | Penumbra: Overture | 2,050,327 | 3.69% | 30 | 4:18:35 |
| 5. | System Shock 2 | 1,970,873 | 3.55% | 122 | 22:00:16 |
| 6. | Dead Space | 1,918,410 | 3.45% | 109 | 19:21:19 |
| 7. | Amnesia: The Dark Descent | 1,884,336 | 3.39% | 85 | 1:01:55:53 |
| 8. | Metro 2033 | 1,796,365 | 3.23% | 78 | 11:50:12 |
| 9. | Silent Hill: Homecoming | 1,749,875 | 3.15% | 60 | 16:22:11 |
| 10. | Aliens Versus Predator 2 | 1,440,974 | 2.59% | 62 | 9:01:33 |
| 11. | Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines | 1,368,862 | 2.46% | 115 | 3:12:59:52 |
| 12. | Aliens Versus Predator | 1,207,647 | 2.17% | 66 | 11:08:22 |
| 13. | Alice: Madness Returns | 1,180,862 | 2.13% | 98 | 1:11:18:16 |
| 14. | Penumbra: Black Plague | 1,152,327 | 2.07% | 26 | 3:56:09 |
| 15. | Dead Space 2 | 1,146,832 | 2.06% | 89 | 20:54:19 |
| 16. | The Suffering | 1,136,508 | 2.05% | 52 | 7:00:34 |
| 17. | Dark Souls | 1,039,382 | 1.87% | 106 | 1:12:30:52 |
| 18. | Amnesia: The Bunker | 972,180 | 1.75% | 14 | 8:52:24 |
| 19. | Silent Hill 3 | 798,911 | 1.44% | 44 | 15:46:54 |
| 20. | Bloodborne | 715,385 | 1.29% | 95 | 3:01:58:02 |
| 21. | Singularity | 692,257 | 1.25% | 32 | 6:07:23 |
| 22. | Cry of Fear | 676,953 | 1.22% | 46 | 9:03:23 |
| 23. | Clive Barker's Undying | 590,638 | 1.06% | 38 | 8:37:23 |
| 24. | Alien: Isolation | 562,325 | 1.01% | 48 | 12:47:58 |
| 25. | Nier | 560,716 | 1.01% | 74 | 1:13:24:09 |
| 26. | Alan Wake | 551,025 | 0.99% | 60 | 1:16:18:05 |
| 27. | Darkwood | 537,532 | 0.97% | 70 | 1:01:29:15 |
| 28. | The Evil Within | 527,639 | 0.95% | 63 | 23:53:06 |
| 29. | S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl | 525,918 | 0.95% | 44 | 1:01:02:54 |
| 30. | Drakengard 3 | 497,556 | 0.90% | 67 | 1:12:09:10 |
| 31. | Eternal Darkness | 495,413 | 0.89% | 40 | 20:22:03 |
| 32. | Dark Souls II | 491,501 | 0.88% | 76 | 2:04:33:21 |
| 33. | Doom 3 | 451,285 | 0.81% | 44 | 9:46:22 |
| 34. | Dead Space 3 | 425,714 | 0.77% | 66 | 18:44:24 |
| 35. | Silent Hill: Downpour | 388,568 | 0.70% | 34 | 7:57:50 |
| 36. | Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth | 373,529 | 0.67% | 38 | 22:40:15 |
| 37. | Dark Souls III | 366,610 | 0.66% | 72 | 23:41:00 |
| 38. | S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Call of Pripyat | 348,727 | 0.63% | 54 | 14:36:06 |
| 39. | Nier: Automata | 316,475 | 0.57% | 69 | 1:17:29:00 |
| 40. | BioShock | 279,946 | 0.50% | 20 | 2:25:44 |
| 41. | Deadly Premonition | 274,360 | 0.49% | 62 | 1:16:56:52 |
| 42. | The Darkness | 267,377 | 0.48% | 22 | 4:53:25 |
| 43. | Soma | 256,707 | 0.46% | 35 | 9:24:44 |
| 44. | Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water | 255,469 | 0.46% | 46 | 12:31:05 |
| 45. | Metro: Last Light | 249,691 | 0.45% | 39 | 8:40:34 |
| 46. | Silent Hill | 242,969 | 0.44% | 33 | 15:25:56 |
| 47. | Resident Evil 7 | 237,565 | 0.43% | 31 | 9:10:12 |
| 48. | Valkyria Chronicles | 233,521 | 0.42% | 48 | 1:20:28:08 |
| 49. | The Evil Within 2 | 229,429 | 0.41% | 47 | 13:53:57 |
| 50. | Resident Evil: Revelations 2 | 225,572 | 0.41% | 40 | 10:08:27 |
| 51. | Resident Evil 4 | 221,296 | 0.40% | 35 | 1:04:21:27 |
