| 1. |  8-BitRyan | 5,525,651 | IT'S TIME WE GO FOR THE TRUE ENDING. | Scrutinized | 24:26 |
| 2. | Forsen Plays | 27,302 | Forsen Plays Scrutinized - Part 2 (With Chat) | 1:51:13 |
| 3. | SmackNPie | 15,303 | WARNING: SCARIEST GAME OF 2020? Scrutinized Horror Game by Reflect Studios Adam (Scrutinized Part 1) | 12:58 |
| 4. | Cayle | 2,338 | 5 Horror Games & 5 Horror Movies for This Halloween | 0:00 |
| 5. | Halloween Charlie | 2,155 | TANNER.. THIS ENDS NOW!?! II Scrutinized (Normal Ending) Night 10 | 12:01 |
| 6. | OldmanGamingHD | 1,970 | KEEP ALL THE LIGHTS OR ELSE ? - NIGHT 3 - Scrutinized | 1:42:01 |
| 7. | JumpCrouch | 966 | Scrutinized Review | 6:58 |
| 8. | JAYM | 514 | Horror Games be GIVING ME HEART ISSUES! | 0:00 |
| 9. | AnalyticalAce | 495 | Welcome To The Game 5 YEARS LATER: Does it hold up in 2021? | 17:38 |
| 10. | Super King Andy | 189 | ANXIETY MODE ON! - Scrutinized Gameplay - Part 1 | 15:20 |
| 11. | Koji Plays | 170 | Is the PERFECT RUN still PERFECT?! | Scrutinized - PART 8 | 1:31:16 |
| 12. | Nimm Plays | 121 | Scrutinized nearly gave me a heart attack | 22:39 |
| 13. | TwistyShape | 101 | Peepin' In Yo Windows! - Let's Play: Scrutinized! | 42:31 |
| 14. | Mystic Hatters | 100 | BALDY BOY KIDNAPPED ME! | Scrutinized #2 | 28:41 |
| 15. | Berreta101 | 90 | MOST JUMPSCARES EVER | Scrutinized (Part 1) | 12:17 |
| 16. | Bo55 Fatwod | 48 | GENUINLY TERRIFIED || Scrutinized | 21:43 |
| 17. | Luna's Extras | 35 | Pello, Luna and others suffer through Scrutinized (Full Recording) | 1:46:02 |
| 18. | Domo | 35 | Scrutinized - Live | 1:12:19 |
| 19. | Chris is Loading | 30 | GET OUT OF MY HOUSE!! | Scrutinized | 39:08 |
| 20. | Kiptea | 27 | He's Watches As You Are Working, He's standing By Your Desk. | 0:47 |
| 21. | Dweirdo | 25 | Scrutinized #1 | STRESSED | 57:08 |
| 22. | Absolute Voltz | 13 | THAT JUMPSCARE THO.... // Scrutinized | 14:33 |
