| 1. |  SwitchCorner | Pumpkin Jack Switch Review | Halloween Hit? | 76 | Review |
| 2. | cub | Pumpkin Jack (ACTUAL Game Review) [PC] | 67 | Review |
| 3. | SuperkenGaming | Pumpkin Jack Review [PS5, Series X, PS4, Switch, Xbox One, & PC] | 43 | Review |
| 4. | I Dream of Indie Games | Pumpkin Jack - Review (PC, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch) | 42 | Review |
| 5. | Fossil21 Gaming | Pumpkin Jack - Review - PS5 | 13 | Review |
| 6. | Big Retro Show | Let's Play Pumpkin Jack - Pumpkin Jack Gameplay | 11 | Review |
| 7. | Pepp's Picks | Pumpkin Jack Review | Classic 3d platformer | 10 | Review |
| 8. | AGD Gameland | Pumpkin Jack | PC Video Game Review | 9 | Review |
| 9. | Rad Dad Redemption | Pumpkin Jack Review | Xbox One X | 9 | Review |
| 10. | Retro Video Game Pickups | Pumpkin Jack Nintendo Switch Review | 8 | Review |
| 11. | 8BE | Pumpkin Jack on Switch is a SPOOKY SCARY 3D Platformer! | 8-Bit Eric | 7 | Review |
| 12. | Nordic Dovah | Spooky Game For Spooking Month - Pumpkin Jack | 6 | Review |
| 13. | Under The Bun | Pumpkin Jack (Review) - This Game Is Really Good! | 5 | Review |
| 14. | Tench Froast | 5 Platformers Full of Throwback Nostalgia | Toast Bites Reviews Ep 14 (Pumpkin Jack + More) | 4 | Review |
| 15. | InDepth Gaming! | Pumpkin Jack Review on Xbox One | 4 | Review |
| 16. | WarriorDan- Game Reviews and Let's Plays | Is Pumpkin Jack Worth Buying [Pumpkin Jack Review] | 3 | Review |
| 17. | Ashes HQ | Pumpkin Jack - Should I Play? YAY orNAY | 3 | Review |
| 18. | Nordic Dovah | The Great Pumpkin Jack - Pumpkin Jack Part 2 | 3 | Review |
| 19. | pixel. | Pumpkin Jack Gameplay Review (PC | Switch | Xbox One | PS4 PS5) | 3 | Review |
| 20. | MightyNifty | Pumpkin Jack Review | 2 | Review |
| 21. | Nintendo Reviewer | Pumpkin Jack (Switch) Review | 2 | Review |
| 22. | Nordic Dovah | The Crazy Witch In The Forest - Pumpkin Jack Part 3 | 2 | Review |
| 23. | NERF Gaming News | Pumpkin Jack PS5 Review | Game of the Week | The Nerf Report | 1 | Review |
| 24. | Nordic Dovah | The Giant Skeleton - Pumpkin Jack Part 4 | 1 | Review |
| 25. | Nordic Dovah | Gluttony The Slime House - Pumpkin Jack Part 5 | 1 | Review |
| 26. | Grindfest | Pumpkin Jack Review: First Impressions | 1 | Review |
| 27. | Nordic Dovah | The Wizard Will Be Stopped - Pumpkin Jack Ending | 1 | Review |
| 28. | PSVG | Pumpkin Jack Review | 1 | Review |