| 52. | Resident Evil 2 | 217,582 | 0.39% | 44 | 21:51:42 |
| 53. | F.E.A.R. 3 | 215,995 | 0.39% | 16 | 4:59:14 |
| 54. | Lone Survivor | 212,689 | 0.38% | 20 | 3:49:14 |
| 55. | World of WarCraft | 209,067 | 0.38% | 17 | 2:45:05 |
| 56. | F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin | 204,261 | 0.37% | 22 | 6:09:43 |
| 57. | Haunting Ground | 191,644 | 0.35% | 40 | 1:04:59:02 |
| 58. | Far Cry | 177,047 | 0.32% | 5 | 26:43 |
| 59. | Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night | 174,071 | 0.31% | 15 | 1:03:21:34 |
| 60. | Aliens vs. Predator | 172,487 | 0.31% | 12 | 2:21:56 |
| 61. | Silent Hill 2 | 166,912 | 0.30% | 28 | 7:16:24 |
| 62. | Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia | 161,008 | 0.29% | 17 | 12:53:59 |
| 63. | The Last Door | 160,205 | 0.29% | 20 | 8:25:17 |
| 64. | Vampyr | 158,036 | 0.28% | 48 | 18:48:09 |
| 65. | Resident Evil 4 | 149,039 | 0.27% | 31 | 11:58:50 |
| 66. | League of Legends | 147,493 | 0.27% | 5 | 3:04:17 |
| 67. | The Suffering: Ties That Bind | 146,598 | 0.26% | 14 | 5:10:14 |
| 68. | Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs | 144,929 | 0.26% | 18 | 4:17:32 |
| 69. | The Binding of Isaac | 142,918 | 0.26% | 18 | 7:56:36 |
| 70. | Resident Evil 5 | 139,746 | 0.25% | 21 | 8:24:41 |
| 71. | No More Heroes | 138,081 | 0.25% | 21 | 15:49:55 |
| 72. | Obscure | 130,749 | 0.24% | 14 | 4:09:32 |
| 73. | Splatterhouse 2 | 130,203 | 0.23% | 8 | 1:30:20 |
| 74. | Obscure II | 126,757 | 0.23% | 20 | 4:57:38 |
| 75. | Audiosurf | 125,806 | 0.23% | 9 | 36:25 |
| 76. | Half-Life 2 | 118,560 | 0.21% | 6 | 1:00:01 |
| 77. | Metro: Exodus | 110,423 | 0.20% | 43 | 14:29:12 |
| 78. | Fatal Frame III: The Tormented | 109,174 | 0.20% | 15 | 2:54:39 |
| 79. | DayZ | 106,644 | 0.19% | 11 | 42:37 |
| 80. | Blasphemous | 103,503 | 0.19% | 9 | 15:21:50 |
| 81. | Bayonetta | 102,362 | 0.18% | 22 | 13:54:29 |
| 82. | Splatterhouse | 100,330 | 0.18% | 21 | 6:15:45 |
| 83. | Fatal Frame | 98,521 | 0.18% | 8 | 1:27:06 |
| 84. | Castlevania | 98,402 | 0.18% | 12 | 11:57:07 |
| 85. | Lust for Darkness | 93,698 | 0.17% | 4 | 2:15:45 |
| 86. | Chrono Trigger | 85,267 | 0.15% | 18 | 1:00:05:17 |
| 87. | Doom | 82,496 | 0.15% | 26 | 11:29:55 |
| 88. | Lust from Beyond | 78,044 | 0.14% | 1 | 44:15 |
| 89. | No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle | 75,146 | 0.14% | 23 | 14:46:53 |
| 90. | Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly | 72,210 | 0.13% | 9 | 2:02:39 |
| 91. | Metal Gear Solid | 71,785 | 0.13% | 20 | 14:00:38 |
| 92. | Minecraft | 69,437 | 0.13% | 3 | 5:55 |
| 93. | Berserk | 68,508 | 0.12% | 7 | 3:09:10 |
| 94. | Secret of Mana | 67,853 | 0.12% | 13 | 14:20:04 |
| 95. | Castlevania: Circle of the Moon | 67,744 | 0.12% | 10 | 3:55:08 |
| 96. | Castlevania: Symphony of the Night | 65,987 | 0.12% | 8 | 6:48:38 |
| 97. | Half-Life | 60,304 | 0.11% | 4 | 38:19 |
| 98. | Ghost House | 59,965 | 0.11% | 2 | 22:01 |
| 99. | The Sinking City | 52,889 | 0.10% | 20 | 1:03:23:01 |
| 100. | Cryostasis: Sleep of Reason | 50,436 | 0.09% | 2 | 18:37 |
