| 1. | Sports | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep15 | 11 | Show |
|
| 2. | A Scroll Through Twitter | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep21 | 9 | Show |
|
| 3. | Pilot Episode | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep1 | 9 | Show |
|
| 4. | "Controversial" takes | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep13 | 6 | Show | Counter-Strike: Source
|
| 5. | Brain Rot | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep109 | 6 | |
|
| 6. | :) | 5 | |
|
| 7. | Dreams and Cyborgs | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep2 | 5 | Show |
|
| 8. | McDonald's vs Burger King | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep129 | 5 | |
|
| 9. | Caleb: The Gambling Fool | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep121 | 5 | |
|
| 10. | Animals are Cool | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep20 | 5 | Show |
|
| 11. | Summertime Memories | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep11 | 4 | Show |
|
| 12. | NIGHT AT THE PARK | 4 | |
|
| 13. | The Great Mistake | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep14 | 4 | Show |
|
| 14. | The Pod from the Garage | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep5 | 4 | Show |
|
| 15. | Just a Couple of Peeps and their Memories | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep49 | 4 | Show |
|
| 16. | Stupid Injuries | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep114 | 4 | |
|
| 17. | Man Vs. Bloodlust Beast | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep7 | 4 | Show |
|
| 18. | Eggin on The Fights | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 13 | 4 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 19. | That's Just A Theory | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep93 | 3 | |
|
| 20. | The Kahoot From Hell | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep52 | 3 | Show |
|
| 21. | Demons Hate This Episode | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep28 | 3 | Show |
|
| 22. | Let Jimmi Take Over | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 14 | 3 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 23. | School: Part 3 | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep127 | 3 | |
|
| 24. | The Nether Sucks | Caleb and Alex play Minecraft Ep 12 | 3 | | Minecraft
|
| 25. | The Fashionable and the Musically Challenged | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep12 | 3 | Show |
|
| 26. | School: Part 1 | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep125 | 3 | |
|
| 27. | Onward to Petalburg | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 3 | 3 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 28. | The Couch Co-op Episode | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep23 | 3 | Show |
|
| 29. | THE HOT WINGS STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN CHALLENGE | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep9 | 3 | Show |
|
| 30. | Times Are Changing | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep95 | 3 | |
|
| 31. | Guilty Pleasures | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep69 | 3 | Show |
|
| 32. | This Episode Won't Age Poorly | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep119 | 3 | |
|
| 33. | Who Knows Who Best | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep26 | 3 | Show |
|
| 34. | Down With Doopliss | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 22 | 2 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 35. | Caleb's Guide To Listening To Podcasts (And Making Friends) | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep73 | 2 | Show |
|
| 36. | Totally Oblivious Plus | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep108 | 2 | |
|
| 37. | The Boys Build Legos | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep10 | 2 | Show |
|
| 38. | Dead Internet Theory | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep105 | 2 | |
|
| 39. | Based Ben | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep36 | 2 | Show |
|
| 40. | Roid Rage | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 17 | 2 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 41. | Caleb's cat goes to Cuba with Tupac | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep3 | 2 | Show |
|
| 42. | The Ghosts of Creepy Steeple | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 20 | 2 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 43. | Caleb Struggles | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep110 | 2 | |
|
| 44. | The 100th Episode Special | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep100 | 2 | |
|
| 45. | Side Quests | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep82 | 2 | Show |
|
| 46. | Only Up From Here | Super Mario RPG Remake Part 10 | 2 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 47. | Alex is a Wizard | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep80 | 2 | Show |
|
| 48. | What's Going On? | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep64 | 2 | Show |
|
| 49. | The Ocean | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep91 | 2 | |
