| 1. |  SalvoG | FIRST TIME HEARING Joe Cocker - When The Night Comes (Live) | REACTION | 54 | |
| 2. | Clawzy | TERRIFYING DEVILS RITUAL [When Night Comes #1] | 25 | |
| 3. | ordinarydreamer | When The Night Comes - PLAYTHROUGH | 22 | |
| 4. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes (Part 1) SWOONING!! | 12 | |
| 5. | TellTaleHeart | August's Route! - When the Night Comes Part 21 | 9 | Let's Play |
| 6. | TellTaleHeart | Finn's Pajamas - When the Night Comes Part 20 | 8 | Let's Play |
| 7. | TellTaleHeart | Disrupting the Hot Chocolate Industry for Omen - When the Night Comes Part 10 | 7 | Let's Play |
| 8. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes! (Part 4) Chapter Two!! | 6 | |
| 9. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes! (Part 6) Creepy Twins!! | 6 | |
| 10. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes! (Part 8) END OF CHAPTER TWO! | 5 | |
| 11. | TellTaleHeart | Furry Scum and Tail Piercings - When the Night Comes Part 2 | 5 | Let's Play |
| 12. | TellTaleHeart | Fantasy HR - When the Night Comes Part 3 | 5 | Let's Play |
| 13. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes! (Part 5) Case Details!! | 5 | |
| 14. | TellTaleHeart | Help From the Clan - When the Night Comes Part 15 | 4 | Let's Play |
| 15. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes! (Part 3) Meeting Everyone! | 4 | |
| 16. | TellTaleHeart | Sexy Muppets - When the Night Comes Part 6 | 4 | Let's Play |
| 17. | TellTaleHeart | Piper Ruins Christmas - When the Night Comes Part 8 | 4 | Let's Play |
| 18. | Simply Freckled | When the Night Comes! (Part 2) August!! | 4 | |
| 19. | BalimoreBlindGaming | A DARK CHANT TO CALL IT FORTH... | LET'S PLAY - WHEN NIGHT COMES | FULL GAME | 4 | Let's Play |
| 20. | TellTaleHeart | Shrimpy and Purple Dracula - When the Night Comes Part 1 | 4 | Let's Play |
| 21. | TellTaleHeart | Taking the Lead with Ezra - When the Night Comes Part 9 | 3 | Let's Play |
| 22. | TellTaleHeart | A Dong Listance Relationship - When The Night Comes Part 14 | 3 | Let's Play |
| 23. | TellTaleHeart | A Light at the End of the Tunnel - When the Night Comes Part 16 | 3 | Let's Play |
| 24. | Crystal Dreams | When the Night Comes - Chapter 4 (Finn) | 3 | |
| 25. | TellTaleHeart | August’s route tho 😳 #shorts #wtnc | 3 | Let's Play |
| 26. | TellTaleHeart | The One With Accents! - When the Night Comes Part 4 | 3 | Let's Play |
| 27. | TellTaleHeart | A Magical Evening with August - When the Night Comes Part 12 | 2 | Let's Play |
| 28. | Jam In The Van | CLEAR PLASTIC MASKS - "When the Night Comes" (Live in Austin, TX 2014) | 2 | |
| 29. | AgentofMischief Productions | When The Night Comes FINALE - Finn's Route | 2 | |
| 30. | TellTaleHeart | Cat(boy)nip - When The Night Comes Part 5 | 2 | Let's Play |
| 31. | AgentofMischief Productions | When The Night Comes Episode 15 - Finn's Route | 2 | |
| 32. | MTA Broadcasting | It was in the closet the whole time!?!?!? | After Stream - Playthrough | 2 | Let's Play |
| 33. | TellTaleHeart | Our Triumphant Return! - When the Night Comes Part 17 | 2 | Let's Play |
| 34. | TellTaleHeart | This B🐶tch Said "Laterz" - When the Night Comes Part 7 | 2 | Let's Play |
| 35. | AgentofMischief Productions | When The Night Comes #1 - The Red Foreman Method - Ezra's Route | 1 | |
| 36. | Ddog Plays Games | CREEPY TWINS | 2 | When The Night Comes | 1 | |
| 37. | AgentofMischief Productions | When The Night Comes Episode 16 - Finn's Route | 1 | |
| 38. | TellTaleHeart | I should not be allowed to play dating sims #shorts #otomegame | 1 | |
| 39. | Jestana Silvercoat | When the Night Comes - Piper Romance - Chapter Three | 1 | |
| 40. | ChorpSaway | When the Night Comes - Stream 1 (Date☆Night: 11/23/21) | 1 | |
| 41. | TellTaleHeart | F🌙ck Around and Find Out - When The Night Comes Part 18 | 1 | Let's Play |
| 42. | TellTaleHeart | Meeting Elaine - When The Night Comes Part 19 | 1 | Let's Play |
| 43. | TellTaleHeart | Meeting August 😳 #shorts #wtncgame | 1 | |
| 44. | Vinicitie Sunlite | When The Night Comes [Visual Novel Reading] - Part 1 | 1 | |
| 45. | ChorpSaway | When the Night Comes - Stream 4 (Date☆Night: 12/28/21) | 1 | |
| 46. | AgentofMischief Productions | When The Night Comes Episode 1 | 1 | |
