| 1. | Silent Hill 2 | 388,059 | 8.97% | 50 | 1:02:41:50 |
| 2. | Silent Hill: Shattered Memories | 316,956 | 7.33% | 66 | 21:18:14 |
| 3. | The Nightmare Before Christmas: Oogie's Revenge | 212,630 | 4.91% | 52 | 13:03:19 |
| 4. | Silent Hill | 209,809 | 4.85% | 60 | 1:17:05:42 |
| 5. | Silent Hill 3 | 182,593 | 4.22% | 39 | 20:51:28 |
| 6. | Undertale | 155,757 | 3.60% | 11 | 13:19:24 |
| 7. | Silent Hill: The Arcade | 86,360 | 2.00% | 5 | 1:07:46 |
| 8. | Night in the Woods | 82,689 | 1.91% | 35 | 17:47:46 |
| 9. | Silent Hill: Origins | 81,070 | 1.87% | 31 | 6:04:23 |
| 10. | Stardew Valley | 80,122 | 1.85% | 60 | 1:15:47:47 |
| 11. | Yooka-Laylee | 69,872 | 1.61% | 33 | 17:57:52 |
| 12. | Final Fantasy VII | 67,645 | 1.56% | 17 | 2:12:59:59 |
| 13. | Final Fantasy IX | 56,548 | 1.31% | 19 | 2:16:14:32 |
| 14. | Sanitarium | 54,720 | 1.26% | 15 | 7:44:24 |
| 15. | Phantasmagoria: A Puzzle of Flesh | 47,939 | 1.11% | 8 | 14:50:46 |
| 16. | Life Is Strange | 41,632 | 0.96% | 12 | 18:31:13 |
| 17. | Spyro: Year of the Dragon | 39,422 | 0.91% | 17 | 9:13:24 |
| 18. | Toonstruck | 39,349 | 0.91% | 11 | 5:40:07 |
| 19. | Doki Doki Literature Club! | 36,900 | 0.85% | 12 | 6:23:08 |
| 20. | Alone in the Dark | 36,665 | 0.85% | 6 | 16:57:55 |
| 21. | Overcooked | 36,010 | 0.83% | 11 | 5:58:41 |
| 22. | Black Mesa | 35,989 | 0.83% | 27 | 14:21:41 |
| 23. | Banjo-Kazooie | 35,346 | 0.82% | 15 | 8:23:54 |
| 24. | Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage! | 35,107 | 0.81% | 14 | 9:51:43 |
| 25. | The Walking Dead | 32,918 | 0.76% | 13 | 19:35:52 |
| 26. | Resident Evil: Revelations | 32,694 | 0.76% | 20 | 10:12:56 |
| 27. | Overcooked! 2 | 32,328 | 0.75% | 24 | 16:16:51 |
| 28. | The Evil Within 2 | 31,849 | 0.74% | 34 | 23:51:48 |
| 29. | The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth | 31,341 | 0.72% | 39 | 1:06:37:59 |
| 30. | Prey | 30,771 | 0.71% | 41 | 23:18:02 |
| 31. | Frog Fractions 2 | 28,644 | 0.66% | 9 | 5:46:24 |
| 32. | Cook, Serve, Delicious! 2!! | 28,625 | 0.66% | 36 | 20:55:11 |
| 33. | Resident Evil 2 | 26,854 | 0.62% | 7 | 19:19:20 |
| 34. | Cook, Serve, Delicious! | 25,721 | 0.59% | 14 | 7:37:45 |
| 35. | I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream | 25,363 | 0.59% | 6 | 7:24:34 |
| 36. | Silent Hill: Downpour | 24,694 | 0.57% | 13 | 12:24:19 |
| 37. | Portal 2 | 23,413 | 0.54% | 16 | 9:03:15 |
| 38. | Psychonauts 2 | 22,959 | 0.53% | 8 | 1:05:30:29 |
| 39. | Alan Wake | 22,800 | 0.53% | 10 | 21:39:29 |
| 40. | Saw | 22,197 | 0.51% | 10 | 6:09:05 |
| 41. | Garry's Mod | 21,472 | 0.50% | 5 | 6:38:37 |
| 42. | Resident Evil 5 | 20,986 | 0.49% | 9 | 5:31:42 |
| 43. | Soma | 20,009 | 0.46% | 8 | 10:22:15 |
| 44. | Immortality | 19,326 | 0.45% | 2 | 9:25:13 |
| 45. | Sonic Mania | 19,023 | 0.44% | 11 | 6:05:05 |
| 46. | Dark Souls | 18,847 | 0.44% | 1 | 1:55 |
| 47. | Slime Rancher | 18,346 | 0.42% | 17 | 9:54:16 |
| 48. | The Medium | 17,790 | 0.41% | 4 | 10:29:07 |
| 49. | The Talos Principle | 17,725 | 0.41% | 20 | 18:09:50 |