|
| 50. | Sundown at Riverside Station | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 31 | 2 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 51. | Gen 1 Tier List | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep107 | 2 | |
|
| 52. | The GOAT | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep50 | 2 | Show |
|
| 53. | Our Wonderful World | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep54 | 2 | Show |
|
| 54. | DIAMONDS | Caleb and Alex play Minecraft Ep 5 | 2 | | Minecraft
|
| 55. | We Touch Grass | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep8 | 2 | Show |
|
| 56. | New Year's Gatekeeping | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep40 | 2 | Show |
|
| 57. | Skibidi Podcast | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep128 | 2 | |
|
| 58. | The Snail | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep 72 | 2 | Show |
|
| 59. | Susan Hunt | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep116 | 2 | |
|
| 60. | Infiltrating The X-Naut Fortress | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 37 | 2 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 61. | Our Future | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep60 | 2 | Show |
|
| 62. | Cartoons and Baguettes | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep18 | 2 | Show | Counter-Strike: Source
|
| 63. | Pokémon Tier List | Totally Oblivious Ep48 | 1 | Show |
|
| 64. | Inciting Caleb's Rage | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep86 | 1 | Show |
|
| 65. | Most Ridiculous and Stupid Episode to Ever Exist | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep44 | 1 | Show |
|
| 66. | Our Favorite Games | Totally Oblivious Ep38 | 1 | Show |
|
| 67. | Storming Bowser's Castle | Super Mario RPG Remake Part 13 | 1 | | Super Mario RPG
|
| 68. | Wisdom | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep104 | 1 | |
|
| 69. | Boys vs Girls | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep70 | 1 | Show |
|
| 70. | Become The Bully | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 6 | 1 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 71. | Video Games are Dead | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep17 | 1 | Show |
|
| 72. | Happy Halloween! | Totally Oblivious Ep31 | 1 | Show |
|
| 73. | Saving The Mushroom Kingdom | Super Mario RPG Remake Part 14 END | 1 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 74. | The April Fool | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep103 | 1 | |
|
| 75. | The Saddest Episode | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep46 | 1 | Show |
|
| 76. | World War II Occultism | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep78 | 1 | Show |
|
| 77. | Alex Achieves Heaven | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep71 | 1 | Show |
|
| 78. | Caleb Ruins A Man's Life | Caleb and Alex play Minecraft Ep 7 | 1 | | Minecraft
|
| 79. | YOU STUPID COW | Caleb and Alex play Minecraft Ep 9 | 1 | | Minecraft
|
| 80. | Are You Ducking Kidding Me? | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep102 | 1 | |
|
| 81. | The Good, The Bad, and The Internet | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep19 | 1 | Show |
|
| 82. | Caleb Hates Tomatoes | Totally Oblivious Podcast Highlight | 1 | Show |
|
| 83. | Campfire Stories | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep16 | 1 | Show |
|
| 84. | All Vibes | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep53 | 1 | Show |
|
| 85. | The Wheel of Fate | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep68 | 1 | Show |
|
| 86. | Poker Nights With A Ratswarm | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep112 | 1 | |
|
| 87. | Politics & Nuggies | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep22 | 1 | Show |
|
| 88. | School: Part 2 | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep126 | 1 | |
|
| 89. | Crazy Conspiracies | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep4 | 1 | Show |
|
| 90. | A Turd in Space | Pikmin Part 1 | Totally Oblivious Gaming | 1 | |
|
| 91. | The Wall | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep32 | 1 | Show |
|
| 92. | The Terrible Treasure Hunter | Super Mario RPG Remake Part 9 | 1 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
| 93. | Aliens? | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep47 | 1 | Show |
|
| 94. | Cereal Tier List | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep51 | 1 | Show |
|
| 95. | The Hit List | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep61 | 1 | Show |
|
| 96. | Terrible Horrible People | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep90 | 1 | |
|
| 97. | The Caleb Experience | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep42 | 1 | Show |
|
| 98. | Pumpkin Spiced Pod | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep25 | 1 | Show |
|
| 99. | Alex's Fears | Totally Oblivious Podcast Ep27 | 1 | Show |
|
| 100. | Best Start Believing In Ghost Stories | Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door Part 30 | 0 | | Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
|
