| 1. | Jeremy Jahns | Shutter Island Review | 314,039 | Review |
| 2. |  Popcorn In Bed | SHUTTER ISLAND (2010) | FIRST TIME WATCHING | MOVIE REACTION | 179,224 | Review |
| 3. |  CineBinge | Shutter Island | Canadian First Time Watching | Movie Reaction | Movie Review | Movie Commentary | 73,678 | Review |
| 4. | Reel Rejects | SHUTTER ISLAND (2010) MOVIE REACTION! FIRST TIME WATCHING!! Leonardo Dicaprio | Martin Scorsese | 29,434 | Review |
| 5. | EOM Reacts | Shutter Island (2010) Movie Reaction First Time Watching Review and Commentary - JL | 19,090 | Review |
| 6. | BAN.MAN_ | Shutter Island Review | 100 Days 100 Reviews Edit (4K) | 16,831 | Review |
| 7. | Manny dela Rosa | "SHUTTER ISLAND" MOVIE REVIEW | 12,328 | Review |
| 8. |  REELOAD MEDIA | Shutter Island Hollywood Movie Malayalam Review | Reeload Media | 10,744 | Review |
| 9. | JKB | Shutter Island Review | 8,754 | Review |
| 10. | FrankFreezy | *SHUTTER ISLAND* was so Heartbreaking | MOVIE REACTION | FIRST TIME WATCHING | 2,881 | Review |
| 11. | Adam Does Movies | Shutter Island Review : Movie Feuds ep21 | 657 | Review |
| 12. | Zion Films Co. | Lost in Madness: Exploring the Twists and Turns of Shutter Island. #moviereview #scene #hit | 373 | Review |
| 13. | FlickDirect: Celebrity Interviews & Entertainment | Shutter Island (4K UHD) Review | Home Video Reviews | 246 | Review |
| 14. | Thomas Hadley | Shutter Island Quick Review #shutterisland #leonardodicaprio #moviereview #filmreview #psycological | 209 | Review |
| 15. | Special Mark Productions | Final Cut Review of Shutter Island | 84 | Review |
| 16. | Ian Fitzgerald | Shutter Island Review Ian Fitzgerald the shifting critic | 45 | Review |
| 17. | Matt Playz [GD] | shutter island | Movie Review | 42 | Review |
| 18. | Cinephellas | Shutter Island (2010) - Movie Review **31 Days of Horror** | 40 | Review |
| 19. |  Movie Burner Entertainment | Shutter Island - Retro Movie Review | 30 | Review |
| 20. | Inways Variety Channel | Joe and The Boyo Review Shutter Island | 15 | Review |
| 21. | Keiynu | Shutter Island - Movie Review | 14 | Review |
| 22. | The MAA Show | Shutter Island Review (HOW A GOOD TWIST CAN HELP A MOVIE) | 14 | Review |
| 23. | RobChar Reviews | Rob Char's Reviews: Shutter Island (2010) | 9 | Review |
| 24. | MrKARproductions | Shutter Island (2010) Movie Review | 6 | Review |
| 25. | The CakeMen Entertainment | Why Shutter Island Is Amazing! - Shutter Island Movie Review! | 5 | Review |
| 26. | TheTexasMan | Shutter Island Full Review | 5 | Review |
| 27. | Unique Movie Review | Shutter Island Full Movie Facts and Review | Leonardo DiCaprio | Mark Ruffalo | Ben Kingsley | 4 | Review |
| 28. | The Campy Company | Fenn Recommends... Ep. 124: Shutter Island | 4 | Review |
| 29. | Mia on Movies | Shutter Island (2010) review | 3 | Review |
| 30. | Adam Sager | Movie review: "Shutter Island"!!! | 2 | Review |
