| 1. | Dungeon Lords | 13,714 | 18.85% | 46 | 1:20:06:34 |
| 2. | Super Mario Bros. | 9,466 | 13.01% | 71 | 3:06:15:25 |
| 3. | SpongeBob SquarePants: Lights, Camera, Pants! | 5,101 | 7.01% | 7 | 4:15:56 |
| 4. | Hollow Knight | 3,188 | 4.38% | 44 | 1:20:27:13 |
| 5. | Super Mario World | 3,056 | 4.20% | 20 | 1:04:43:52 |
| 6. | Super Mario Bros 3: Mario Forever | 2,741 | 3.77% | 26 | 16:05:18 |
| 7. | Sonic Heroes | 2,155 | 2.96% | 29 | 1:01:19:00 |
| 8. | Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island | 1,990 | 2.73% | 20 | 21:33:00 |
| 9. | Sonic Unleashed | 1,349 | 1.85% | 18 | 18:28:25 |
| 10. | The Saboteur | 1,205 | 1.66% | 43 | 22:27:00 |
| 11. | Wizards & Warriors | 1,161 | 1.60% | 3 | 2:28:07 |
| 12. | Sonic Adventure DX: Director's Cut | 1,095 | 1.50% | 26 | 13:42:50 |
| 13. | Wario Land 4 | 898 | 1.23% | 11 | 6:57:38 |
| 14. | Metro: Exodus | 865 | 1.19% | 31 | 1:18:24:43 |
| 15. | Metroid II: Return of Samus | 843 | 1.16% | 11 | 12:24:45 |
| 16. | Borderlands 3 | 773 | 1.06% | 61 | 2:04:53:28 |
| 17. | Shantae | 562 | 0.77% | 12 | 8:30:03 |
| 18. | The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth | 514 | 0.71% | 14 | 11:47:40 |
| 19. | New Super Mario Bros. Wii | 399 | 0.55% | 9 | 4:41:09 |
| 20. | Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy | 391 | 0.54% | 19 | 9:23:37 |
| 21. | Mass Effect 2 | 386 | 0.53% | 29 | 1:01:04:48 |
| 22. | Amnesia: The Dark Descent | 367 | 0.50% | 29 | 1:04:01:46 |
| 23. | Cry of Fear | 357 | 0.49% | 18 | 10:43:20 |
| 24. | Darksiders III | 355 | 0.49% | 17 | 21:58:20 |
| 25. | Home Sweet Home: Episode II | 348 | 0.48% | 7 | 5:48:19 |
| 26. | Half-Life | 343 | 0.47% | 15 | 11:04:32 |
| 27. | Full Pipe | 327 | 0.45% | 6 | 4:28:36 |
| 28. | Shantae: Risky's Revenge | 323 | 0.44% | 14 | 5:58:57 |
| 29. | Mass Effect | 320 | 0.44% | 24 | 1:05:03:55 |
| 30. | Deadly Premonition | 305 | 0.42% | 25 | 18:49:03 |
| 31. | Shadow the Hedgehog | 291 | 0.40% | 8 | 3:55:07 |
| 32. | Noita | 257 | 0.35% | 10 | 6:54:20 |
| 33. | A Plague Tale: Innocence | 255 | 0.35% | 14 | 19:01:40 |
| 34. | Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins | 252 | 0.35% | 2 | 56:06 |
| 35. | Super Meat Boy | 240 | 0.33% | 7 | 4:59:27 |
| 36. | Outlast | 226 | 0.31% | 14 | 8:37:41 |
| 37. | Duke Nukem 3D | 216 | 0.30% | 5 | 3:27:29 |
| 38. | Pathologic 2 | 215 | 0.30% | 6 | 19:18:19 |
| 39. | Layers of Fear | 213 | 0.29% | 8 | 7:42:19 |
| 40. | Counter-Strike: Condition Zero | 209 | 0.29% | 3 | 1:14:40 |
| 41. | Doom | 190 | 0.26% | 5 | 8:22:51 |
| 42. | Horror Girls | 186 | 0.26% | 4 | 1:33:59 |
| 43. | Legendary | 184 | 0.25% | 8 | 6:50:13 |
| 44. | DreadOut | 182 | 0.25% | 10 | 6:33:26 |
| 45. | Penumbra: Black Plague | 167 | 0.23% | 9 | 10:52:07 |
| 46. | Krampus is Home | 160 | 0.22% | 9 | 5:55:10 |
| 47. | Super Mario Land | 159 | 0.22% | 1 | 1:09:24 |
| 48. | Katana Zero | 142 | 0.20% | 5 | 4:05:45 |
| 49. | Tasty Planet Forever | 134 | 0.18% | 6 | 4:36:55 |
| 50. | Call of Cthulhu | 122 | 0.17% | 9 | 9:56:09 |
| 51. | Chop is Dish | 116 | 0.16% | 2 | 1:02:15 |
| 52. | Spark in the Dark | 114 | 0.16% | 1 | 1:01:04 |
| 53. | U.F.O.s | 108 | 0.15% | 4 | 2:46:27 |
| 54. | Unravel | 106 | 0.15% | 11 | 9:36:01 |
| 55. | Slender: The Arrival | 94 | 0.13% | 2 | 53:27 |
| 56. | Sinner: Sacrifice for Redemption | 84 | 0.12% | 2 | 39:54 |
| 57. | Need for Speed Payback | 84 | 0.12% | 2 | 3:23:26 |
| 58. | Assassin's Creed Chronicles | 72 | 0.10% | 5 | 4:02:21 |
| 59. | The Baby In Yellow | 67 | 0.09% | 1 | 32:24 |
| 60. | Penumbra: Requiem | 54 | 0.07% | 5 | 5:54:41 |
| 61. | Penumbra: Overture | 38 | 0.05% | 1 | 1:45:16 |
| 62. | Home Sweet Home | 32 | 0.04% | 1 | 40:26 |
| 63. | Metro: Last Light | 27 | 0.04% | 1 | 56:18 |
| 64. | SCP-087 | 23 | 0.03% | 1 | 24:50 |
| 65. | Doom II: Hell on Earth | 16 | 0.02% | 1 | 32:19 |
