Jubilee Fascist Confronted on Immigration in Heated Debate
18Discord: https://discord.com/invite/rbrNz6YdVB
Nonfon debates a far-right MAGA conservative who recently appeared on Jubilee's new Surrounded episode: "1 Progressive vs 20 Far-Right Conservatives (ft. Mehdi Hasan)". They discuss his statements made on Jubilee about immigration. Specifically, immigrants impact on wages in both the long and short term. Immigrants' impact on wages within occupations compared to their overall impact. If immigrants have an overall negative effect on culture. If immigrants pose a national security threat. The effects of H1b visas on wages, innovation, and culture. As well as general social cohesion effects, immigrants may have.
▼ Follow Me EVERYWHERE ▼
► Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/nonfon420
► Twitter/X: https://x.com/nonfon420
► Blue Sky: https://bsky.app/profile/nonfon.bsky.social
► Kick: https://kick.com/nonfon420
► Rumble: https://rumble.com/user/Nonfon
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nonfon420
► YouTube:
► Clips & memes channel: / @nonfonclips
► Trovo: https://trovo.live/s/Nonfon
► Discord: https://discord.com/invite/rbrNz6YdVB
00:00 Intro
01:10 Initial Disagreements on Immigration
02:24 Immigration's Impact on Wages: Winners, Losers, and Long-Term Effects
05:04 Internal Migration and Spatial Analysis Limitations
06:37 Critiques of Mariel Boatlift Studies and Aggregation Issues
09:50 Spillover Effects and Consumer Prices
15:13 Purchasing Power and Wage Decline
17:50 Demographic Shifts and Sectoral Competition
28:17 Production, Bargaining Power, and Unionization
30:23 Social Cohesion, Welfare State, and Cultural Concerns
36:20 Immigration and Crime Rates
44:39 Innovation and Demographics
1:01:12 National Security and Skilled Immigrants
1:08:35 Cultural Problems with Elite Immigrants
1:29:04 Concluding Thoughts: Economic vs. Cultural Priorities and Future Debates
This video unpacks a contentious debate on immigration's multi-faceted impacts, starting with a core disagreement: is it "good for the economy"? It immediately questions *how much immigrants lower wages* and if they pose a "net negative". While "winners and losers" are acknowledged, one side posits an "overall benefit," citing studies showing "negligible" or even positive long-term wage impacts.
However, others highlight *significant negative impacts in specific sectors* like construction. Critiques target "spatial analysis" and "aggregation" in studies (e.g., Mariel Boatlift), arguing immigrants cluster in "very specific low-skilled sectors," requiring focused analysis on direct competition. Borjas's "perfect substitution" assumption is also questioned.
Debated benefits include lower consumer prices and increased employment. Yet, concerns arise over **decreased purchasing power for low-wage workers**, framed as "redistribution from the bottom up". The potential for government policy (like subsidies) to mediate economic issues, rather than immigration, is also raised. Crucially, it's asserted that much opposition to immigration is "mostly a social social cultural issue," driven by aversion to "brown people".
#Debate #Politics #Economics #news #EconomicPolicy #ImmigrationDebate #Economics #SocialImpact #CulturalImpact #Wages #LaborMarket #Innovation #CrimeRates #SocialCohesion #PolicyDiscussion #PoliticalEconomy #Demographics #NationalSecurity #H1BVisa #PostKeynesian #RaceRealism #Globalization #USImmigration #trump #border #jubilee #mehdihasan #immigration