What Makes a Paper Mario Game Great?
42The Paper Mario series is one of Nintendo’s most unique and polarizing franchises. Originally celebrated for its clever writing, turn-based combat, and charming RPG mechanics, the series has taken dramatic shifts in direction over the years. In this in-depth video, we ask the core question: What makes a Paper Mario game great? From the genre-defining classics to the more divisive modern entries, we break down the evolution of this iconic Mario spin-off and explore what fans love—and hate—about the changes Nintendo has made.
We’ll take a look at every major Paper Mario game, including:
Paper Mario 64 – the N64 RPG that started it all
Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door – often regarded as the best Paper Mario game ever made
Super Paper Mario – a bold shift into action-platforming and storytelling
Sticker Star – the most controversial entry in the series
Color Splash – a visually stunning but polarizing Wii U title
The Origami King – a modern Switch entry that sparked fresh debate among fans
Whether you prefer the traditional RPG style of the early games or you enjoy the action-adventure mechanics of the newer titles, this video is for you. We’ll analyze gameplay mechanics, character design, world-building, story depth, humor, partner systems, and battle mechanics. We'll also explore how nostalgia and personal gaming history affect our perception of what makes a Paper Mario game “good.”
This isn’t just a tier list or ranking—it’s a thoughtful discussion about the history of Paper Mario, Nintendo's creative decisions, and the future of the series, especially with the upcoming Nintendo Switch 2 on the horizon. Could a brand new Paper Mario game be coming soon? And if it is, what should it look like?
🧠 Join the conversation by leaving your thoughts in the comments! What’s your favorite Paper Mario game and why? Do you prefer the classic RPG formula or the newer action-adventure approach?
📢 Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and hit the notification bell for more deep dives into Nintendo games, Mario RPG retrospectives, and all things Paper Mario.
Paper Mario, best Paper Mario game, history of Paper Mario, Paper Mario series analysis, Nintendo RPGs, Mario RPG, Switch RPGs, The Thousand-Year Door, Paper Mario 64, Super Paper Mario, Sticker Star, Color Splash, Origami King, Nintendo Switch games, Switch 2 games, upcoming Nintendo games, Paper Mario combat, Paper Mario partners, Mario story games, turn-based RPGs, Paper Mario opinions, Paper Mario timeline, Nintendo franchise evolution
#PaperMario #nintendoswitch2 #PaperMario64 #ThousandYearDoor #OrigamiKing #ColorSplash #StickerStar #NintendoSwitch #MarioRPG #MarioGames #PaperMarioRetrospective #NintendoAnalysis
@stillbrokemoses edited this
Thank you for watching Game Domain! Subscribe here hhttp://bit.ly/2c2M2Ix
Support us on Patreon: hhttps://www.patreon.com/user?u=2800249Join our Discord: https://discord.gg/BJvjKMsFollow us on X: https://twitter.com/realgamedomain
Follow us on Insta: https://www.instagram.com/realgamedomain/
Checkout our Rankings series: hhttps://bit.ly/2oqUJIaCheckout our Top 10s: hhttps://bit.ly/3Ructw2Checkout our Best Mario Videos: hhttps://bit.ly/4jkPWxPCheckout our Documentaries: hhttps://bit.ly/4iKVhOS
Some of our personal favorite videos:
Top 10 Nintendo Switch Games: • Top 10 BEST Nintendo Switch Games
Ranking Every Mario RPG: • Ranking EVERY Mario RPG (2025)
Mario & Luigi Documentary: • The Complete History of the Mario & L...
Ranking EVERY Zelda Game: • Ranking The Legend of Zelda Games (Al...
New Super Mario Bros Documentary: • New Super Mario Bros - Documentary
Pikmin Documentary: • The History of Pikmin - Documentary
For any press inquiries, or sponsorship questions, please email gamedomainbiz@gmail.com
For any collaboration request, DM us on X, Discord or send an email.
Film Domain: / @filmdomain
Other Videos By Game Domain
Other Statistics
Paper Mario Statistics For Game Domain
Game Domain presently has 165,230 views for Paper Mario across 22 videos, and about 7 hours worth of Paper Mario videos were uploaded to his channel. This makes up 3.66% of the content that Game Domain has uploaded to YouTube.