| 1. |  Channel Awesome | The Mummy - Nostalgia Critic | 8,316 | Review |
| 2. | Channel Awesome | Spider-Man - Nostalgia Critic | 7,238 | Review |
| 3. | Channel Awesome | Who Framed Roger Rabbit - Nostalgia Critic | 5,025 | Review |
| 4. | Channel Awesome | Battleship - Nostalgia Critic | 3,751 | Review |
| 5. | Channel Awesome | Scooby-Doo and the Witch's Ghost - Nostalgia Critic | 2,901 | Review |
| 6. | Channel Awesome | All the Spider-Man Movies - Nostalgia Critic | 2,302 | Review |
| 7. | Erik C 'Piano Man' | Animal Crossing: Piano Medley (Nostalgia Edition) | 2,052 | |
| 8. | MVPerry | Ranking every mobile game that gave us nostalgia... | 1,800 | |
| 9. | Channel Awesome | Transformers (The 1st Nostalgia Critic Episode!) - Nostalgia Critic | 1,138 | Show |
| 10. | Channel Awesome | The Cat in the Hat (Original Edit) - Nostalgia Critic | 943 | Review |
| 11. | TimTheTatman Two | TIMTHETATMAN REACTS TO THE BEST TRICKSHOTS IN CALL OF DUTY HISTORY | 809 | |
| 12. | Renegades React | Renegades React to... Nostalgia Critic - Star Wars: The Last Jedi | 368 | |
| 13. | El Locon Gamer | PlayStation Classic es un TIMO a la nostalgia | Las compañías se aprovechan de la nostalgia | 322 | Let's Play |
| 14. | IGN | PlayStation Classic Wants Your Nostalgia Dollars - IGN Daily Fix | 299 | Let's Play |
| 15. | Madlittlepixel | Do You Miss Video Game Manuals? Bring Them BACK Or Just Retro Nostalgia? | 284 | Tutorial |
| 16. | theduckgoesmoo | I NEVER HEARD OF THIS MOVIE BEFORE!!! Reacting to "Who Framed Roger Rabbit" - Nostalgia Critic | 252 | |
| 17. | theduckgoesmoo | THIS JUST ISN'T RIGHT!!! Reacting to "Cat in the Hat" by Nostalgia Critic! | 188 | |
| 18. | wallbieswarriors | X-Mas Nostalgia SvR '09 Nintendo Royal Rumble | 186 | |
| 19. | theduckgoesmoo | THE ONLY GODZILLA I KNOW!!! Reacting to "Godzilla (1998)" - Nostalgia Critic | 182 | |
| 20. | arwuns | 2000 TV Commercials - 2000s Commercial Compilation #29 | 162 | |
| 21. | SimplyUnlucky | *RARE* YuGiOh Pharaonic Guardian 2003 Double Blister Pack Opening & Review! Nostalgia is Real | 154 | Review |
| 22. | EmSwizzle | The ULTIMATE Nintendo DS Nostalgia Compilation... | 149 | |
| 23. | theduckgoesmoo | MY FIRST STAR WARS MOVIE EXPERIENCE!! Reacting to "Star Wars Christmas" - Nostalgia Critic | 145 | |
| 24. | Channel Awesome | Spider-Man - Making of Nostalgia Critic | 145 | |
| 25. | Engadget | PlayStation Classic Hands-On: Nostalgia in a box | 116 | Let's Play |
| 26. | Straydog | The FORBIDDEN Gamerscore of Avatar the Burning Earth - Nostalgia Drive | 114 | |
| 27. | theduckgoesmoo | THE WEIRDEST ALADDIN EVER!! Reacting to "The Thief and the Cobbler" - Nostalgia Critic | 95 | |
| 28. | theduckgoesmoo | THE MOST FRUSTRATING GAME EVER?!?! Reacting to "Dragon's Lair" by Nostalgia Critic! | 89 | |
| 29. | theduckgoesmoo | EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS IS CRAZY!! Reacting to "Face Off" - Nostalgia Critic | 82 | |
| 30. | Last Stand Media | Spider-Man (2002 Film) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 179 | 80 | Show |
| 31. | the Nathan NAPALM | MMORPG Chasing the Dragon : Nostalgia & Reality in 2021 | 77 | Discussion |
| 32. | Frost The Hobidon | Frost Reaction: Nostalgia Critic: Spider-man | 76 | |
| 33. | theduckgoesmoo | THAT'S THE PLOT OF SUPERMAN?! Reacting to "Man of Steel" by Nostalgia Critic | 74 | |
| 34. | wavywebsurf | Let's talk about Online Gaming Nostalgia... | 71 | Discussion |
