| 1. |  Jay's Horror Gaming | Scariest Game of 2023 on Itch.io | Horror Game | 1,133 | Let's Play |
| 2. |  KendroBTG | 3 JEUX D'HORREUR : Fatal Midnight, You and the Night , Burger & Frights (Let's Play Horreur FR) | 935 | Let's Play |
| 3. | INERTIA | Inertia Plays Fatal Midnight | 681 | Let's Play |
| 4. | RJsoLit2x | BABYSITTING my sister BUT she's a DEMON [Fatal Midnight Gameplay] | 520 | Let's Play |
| 5. | Nard The Gamer | MY SISTER IS CURSED! | Fatal Midnight Full Let’s Play | #fyp #fy #fypシ #horrorgaming | 427 | Let's Play |
| 6. | Ties That Bind Gaming | Fatal Midnight | Highlights from Full Playthrough with No Commentary Gameplay | PC | 420 | Let's Play |
| 7. | Nard The Gamer | MY SISTER IS CURSED! | Fatal Midnight Full Let’s Play | #fyp #fy #fypシ #horrorgaming | 410 | Let's Play |
| 8. | Ties That Bind Gaming | Fatal Midnight | More Highlights from Full Playthrough with No Commentary Gameplay | PC | 409 | Let's Play |
| 9. | Jay's Horror SHORTS | Is That A Shotgun?! | Horror Game | 344 | Let's Play |
| 10. | GeninMyles | OK, I think this was the loudest I've ever screamed. | Fatal Midnight - Short Indie Horror Game | 291 | Let's Play |
| 11. | Long Gone | A Horror Writer Plays Fatal Midnight #letsplay #indiegame | 153 | Let's Play |
| 12. | RiledKitty | ONE IN EVERY FAMILY... | Fatal Midnight | 90 | Let's Play |
| 13. |  Esh Plays | Sibling Quarrel | Esh Plays FATAL MIDNIGHT | 89 | Let's Play |
| 14. |  Mr lahmach | FatalMidnight►Наглая девушка ходит по моему дому пока я спал►Страшилки | 86 | Let's Play |
| 15. | Jay's Horror Gaming | When P.T. Meets Reality & It's Terrifying! | Let's Play Horror | 86 | Let's Play |
| 16. | Against the Ivy | FATAL MIDNIGHT | WHO IS THE REAL THREAT? | 82 | Let's Play |
| 17. |  German Indie Horror Games | Let's play Fatal Midnight | 67 | Let's Play |
| 18. | Call Me DNA | Babysitting my demonic sister! | Fatal Midnight | 66 | Let's Play |
| 19. | PookieVideo | I CANNOT BELIEVE WHAT I PLAYED! - Fatal Midnight | 64 | Let's Play |
| 20. |  Domo | Fatal Midnight - Indie Horror Game - FULL GAME | 64 | Let's Play |
| 21. | MigsXL | I GOTTA FIND MY SISTER BEFORE IT DOES!! | Fatal Midnight - Full Game Playthrough | 58 | Let's Play |
| 22. | HaTheGamer | Everything Is Not What It Seems... | 57 | Let's Play |
| 23. |  Vampirschi Gaming | Fatal Midnight - Playthrough (short indie horror) | 56 | Let's Play |
| 24. |  The Haple Maple Show | My Younger Annoying Sister Got Possessed | 54 | Let's Play |
| 25. | Nard The Gamer | MY SISTER IS CURSED! | Fatal Midnight Full Let’s Play | #fyp #fy #fypシ #horrorgaming | 48 | Let's Play |
| 26. | IAmFinn | HELP My Sister Has Been POSSESSED And Won't Stop CHASING ME!!! | Fatal Midnight | 45 | Let's Play |
| 27. | Lucky Gent | THREW MY HEADPHONES! - Fatal Midnight Playthrough | 45 | Let's Play |
| 28. | mammarosaUNCUT | was ist nur bloß…mit unserer Schwester LOS... 😱 FATAL MIDNIGHT | 37 | Let's Play |
| 29. |  LatestDave | This Game Takes You For A Ride! | Fatal Midnight | Let's Play | 36 | Let's Play |
| 30. | finaleffect4 | Fatal Midnight! J'exorcisme m'a soeur à coup de flingue! jeu complet (FR) #horrorgaming #fullgame | 36 | Let's Play |
| 31. | WillBotch | Fatal Midnight: "You Okay Sis?" #WillBotch #letsplay | 32 | Let's Play |
| 32. |  Kenzies Chaotic Corner | Fatal Midnight - Playthrough with comments - itch.io - Horror | 30 | Let's Play |
| 33. | The Don't Look Back Network | Let's Play- Fatal Midnight- (PC/2023)- LP#199 | 25 | Let's Play |
| 34. | Nard The Gamer | MY SISTER IS CURSED! | Fatal Midnight Full Let’s Play | 23 | Let's Play |
| 35. | Esh Plays | I'm Leaving a One-Star Review | Esh Plays SCAREBNB (Demo) | 21 | Let's Play |
| 36. |  LostZoss | Hey Sister! | Fatal Midnight | 20 | Let's Play |
| 37. | Ties That Bind Gaming | Fatal Midnight | Full Playthrough with No Commentary Gameplay | PC | 12 | Let's Play |
| 38. | ThickBeardGaming | Looking After My Possessed Sister | 12 | Let's Play |
| 39. | Thegingerbeerdman | Fatal Midnight Complete Play Through My heart left me a moment | 8 | Let's Play |