| 50. | Kathy Rain | 17,523 | 0.40% | 11 | 6:13:46 |
| 51. | Half-Life 2 | 17,250 | 0.40% | 3 | 6:30:41 |
| 52. | Silent Hill: Homecoming | 17,105 | 0.40% | 5 | 5:04:09 |
| 53. | Silent Hill 4: The Room | 17,032 | 0.39% | 3 | 11:07:14 |
| 54. | Zero Time Dilemma | 15,878 | 0.37% | 8 | 22:14:03 |
| 55. | Psychonauts | 15,859 | 0.37% | 7 | 19:31:08 |
| 56. | Hypnospace Outlaw | 15,393 | 0.36% | 5 | 11:05:39 |
| 57. | Parasite Eve | 14,975 | 0.35% | 5 | 13:45:02 |
| 58. | The Evil Within | 14,709 | 0.34% | 6 | 10:15:48 |
| 59. | Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale | 14,513 | 0.34% | 6 | 6:18:30 |
| 60. | Spyro Reignited Trilogy | 13,909 | 0.32% | 11 | 10:11:28 |
| 61. | Firewatch | 13,291 | 0.31% | 6 | 4:53:33 |
| 62. | Drawful 2 | 13,168 | 0.30% | 6 | 4:10:25 |
| 63. | Back in 1995 | 12,772 | 0.30% | 4 | 2:19:54 |
| 64. | Detention | 12,191 | 0.28% | 5 | 3:02:42 |
| 65. | Inscryption | 11,624 | 0.27% | 6 | 17:50:49 |
| 66. | Celeste | 11,226 | 0.26% | 19 | 10:09:10 |
| 67. | The Sexy Brutale | 11,211 | 0.26% | 11 | 6:04:39 |
| 68. | Uncanny Valley | 11,177 | 0.26% | 5 | 2:18:56 |
| 69. | The Wolf Among Us | 10,992 | 0.25% | 5 | 8:13:45 |
| 70. | Oxenfree | 10,417 | 0.24% | 8 | 4:16:21 |
| 71. | Wolfenstein: The New Order | 10,334 | 0.24% | 5 | 10:10:31 |
| 72. | Phasmophobia | 9,712 | 0.22% | 4 | 9:07:45 |
| 73. | Dropsy | 9,321 | 0.22% | 4 | 4:13:11 |
| 74. | The Turing Test | 9,266 | 0.21% | 10 | 6:31:17 |
| 75. | Layers of Fear 2 | 9,251 | 0.21% | 6 | 8:25:22 |
| 76. | Amnesia: Rebirth | 9,249 | 0.21% | 8 | 11:59:43 |
| 77. | The Sims 3 | 9,115 | 0.21% | 12 | 6:36:35 |
| 78. | Tomb Raider | 8,675 | 0.20% | 2 | 15:53 |
| 79. | Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number | 8,536 | 0.20% | 6 | 9:56:47 |
| 80. | Puzzle Agent | 8,504 | 0.20% | 8 | 4:12:48 |
| 81. | The Jackbox Party Pack 5 | 8,480 | 0.20% | 4 | 2:32:02 |
| 82. | Scorn | 8,340 | 0.19% | 3 | 5:49:19 |
| 83. | Costume Quest 2 | 8,313 | 0.19% | 7 | 9:02:31 |
| 84. | Passpartout: The Starving Artist | 8,219 | 0.19% | 7 | 4:08:56 |
| 85. | The Missing: J.J. Macfield and the Island of Memories | 8,043 | 0.19% | 9 | 5:30:59 |
| 86. | Jenny LeClue: Detectivú | 7,947 | 0.18% | 5 | 10:42:04 |
| 87. | Super Mario RPG | 7,792 | 0.18% | 4 | 9:24:37 |
| 88. | 2064: Read Only Memories | 7,461 | 0.17% | 6 | 6:42:22 |
| 89. | Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs | 7,441 | 0.17% | 3 | 5:46:35 |
| 90. | Paradise Killer | 7,347 | 0.17% | 6 | 16:44:57 |
| 91. | Telling Lies | 7,293 | 0.17% | 2 | 6:29:24 |
| 92. | Fallout 2 | 7,073 | 0.16% | 3 | 3:06:52 |
| 93. | Twelve Minutes | 7,072 | 0.16% | 2 | 4:22:40 |
| 94. | Civilization V | 7,070 | 0.16% | 3 | 5:54:07 |
| 95. | Stories Untold | 6,904 | 0.16% | 6 | 3:06:56 |
| 96. | Tropico 4 | 6,850 | 0.16% | 3 | 5:54:34 |
| 97. | Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light | 6,841 | 0.16% | 3 | 6:24:53 |
| 98. | Little Nightmares | 6,372 | 0.15% | 4 | 4:22:59 |
| 99. | Yume Nikki | 6,334 | 0.15% | 6 | 3:12:36 |
| 100. | Tropico 5 | 6,232 | 0.14% | 5 | 3:36:46 |
