| 1. | Redskins vs Colts Super Bowl 52 | 54 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 2. | Browns vs Dolphins WK3 2016 | 31 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 3. | Redskins vs Colts WK10 2026 | 23 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 4. | Bills vs Colts WK1 2030 | 22 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 5. | Packers vs Colts WK17 2028 | 21 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 6. | Redskins vs Colts WK7 2034 2nd Half | 20 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 7. | Rams vs Colts WK6 2025 | 17 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 8. | Colts vs Titans WK14 2020 Pt1 | 16 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 9. | Colts vs Jaguars WK12 2031 2nd Half | 15 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 10. | Colts vs Dolphins WK7 2024 | 15 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 11. | Jaguars vs Colts WK1 2024 | 15 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 12. | Colts vs Titans WK14 2020 Pt2 | 15 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 13. | Colts vs Titans WK10 2029 | 14 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 14. | Vikings vs Colts WK16 2028 | 14 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 15. | Panthers vs Colts WK1 2027 | 13 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 16. | Cardinals vs Colts WK11 2029 | 13 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 17. | Eagles vs Colts WK8 2026 | 13 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 18. | Colts vs Jaguars WK17 2029 | 13 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 19. | Browns vs Chargers WK9 2018 | 12 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 20. | Colts vs Lions WK12 2028 | 12 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 21. | Chiefs vs Colts WK17 2030 2nd Half | 12 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 22. | Colts vs Jaguars WK9 2032 2nd Half | 11 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 23. | Dolphins vs Colts WK6 2027 | 11 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 24. | Jaguars vs Colts WK17 2033 2nd Half | 11 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 25. | Dolphins vs Colts WK8 2030 | 11 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 26. | Colts vs Dolphins WK15 2037 | 11 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 27. | Jaguars vs Colts WK11 2025 | 11 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 28. | Chiefs vs Titans AFC Divisional RD 2033 2nd Half | 9 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 29. | Patriots vs Colts WK15 2026 | 9 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 30. | Seahawks vs Colts WK14 2025 | 9 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 31. | Browns vs Titans WK5 2023 | 9 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 32. | Dolphins vs Colts WK8 2033 1st Half | 8 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 33. | Jets vs Colts WK17 2024 | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 34. | Panthers vs Colts WK4 2031 2nd Half | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 35. | Chargers vs Colts WK3 2024 | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 36. | Colts vs Bills WK10 2025 | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 37. | Chiefs vs Colts WK4 2028 | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 38. | Dolphins vs Colts WK8 2033 2nd Half | 8 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 39. | Colts vs Jaguars WK12 2031 1st Half | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 40. | Colts vs Titans WK1 2025 | 8 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 41. | Texans vs Colts WK17 2025 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 42. | Colts vs Titans WK16 2030 2nd Half | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 43. | Texans vs Colts WK2 2026 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 44. | Jaguars vs Colts WK6 2029 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 45. | Titans vs Colts WK7 2025 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 46. | Colts vs Jaguars WK13 2025 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 47. | Texans vs Colts WK13 2024 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 48. | Steelers vs Jaguars AFC Divisional 2026 2nd Half | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 49. | Lions vs Browns WK16 2029 | 7 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 50. | Colts vs Jets WK17 2027 | 6 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 51. | Colts vs Titans WK9 2024 | 6 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 52. | Browns vs Rams WK5 2019 | 6 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 53. | Colts vs Jaguars WK15 2028 | 6 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 54. | Vikings vs Colts WK10 2024 | 6 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 55. | Colts vs Jaguars WK8 2027 | 6 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 56. | Browns vs Panthers WK2 2022 | 5 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 57. | Colts vs Chargers WK2 2028 | 5 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 58. | Panthers vs Browns WK5 2026 | 5 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 59. | Jaguars vs Colts WK14 2026 | 5 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 60. | Jaguars vs Colts WK6 2030 | 5 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 61. | Colts vs Jaguars WK4 2030 | 5 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 62. | Dolphins vs Colts AFC Divisional RD 2025 | 5 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 63. | Falcons vs Vikings NFC Wild Card 2031 2nd Half | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 64. | Browns vs Chargers WK7 2027 | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 65. | Bills vs Colts AFC Title 2024 | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 66. | Chiefs vs Colts WK17 2030 1st Half | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 67. | Steelers vs Jaguars AFC Divisional RD 2026 1st | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 68. | Bills vs Colts WK15 2024 | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 69. | Colts vs Titans WK13 2032 1st Half | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 70. | Colts vs Titans WK16 2026 | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 71. | Jaguars vs Bills AFC Wild Card 2028 2nd Half | 4 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 72. | Colts vs Jaguars WK6 2026 | 3 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 73. | Broncos vs Dolphins AFC Divisional 2035 | 3 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 74. | Jaguars vs Colts WK17 2033 1st Half | 3 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 75. | Colts vs Titans WK13 2032 2nd Half | 3 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 76. | Bengals vs Dolphins AFC Wild Card 2037 Pt.2 | 3 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 77. | Browns vs Jaguars WK2 2029 | 3 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 78. | Dolphins vs Bills AFC Wild Card 2034 2nd Half | 3 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 79. | Texans vs Colts WK2 2030 | 2 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 80. | Dolphins vs Bills AFC Wild Card 2034 1st Half | 2 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 81. | Bills vs Colts WK17 2032 1st Half | 2 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 82. | Colts vs Texans WK17 2026 | 2 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 83. | Browns vs Jaguars WK13 2032 2nd Half | 2 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 84. | Chiefs vs Titans AFC Divisional RD 1st Half | 2 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 85. | Browns vs Dolphins WK5 2028 | 2 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 86. | Browns vs Jaguars WK13 2032 1st Half | 1 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 87. | Browns vs Jaguars WK14 2035 1st Half | 1 | | Madden NFL 18
|
| 88. | Dolphins vs Browns WK13 2034 1st Half | 1 | Let's Play | Madden NFL 18
|
| 89. | Colts vs Jaguars WK9 2032 1st Half | 1 | | Madden NFL 18
|