| 35. | NGameTheCube | Nintendo Will Bring Back the DS and Wii In 2022 | 71 | |
| 36. | Madlittlepixel | Milking Retro Nostalgia - Cotton 100% Nintendo Switch Review! | 58 | Review |
| 37. | theduckgoesmoo | HOW BAD CAN IT BE??!! Reacting to "Superman IV" by Nostalgia Critic | 58 | |
| 38. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season One) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 214 | 53 | Show |
| 39. | Pop Culture Cast | 18 Classic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Commercials (Nostalgia Overload) | 52 | |
| 40. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season 8) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 230 | 52 | Show |
| 41. | TheInsaneGamefreak | Nostalgia Rush: Scooby Doo | 48 | |
| 42. | Last Stand Media | The Incredible Hulk (film) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 187 | 40 | Show |
| 43. | Last Stand Media | Top Gun | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 182 | 37 | Show |
| 44. | Master Ryo Sakurai | Old vs New Spider Man Movies - Nostalgia Critic REACTION! Master Ryo Sakurai! | 35 | |
| 45. | Last Stand Media | The Terminator | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 226 | 34 | |
| 46. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season 2) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 216 | 32 | Show |
| 47. | arwuns | Half-Hour of 2002 Comedy Central TV Commercials - 2000s Commercial Compilation #37 | 28 | |
| 48. | WTFLOL | The Last Blockbuster - Concept/Pitch Trailer | 28 | Preview |
| 49. | PixleyLore | Nintendo Nostalgia Trip: Top 10 | 27 | |
| 50. | Last Stand Media | The Star Wars Christmas Special | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 201 | 25 | |
| 51. | Last Stand Media | Labyrinth | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 181 | 25 | Show |
| 52. | Iowa Retro Gamer Dad | Only Kids Born In The 80s And 90s Will Understand These Retro Things | Nostalgia Unlocked | 25 | |
| 53. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season 3) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 218 | 25 | Show |
| 54. | RetroRalphLIVE | Coffee Talk Podcast - Chasing Nostalgia is this Friday - 10/1 @ 6PM PST! | 25 | Let's Play |
| 55. | Master Ryo Sakurai | X2: X Men United: Nostalgia Critic REACTION! Master Ryo Sakurai! | 22 | |
| 56. | Spawn Trapped | A Wave of Nintendo DS Nostalgia is Coming... | 22 | |
| 57. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season 6) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 225 | 21 | Show |
| 58. | Iron Lords Podcast | Michael Mercy | 80's Arcades & Nostalgia | PS5 faster than Xbox Series X? | Phil Spencer in Japan | 20 | |
| 59. | BBT Network | Star Wars Christmas - Nostalgia Critic - Reaction! (BBT) | 19 | |
| 60. | Master Ryo Sakurai | Nostalgia Critic X Men REACTION! Master Ryo Sakurai! | 18 | |
| 61. | Duxativa | NOSTALGIA! The King of Fighters Collection: The Orochi Saga PS5 | 17 | |
| 62. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season 4) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 221 | 17 | Show |
| 63. | Nostalgist | Videogame Nostalgia | 16 | |
| 64. | Just DiVine | NFL Street Eagles Vs Packers|Nostalgia Friday Ep.2 | 15 | |
| 65. | Last Stand Media | Game of Thrones (Season 5) | KnockBack: The Retro and Nostalgia Podcast Episode 223 | 15 | Show |
