| 1. | Sarah Breaks A Chair - APWSTR 196 | 107 | |
|
| 2. | Milk Is The Exception - APWSTR 177 | 102 | |
|
| 3. | Freddy FiveBears On The Cross - APWSTR 184 | 93 | |
|
| 4. | Fanfiction Is Art - APWSTR 178 | 80 | |
|
| 5. | Homelander, The Biggest A-Hole - APWSTR 179 | 77 | |
|
| 6. | Let's Just Chill Out - APWSTR 189 | 76 | |
|
| 7. | "Placeholder" Engagement Ring - APWSTR 172 | 74 | Show |
|
| 8. | Don't Do The Math - APWSTR 165 | 69 | Show | Counter-Strike: Source
|
| 9. | The Coffee Episode - APWSTR 186 | 68 | |
|
| 10. | 200 Too Many - APWSTR 200 | 67 | |
|
| 11. | A Very Masculine Episode - APWSTR 201 | 67 | |
|
| 12. | We Swear This One's Funny - APWSTR 197 | 66 | |
|
| 13. | Stop Farting In My Face - APWSTR 180 | 65 | |
|
| 14. | Sarah Gray Rocks The Audience - APWSTR 169 | 64 | Show |
|
| 15. | Stop Kissing Your Own Baby - APWSTR 173 | 63 | Show |
|
| 16. | We Got It Right The Second Time (Featuring John From OKOP!) - APWSTR 181 | 63 | |
|
| 17. | The Anger Episode - APWSTR 188 | 62 | |
|
| 18. | Distractable Gnomes - APWSTR 191 | 62 | |
|
| 19. | Thicc Bois - APWSTR 190 | 60 | |
|
| 20. | Wake Yourself Up By Your Bootstraps - APWSTR 203 | 60 | |
|
| 21. | Don't Watch This One - APWSTR 183 | 59 | |
|
| 22. | Escalating In Simplicity - APWSTR 205 | 59 | |
|
| 23. | History Will Call Them Friends - APWSTR 171 | 59 | Show |
|
| 24. | Don't Shoot Dogs!! - APWSTR 195 | 58 | |
|
| 25. | You Should Gaslight Your Dad - APWSTR 199 | 57 | |
|
| 26. | Pleasure Filled Weekend Getaway - APWSTR 164 | 56 | Show | Getaway!
|
| 27. | Towers Be Tumbling - APWSTR 182 | 56 | |
|
| 28. | This Is A Low Energy One - APWSTR 194 | 55 | |
|
| 29. | Amogus But It's Reddit Stories - APWSTR 168 | 53 | Show | Counter-Strike: Source
|
| 30. | Waxed From Head To Toe - APWSTR 166 | 53 | Show |
|
| 31. | Finding The Cheese - APWSTR 206 | 52 | |
|
| 32. | Josh Is Judgmental - APWSTR 208 | 52 | |
|
| 33. | Friendzoning Your Fiancée - APWSTR 159 | 52 | Show |
|
| 34. | CLAPPING IS FUN - APWSTR 161 | 52 | Show |
|
| 35. | The Life And Death Of Fawkes - APWSTR 210 | 52 | |
|
| 36. | One Crazy Night In York - APWSTR 212 | 51 | |
|
| 37. | Nitpicking Your Way To Hell - APWSTR 187 | 50 | |
|
| 38. | The Taming Of The Lions - APWSTR 202 | 50 | |
|
| 39. | FaLlOuT iS wOkE nOw - APWSTR 193 | 49 | |
|
| 40. | Would Society Be Okay With That? - APWSTR 162 | 49 | Show |
|
| 41. | Solid Snake, Gnome Stealer - APWSTR 204 | 49 | |
|
| 42. | We're Sorry Tampa - APWSTR 207 | 48 | |
|
| 43. | Only Slightly Inappropriate - APWSTR 170 | 47 | Show |
|
| 44. | BADA-DADA-DADA-DADUP - APWSTR 211 | 45 | |
|
| 45. | Fulfilling Our Contractual Obligations - APWSTR 209 | 44 | |
|
| 46. | Water Not Get - APWSTR 192 | 44 | |
|
| 47. | The Book of Henry Broke Us - APWSTR 198 | 43 | |
|
| 48. | Leave Him a Shell of a Human Being - APWSTR 156 | 42 | Show |
|
| 49. | The Great Cockatoo Heist of 1984 - APWSTR 185 | 42 | |
|
| 50. | Can Bluey Please Stop Making Us Cry - APWSTR #148 | 42 | Show |
|
| 51. | The Pizza Episode - APWSTR 163 | 40 | Show |
|
| 52. | AITA: Want a Normal Christmas Tree - APWSTR #142 Highlight | 39 | |
|
| 53. | Meet Me in the Podcast Parking Lot - APWSTR #142 | 38 | |
|
| 54. | Getting Lightly Hit By a Car - APWSTR #153 | 37 | Show |
|
| 55. | You Gotta Have Two Toilets - APWSTR 157 | 35 | Show |
|
| 56. | Mouth-to-Mouth With Josh Hutcherson - APWSTR 167 | 33 | Show | Counter-Strike: Source
