| 1. | 2024 MLB Home Run Derby Final | 490 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 2. | Reds vs Guardians S5 GM24 | 382 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 3. | Padres vs Guardians League S6 GM41 | 362 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 4. | Rockies vs Braves 2023 NL Wild Card | 309 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 5. | Braves vs Guardians 2025 World Series Game 6 (CLE 3-2) | 303 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 6. | Francisco Lindor 100th HR in Diamond Dynasty | 246 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 7. | Guardians vs Yankees 2024 ALDS Game 3 (Tied 1-1) | 242 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 8. | Guardians vs Angels 2023 ALDS Game 3 (CLE 2-O) | 225 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 9. | Padres vs Guardians League S6 GM35 | 222 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 10. | Astros vs Guardians 7/22/2026 | 219 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 11. | Brewers vs Braves 2021 NLDS Game 1 | 213 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 12. | Guardians vs Royals 5/24/2023 | 209 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 13. | Braves vs Dodgers 2023 NLDS Game 2 (LAD 1-0) | 208 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 14. | Rockies vs Guardians League S6 GM49 | 201 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 15. | Guardians vs White Sox S5 GM27 | 191 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 16. | Rangers vs Guardians 9/24/2026 | 176 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 17. | Twins vs Guardians 8/11/2026 | 166 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 18. | Dodgers vs Guardians League S6 GM48 | 165 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 19. | Braves vs Guardians League S6 GM50 | 164 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 20. | Guardians vs Orioles League S6 GM28 | 161 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 21. | Rays vs Guardians 2026 AL Wild Card Game 1 | 160 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 22. | Reds vs Guardians League S6 GM44 | 159 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 23. | Angels vs Guardians League S6 GM39 | 155 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 24. | Brewers vs Phillies 2023 NLDS Game 4 (MIL 2-1) | 154 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 25. | Guardians vs Braves 2025 World Series Game 4 (CLE 2-1) | 153 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 26. | Phillies vs Brewers 2023 NLDS Game 5 (Tied 2-2) | 149 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 27. | Braves vs Diamondbacks 2026 NLCS Game 7 | 149 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 28. | Guardians vs Athletics 5/7/2024 | 148 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 29. | Guardians vs Braves 2025 World Series Game 3 (Tied 1-1) | 147 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 30. | Cardinals vs Guardians League S6 GM33 | 141 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 31. | Braves vs Guardians League S6 GM34 | 139 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 32. | Guardians vs Dodgers League S6 GM27 | 139 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 33. | Guardians vs Cardinals League S6 GM12 | 138 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 34. | Mariners vs Guardians League S6 GM26 | 137 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 35. | Guardians vs Rockies League S6 GM31 | 136 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 36. | Braves vs Guardians 2025 World Series Game 2 (CLE 1-0) | 136 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 37. | Marlins vs Braves 2026 NLDS Game 1 | 133 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 38. | Royals vs Guardians 9/29/2023 | 129 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 39. | Reds vs Guardians 8/25/2025 | 129 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 40. | Rangers vs Guardians 2026 ALDS Game 3 (Tied 1-1) | 128 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 41. | Phillies vs Cubs 2025 NLDS Game 1 Pre Stream | 128 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 42. | Mariners vs Guardians League S6 GM40 | 127 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 43. | Diamondbacks vs Braves 2026 NLCS Game 3 (ARI 2-0) | 124 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 44. | Guardians vs Rangers League S6 GM42 | 123 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 45. | Twins vs Guardians 9/16/2023 | 122 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 46. | Phillies vs Brewers 2023 NLDS Game 1 | 116 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 47. | Guardians vs Royals 9/8/2025 | 116 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 48. | Guardians vs Padres League S6 GM17 | 115 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 49. | Guardians vs Braves League S6 GM47 | 113 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 50. | Guardians vs Rays 5/5/2024 | 112 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 