| 66. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #1 - Skies of Arcadia 2! | 15 | Let's Play |
| 67. | Podcast Now | Spider-Man No Way Home Was Nostalgia Done RIGHT - (Not Nostalgia Bait) | 14 | |
| 68. | Layers of Dylan | The Quest For Nostalgia Episode 1! Yu-gi-oh, PSX, and Gameboy! | 14 | Show |
| 69. | David V. Kimball | Garrett Williamson Interview | music, Melee, composing Metagame doc's soundtrack, and nostalgia | 12 | |
| 70. | ABitOddish | Opening 90's Nostalgia Trading Card Game Packs! Batman Returns?! Dinosaurs?! | 11 | |
| 71. | MrBasic | Golden Freddy Nostalgia | 11 | |
| 72. | PappaTsunami | Early 2000s Gaming Nostalgia! | #shorts #reaction #nostalgia #2000 | 10 | |
| 73. | Stormlight | Stormlight Reacts to: The Mummy - Nostalgia Critic | 10 | |
| 74. | Grotesque | Nostalgic Games I'll Never Stop Playing | 9 | |
| 75. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #32 - Barbarians of Lemuria | 9 | Let's Play |
| 76. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #29 - Ghosts of Atlantis | 9 | Let's Play |
| 77. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #3 - Cruising to Cairo | 8 | Let's Play |
| 78. | Daizoren Gaming | Power Puff Girls: Defenders of Townsville (Part 1) walkthrough | NOSTALGIA!!! | 8 | Walkthrough |
| 79. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #45 - Adventurer's Notebook | 8 | Let's Play |
| 80. | Pixel Bro Lee | Try NOT to Nostalgia for This JRPG! #videogames #shorts #rpg | 8 | |
| 81. | philberto78 | My Top 10 Super Nintendo Games (Ooo nostalgia...) | 8 | |
| 82. | Gamemaster13000 | Ode To Nostalgia(30): Teen Titan Battle Blitz | 8 | |
| 83. | Adventurecoats | 1/2 Price Handheld Video Game! #nostalgia #retro #computer #school #computerlab #oregontrail #games | 8 | |
| 84. | SoulsMidknight | Neo King Dodongo I was not ready 🤣🤣 #zelda #shorts #nostalgia #gaming #gameplay | 8 | |
| 85. | Czms | Nostalgia November day 26 he got beat like a drum #nostalgia #spiderman #didyouknow #tombstone #fit | 7 | |
| 86. | TheNintendo | Nostalgia DS (Nostalgio no Kaze) | 7 | |
| 87. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #41 - Final Boss, Ending, and Review | 7 | Let's Play |
| 88. | SlightlyMorphed | Hot Shots Golf 3 - Part 1 - The Nostalgia Begins | 6 | |
| 89. | Sir Sim-Alot | NEW The Nostalgia Is Real | Ghostbusters Spirits Unleashed First Look | 6 | First Impressions |
| 90. | Murray React and Gaming | The Italian Bootleg Titanic Film - Nostalgia Critic Titanic: The Legend Goes on Reaction | 6 | |
| 91. | Arrrash Live | Chasing Nostalgia is a Dangerous Game | 6 | |
| 92. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #16 - A Mother's Love | 6 | Let's Play |
| 93. | TheEricButts | UNBOXING! ZBOX November 2020 - Nostalgia! - Back to the Future, Batman | 6 | |
| 94. | Lion Loves Unity | #160 Halo 5 2v2! | 6 | |
| 95. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #30 - I Can Show You the World | 6 | Let's Play |
| 96. | J-CARTS ARTS | NOSTALGIA CRITIC REACTION: The Terminator (1984) | 5 | |
| 97. | PolskiHussar | The Nostalgia hits hard with this Star Wars VHS pack #starwars #shorts #vhs #starwarscollector | 5 | |
| 98. | Davidvinc RPGs | Let's Play Nostalgia #2 - Rat Extermination! | 5 | Let's Play |
| 99. | Stormlight | Stormlight Reacts to: Alien vs. Predator - Nostalgia Critic | 5 | |
| 100. | What About | Following Spider-Man Nostalgia Hit, Billy Zane Wants IN On That - Talks Wanting The Phantom Sequel | 5 | |
