| 1. | ALCS Game 5. - Astros Vs Yankees | 1,516 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 2. | World Series Game 6. Phillies Vs Astros | 1,419 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 3. | World Series Game 5. - Mets Vs Yankees | 1,100 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 4. | World Series Game 2. Phillies Vs Astros | 861 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 5. | MLB the Show 20 RTTS Home run compilation | 616 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 6. | World Series Game 7. - Yankees Vs Mets | 376 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 7. | World Series (2000) Game 2. Mets Vs Yankees | 345 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 8. | World Series Game 4. Astros Vs Phillies | 336 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 9. | World Series Game 3. - Mets Vs Yankees | 305 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 10. | NLCS Game 4. - Mets Vs Braves | 251 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 11. | World Series Game 1. Phillies Vs Astros | 237 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 12. | World Series Game 3. Astros Vs Phillies | 188 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 13. | ALDS Game 5. - Guardians Vs Yankees | 187 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 14. | NLCS Game 3 - Mets Vs Braves | 187 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 15. | World Series Game 2. - Yankees Vs Mets | 138 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 16. | ALDS Game 4. - Yankees Vs Guardians | 137 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 17. | NLDS Game 1. - Braves Vs Dodgers | 128 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 18. | NLCS Game 7. - Braves Vs Mets | 116 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 19. | World Series Game 1. - Yankees Vs Mets | 116 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 20. | ALDS Game 1 - Guardians Vs Yankees | 114 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 21. | NLCS Game 5. - Mets Vs Braves | 103 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 22. | World Series (2000) Game 4. Yankees Vs Mets | 97 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 23. | ALDS Game 2 - Guardians Vs Yankees | 85 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 24. | NLDS Game 2. - Cardinals Vs Mets | 78 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 25. | ALCS Game 4. - Astros Vs Yankees | 75 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 26. | World Series (2000) Game 3. Yankees Vs Mets | 74 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 27. | World Series Game 4. - Mets Vs Yankees | 74 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 28. | World Series (2000) Game 5. Yankees Vs Mets | 56 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 29. | NLDS Game 1. - Cardinals Vs Mets | 52 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 30. | MLB The Show 20 - Mets Vs Nationals (2021) | 38 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 31. | MLB The Show 20 - Cardinals Vs Phillies (2021) | 37 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 32. | MLB The Show 20 | Yankees Vs Nationals | 28 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 33. | MLB The Show 20 RTTS World Series Game 7 | 23 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 34. | MLB The Show 20 | Nationals Vs Rockies | 22 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 35. | MLB The Show 20 | Mets Vs Yankees | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 36. | MLB The Show 20 - RTTS Walkoff NLDS | 19 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 37. | MLB The Show 20 | Brewers Vs Nationals | 18 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 38. | MLB The Show 20 - Twins Vs Yankees (2021) | 17 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 39. | MLB The Show 20 | Nationals Vs Astros | 17 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 40. | MLB The Show 20 - Indians Vs Yankees | 16 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 41. | MLB The Show 20 RTTS Debut | 16 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 42. | MLB The Show 20 - Phillies Vs Mets | 16 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 43. | MLB The Show 20 | Dodgers Vs Cardinals | 15 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 44. | MLB The Show 20 - Angels Vs Twins | 14 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 45. | MLB The Show 20 RTTS Called up | 14 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 46. | MLB The Show 20 - Twins Vs Indians | 14 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 47. | MLB The Show 20 - Yankees Vs Phillies | 14 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 48. | MLB The Show 20 | White Sox Vs Rays | 12 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 49. | MLB The Show 20 - Rays Vs Red Sox (2021) | 11 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 50. | MLB The Show 20 - NLCS Game 6 | 10 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 51. | MLB The Show 20 DD Perfect Game | 8 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
| 52. | MLB The Show 20 - Diamond Dynasty | 4 | Show | MLB The Show 20
|
