| 1. | Braves vs Indians 2024 World Series GM6 | 75 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 2. | Braves vs Indians 2024 World Series GM1 | 55 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 3. | Indians vs Braves 2024 World Series GM4 | 52 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 4. | Yankees vs Dodgers 2023 World Series GM5 | 42 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 5. | Indians(PCON) vs Rays(Heffe) League Match #2 | 38 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 6. | Indians vs Braves 2024 World Series GM3 | 31 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 7. | Screw your bunt cheese | 30 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 8. | I took that replay very personally. | 26 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 9. | Indians(PCON) vs Brewers(KD) League Match #10 | 26 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 10. | Red(Cigs) vs Indians(PCON) Round 1 GM1 | 21 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 11. | Dodgers vs Diamondbacks 2026 NLDS Game 1 | 21 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 12. | Mariners vs Indians 2024 ALDS GM1 | 18 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 13. | Guardians vs Blue Jays S5 GM13 | 18 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 14. | Indians (PCON) vs Nationals (CSteele) League Match #15 | 18 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 15. | Rockies (Daddy-Oh) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #10 | 18 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 16. | Braves vs Dodgers 2022 NLCS GM7 | 17 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 17. | Indians(PCON) vs Twins(Ryguy) League Match #5 | 17 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 18. | Rockies (Heffe) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #28 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 19. | Twins (Ryguy) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #17 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 20. | Diamond Dynasty #14 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 21. | Red Sox vs Indians 2019 ALCS GM1 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 22. | Braves vs Cubs 2022 NLDS GM1 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 23. | Red(Cigs) vs Indians(PCON) League Match #6 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 24. | Indians (PCON) vs Phillies (Durranter) League Match #8 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 25. | Indians vs Red Sox 2019 ALCS GM5 | 16 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 26. | Diamondbacks vs Dodgers 2026 NLDS Game 3 | 15 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 27. | Indians vs Yankees 2024 ALCS GM6 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 28. | Angels (TSteff) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #20 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 29. | Brewers vs Dodgers 2024 NLDS GM1 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 30. | Brewers (Comein) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #11 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 31. | Indians(PCON) vs Phillies(Impulse) League Match #4 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 32. | Diamond Dynasty #9 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 33. | Yankees vs Indians 2024 ALCS GM4 | 14 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 34. | Diamond Dynasty #12 | 13 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 35. | Indians(PCON) vs Mets(X-Brzy) League Match #1 | 13 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 36. | Diamond Dynasty #16 | 12 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 37. | Diamond Dynasty #13 | 12 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 38. | Indians(PCON) vs Phillies(Durranter) S3 Game #9 | 12 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 39. | First Ever No Hitter | 12 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 40. | Brewers vs Diamondbacks 2025 NLCS GM1 | 12 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 41. | Diamond Dynasty #31 | 12 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 42. | Angels(Kenny) vs Indians(PCON) League Match #3 | 11 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 43. | Nationals(CSteele) vs Indians(PCON) League Match #2 | 11 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 44. | Astros (Heffe) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #7 | 11 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 45. | Nationals vs Dodgers 2022 NLDS GM1 | 11 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 46. | Indians (PCON) vs Cubs (Elquad) League Match #13 | 11 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 47. | Indians(PCON) vs Mets(ShowSeoul) S3 Game #14 | 10 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 48. | Cubs (Elquad) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #17 | 10 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 49. | Twins(Ryguy) vs Indians(PCON) S3 Game #11 Highlights | 10 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 50. | Impulse vs PCON Playoff Game #5 (2-2) | 10 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 51. | Twins (Ryguy) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #12 | 10 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 52. | Indians(PCON) vs Red(Cigs) League Match #7 | 10 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 53. | Red(Cigs) vs Indians (PCON) League Match 1st Round GM5 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 54. | Indians (PCON) vs Brewers (Comein) League Match #1 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 55. | Brewers (Comein) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #16 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 56. | Rays vs Brewers 2025 World Series GM3 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 57. | Mariners vs Indians 2024 ALDS GM2 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 58. | Diamond Dynasty #10 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 59. | Brewers(KD) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #14 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 60. | Brewers(KD) vs Indians(PCON) League Match #9 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 61. | Diamond Dynasty #15 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 62. | Indians (PCON) vs Blue Jays (Snoddy) League Match #37 | 9 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 63. | Angels(Kenny) vs Indians(PCON) League Match #13 | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 64. | Diamond Dynasty #17 | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 65. | Indians (PCON) vs Rockies (Heffe) League Match #26 | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 66. | Indians(PCON) vs Red(Cigs) Round 1 GM3 | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 67. | A's (Elcuh) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #20 | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 68. | Impulse vs PCON Playoff Game #3 (1-1) | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 69. | Indians(PCON) vs Angels(Kenny) League Match #12 | 8 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 70. | White Sox (Cigs) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #25 | 7 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 71. | Indians (PCON) vs Rockies (Daddy-Oh) League Match #29 | 7 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 72. | Impulse vs PCON Playoff Game #4 (1-2) | 7 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 73. | Nationals vs Dodgers 2022 NLDS GM5 | 7 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 74. | Athletics vs Indians 2025 ALDS GM2 | 7 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 75. | Astros (Heffe) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #18 | 7 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 76. | Diamond Dynasty #79 | 6 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 77. | Cardinals (KD) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #26 | 6 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 78. | Phillies (Impulse) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #23 | 5 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 79. | Red(Cigs) vs Indians(PCON) Round 1 GM2 | 5 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 80. | A's (Elcuh) vs Indians (PCON) League Match #22 | 4 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 81. | Indians (PCON) vs A's (Elcuh) League Match #21 | 4 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 82. | Indians(PCON) vs Cubs(Elquad) S3 Game #13 | 3 | | MLB The Show 18
|
| 83. | Diamondbacks vs Royals 2026 World Series Game 4 Part 2 | 2 | | MLB The Show 18
|
