| 1. |  Cinemassacre | 309,306 | Superman 64 (Nintendo 64) Full Playthrough w/ Mike Matei | 4:07:25 |
| 2. | RoyalPear | 266,577 | I Played the WORST Video Games | 10:01 |
| 3. | Cinemassacre Clips | 202,290 | Superman 64 (N64) Part 8 - END OF GAME!! Cinemassacre Plays | 1:17:35 |
| 4. | Geek & Sundry | 139,050 | Superman - Retro Let's Play: Co-Optitude Ep 44 | 12:40 |
| 5. | Kinda Funny Games | 61,550 | Let's Play Superman 64 (Worst Game of All-Time) - Throwback Thursdays | 16:59 |
| 6. | GameRaveTV | 24,488 | Superman PSX Prototype Full "Let's Play" | GameRaveTV Ep. 114-B | 1:29:08 |
| 7. | RedFalconGames | 19,013 | Let's Play Superman 64: Finale - Rage Quit | 6:03 |
| 8. | Retro Pals | 15,943 | Unreleased PS1 Games: Alphas + Prototypes | 41:20 |
| 9. | The Charity Room | 15,381 | SomecallmeJohnny Plays Superman 64 For Charity | 'Superman 64' - License to Chill | 6:20:16 |
| 10. | OKeijiDragon | 12,911 | (Part 3) Superman [Unreleased PlayStation version] | June 22, 2000 Prototype | 3:51 |
| 11. | StephenPlays | 6,068 | Semi-Soft Noodle | 0:38 |
| 12. | KwingsLetsPlays | 3,727 | Superman The Musical 🎶 Part 1 #Shorts | 0:50 |
| 13. | KitaNashGaming | 3,317 | Tricking My Husband into Playing Superman 64 | 11:25 |
| 14. | 4-8Productions | 2,246 | death Plays Superman 64 [4-8Live] | 38:30 |
| 15. | elison | 1,650 | Let's Play Superman 64 - FINALE !!! | 1:11:40 |
| 16. | GamerThumbTV | 798 | Superman (Unreleased PS1 Version) | Parasite Plays Tag | 0:46 |
| 17. | Wizardman | 582 | Superman (PS1): Superman on the Playstation is actually good! No Superman 64 here! [PS1 Project] | 3:40:25 |
| 18. | Refle18 | 348 | I know Let's Play a bad game- Superman 64 | 19:04 |
| 19. | The Satellite | 316 | Superman 64 Blind Playthrough (Livestream) - Incomplete, and rightly so. | 1:56:52 |
| 20. | Joe Nostalgia | 191 | Let's Play Superman 64 | 15:23 |
| 21. | Kratos Aurion Plays | 150 | Kratos plays Superman 64: Too many rings! | 22:54 |
| 22. | Bossrosslp | 143 | Stupid Games Saturday Episode 50: Superman 64!?!? | 23:51 |
| 23. | TheSuperzemus | 123 | Let's Play Superman 64 Episode 1 - Jumping Through Hoops | 13:47 |
| 24. | 2-Bit Players | 105 | Let's Play Superman 64 | I Resent Getting Better at This Game | 2-Bit Players SUCK! | 13:56 |
| 25. | Common Goblin Gaming | 101 | Is This Really the Worst Game Ever? | Superman 64 (Nintendo 64, Retro Videogame Let's Play) | 14:36 |
| 26. | Sephiroth1204 | 81 | Let's Play Superman 64 #1 - #LexWins | 27:28 |
| 27. | RayneKisaragi | 75 | Let's Play Superman 64 Part 1 - The man of steel | 7:47 |
| 28. | GameEnthus | 39 | GameEnthus Crew Plays: Superman64 - EnthusPlays++ #Superman64 #Retrotink | 25:18 |
| 29. | Alphamega Zulu | 27 | Superman 64 | W/Friends | Part 4 | THE MALEVOLENT MALA | 10:15 |
| 30. | WillPendingPermanent | 23 | This was a horrible idea - Superman 64 Blind Race! With friends! (WillPending 06/12/2020) | 3:05:01 |
| 31. | Da Hubbz | 20 | Jessica Plays Superman 64 | 29:38 |
| 32. | Geeks and Nerds | 5 | Pablo Plays - Various Licensed Media NES Games | 31:10 |
| 33. | Mustached Tom | 4 | Mustached Tom Plays Superman | 14:24 |