|
| 57. | You Got No Horse Money - APWSTR 160 | 32 | Show |
|
| 58. | CANCER: A Gateway Drug - APWSTR 158 | 30 | Show |
|
| 59. | 150 Too Many - APWSTR #150 | 29 | Show |
|
| 60. | AITA: Told SIL To Stop Crocheting - APWSTR 179 Highlight | 28 | |
|
| 61. | The Queen Died and Werewolves Did It - APWSTR #134 | 28 | Show |
|
| 62. | Stranger Things Ruined Doja Cat AND D&D - APWSTR #128 | 25 | Show |
|
| 63. | The Last of Us Can't Compete With This Wolf Story - APWSTR #145 | 25 | Show | The Last of Us
|
| 64. | But is Love REALLY Blind? - APWSTR 154 | 24 | Show |
|
| 65. | We Just Jumped Into It - APWSTR #139 | 24 | Show |
|
| 66. | two podcasters read wolf fanfiction for 11 hours and 49 minutes | 21 | Show |
|
| 67. | Jennette McCurdy and Sarah Have One Thing in Common - APWSTR #131 | 21 | Show |
|
| 68. | The Ten Condiments - APWSTR #152 | 21 | Show |
|
| 69. | New Year, New Me - APWSTR #143 | 20 | |
|
| 70. | Chekhov's Loneliness - APWSTR #147 | 20 | Show |
|
| 71. | Calm Down, We'll Talk About This Later - APWSTR #149 | 20 | Show | Counter-Strike: Source
|
| 72. | All These Men Are Trash - APWSTR #125 | 20 | Show |
|
| 73. | Surviving Hurricane Ian and Ned Fulmer - APWSTR #135 | 19 | Show |
|
| 74. | Maybe Don't Abuse Your Power - APWSTR #144 | 19 | Show |
|
| 75. | Decision 2022: Team Ryder vs. Team James - APWSTR #137 | 19 | Show |
|
| 76. | Wolf Fanfiction Found at Mar-a-Lago - APWSTR #132 | 19 | Show |
|
| 77. | The Circle v. Squid Game/Karate Kicking People Out - APWSTR #95 | 18 | Show |
|
| 78. | Marmaduke Absolutely Destroyed Us - APWSTR #129 | 18 | Show |
|
| 79. | It Was a Horse Story All Along - APWSTR #146 | 18 | Show |
|
| 80. | Wedding Shenanigans, Emergencies, and Expelled “Friends” - APWSTR #113 | 18 | Show |
|
| 81. | Ten Times More Pleasure - APWSTR 155 | 18 | Show |
|
| 82. | Rehearsing Your Return to Alpha Tyler - APWSTR #133 | 17 | Show |
|
| 83. | AITA: BF Wants Me To Stop My Period - APWSTR 204 Highlight | 17 | |
|
| 84. | Josh Gets Old, The World Gets Worse, and Breaking Off Friends - APWSTR #122 | 16 | Show |
|
| 85. | Pride, Returning to Reddit, and Birthdays - APWSTR #123 | 16 | Show |
|
| 86. | A Very Epic Valentine's Day Episode - APWSTR #111 | 15 | Show |
|
| 87. | Theater Kids, Cheating Before Marriage, and Poop! - APWSTR #96 | 15 | Show |
|
| 88. | AITA: Took Pregnant Wife For Hike - APWSTR 187 Highlight | 15 | |
|
| 89. | Love is Blind, Funeral Parties, and Fights - APWSTR #112 | 15 | Show |
|
| 90. | AITA: Deleted GF's Sims Saves - APWSTR 195 Highlight | 15 | |
|
| 91. | Bloomberg Bad, Privates in Ice Cream, and Photoshopped Pics - APWSTR #107 | 15 | Show |
|
| 92. | two podcasters read starkit's prophecy for 4 hours and 49 minutes | 14 | |
|
| 93. | Steven Universe, Epic Pranks, and Very Messy Situations - APWSTR #109 | 14 | Show |
|
| 94. | Maybe Buying Twitter Was a Bad Idea - APWSTR #138 | 14 | Show |
|
| 95. | AITA: Didn't Make Extra Pancakes for Niece - APWSTR #145 Highlight | 14 | Show |
|
| 96. | Josh and Sarah's Epic COVID Adventure - APWSTR #106 | 14 | Show |
|
| 97. | AITA: Told GF To Keep Topics to Herself - APWSTR #139 Highlight | 13 | Show |
|
| 98. | AITA: Cut Step-Daughter's Hair - APWSTR 161 Highlight | 13 | Show |
|
| 99. | Creator Clash, Skipping School, and Bad Friends - APWSTR #120 | 13 | Show |
|
| 100. | Masterclass on Being The Worst - APWSTR #99 | 13 | Show |
|