51. | Brewers vs Guardians 8/8/2025 | 110 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 52. | Guardians vs Angels 8/23/2025 | 109 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 53. | Angels vs Guardians 8/11/2025 | 109 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 54. | Guardians vs Pirates 8/15/2025 | 109 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 55. | Marlins vs Pirates 2026 NL Wild Card Game 2 (MIA 1-0) | 108 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 56. | Angels vs Guardians 8/12/2025 | 108 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 57. | Guardians vs Rangers 2024 ALCS Game 6 (TEX 3-2) | 104 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 58. | Marlins vs Guardians League S6 GM43 | 104 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 59. | Guardians vs Rays 4/14/2026 | 101 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 60. | Diamondbacks vs Braves 2026 NLCS Game 5 (ARI 3-1) | 101 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 61. | Athletics vs Guardians 4/2/2026 | 99 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 62. | Marlins vs Guardians S5 GM39 | 99 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 63. | Guardians vs Tigers 4/27/2025 | 98 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 64. | Guardians vs Rangers 2026 ALDS Game 1 | 95 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 65. | Rangers vs Guardians 7/22/2024 | 95 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 66. | Diamondbacks vs Braves 2026 NLCS Game 4 (ARI 3-0) | 94 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 67. | Marlins vs Braves 2026 NLDS Game 2 (ATL 1-0) | 94 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 68. | Astros vs Orioles 2025 AL Wild Card GM2 (HOU 1-0) | 93 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 69. | Cubs vs Braves 2025 NLCS Game 2 (CHC 1-0) | 93 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 70. | Giants vs Diamondbacks 2026 NLDS Game 2 (ARI 1-0) | 92 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 71. | Orioles vs Diamondbacks 2026 World Series Game 3 (BAL 2-0) | 92 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 72. | Braves vs Marlins 2026 NLDS Game 3 (Tied 1-1) | 91 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 73. | Athletics vs Guardians League S6 GM32 | 91 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 74. | Guardians vs Rangers 7/12/2026 | 89 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 75. | Rangers vs Guardians 2025 ALCS Game 2 (TEX 1-0) | 89 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 76. | Marlins vs Braves 2026 NLDS Game 5 (Tied 2-2) | 89 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 77. | Braves vs Guardians 7/30/2025 | 88 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 78. | Guardians vs Mariners 9/21/2025 | 88 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 79. | Royals vs Guardians 9/2/2025 | 87 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 80. | Cubs vs Braves 2025 NLCS Game 6 (ATL 3-2) | 87 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 81. | Diamondbacks vs Orioles 2026 World Series Game 1 | 87 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 82. | Rangers vs Guardians 2025 ALCS Game 6 (CLE 3-2) | 86 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 83. | Guardians vs Blue Jays 9/13/2024 | 85 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 84. | Royals vs Guardians 7/23/2023 | 82 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 85. | Diamond Dynasty #114 | 82 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 86. | Orioles vs Guardians 2026 ALCS Game 5 (CLE 3-1) Final | 82 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 87. | Guardians vs Mariners 5/16/2026 | 81 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 88. | White Sox vs Guardians League S6 GM36 (Quest for 22 wins in a row, at 21) | 81 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 89. | Guardians vs Twins 7/6/2025 | 81 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 90. | PCON36’s Custom Leagues 22 Game Winning Streak Highlights | 80 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 91. | Cubs vs Braves 2025 NLCS Game 1 | 80 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 92. | Diamond Dynasty #108 | 80 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 93. | Guardians vs Yankees 7/11/2024 Final | 80 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 94. | Dodgers vs Brewers 2023 NLCS Game 4 (LAD 2-1) | 78 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 95. | Orioles vs Guardians 2026 ALCS Game 3 (Tied 1-1) | 77 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 96. | White Sox vs Guardians League S6 GM20 | 77 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 97. | Royals vs Diamondbacks 2026 World Series Game 7 | 77 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 98. | Guardians vs Marlins League S6 GM8 | 77 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 99. | Rockies vs Guardians League S6 GM5 | 77 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 100. | Twins vs Guardians 9/15/2025 | 76 | | MLB The Show 20
|
