| 1. |  ITSREAL85 The Goat | My Sister Was Acting WEIRD! 😳 SHE GOTTA GO! | 19,648 | |
| 2. | SWOL | FATAL MIDNIGHT Is TERRIFYING | 15,455 | |
| 3. | SWOL | Full Body Jumpscare #gaming #horrorgaming #scary #scaryindiegame | 14,747 | |
| 4. | InternetCity Gaming | The CRAZIEST twist Ever!!! - (Fatal Midnight) | 4,251 | |
| 5. | GoodyLuck | I DEFEATED THE DEMON!😳#horrorgaming | 3,586 | |
| 6. | Hayden Green | I'M SUPPOSED TO TAKE CARE OF MY SICK SISTER BUT SOMETHING IS VERY WRONG HERE | Free Random Games | 2,987 | |
| 7. | GoodyLuck | THAT'S MY ROOM!😡#horrorgaming | 2,952 | |
| 8. | Loud Flavor | I Think My Sister Is Possessed! | 2,758 | |
| 9. | Chesh | My Sister Is So Mean To Me.. #fatalmidnight #gaming #horror | 2,717 | |
| 10. | Adrionic | THERE'S SOMETHING HORRIBLY WRONG WITH MY SISTER | Fatal Midnight | 2,590 | |
| 11. | GoodyLuck | LOCKED IN THE BATHROOM!🤬#horrorgaming | 2,538 | |
| 12. | GoodyLuck | WHAT THE HELL!?😱#horrorgaming | 2,518 | |
| 13. | GoodyLuck | I FOUND THE MONSTER!😖#horrorgaming | 2,455 | |
| 14. | GoodyLuck | You Saw That Right?😳😖#horrorgaming | 2,410 | |
| 15. | LayItDown Gaming | LIL SIS GOT THE DEVIL IN HER | FATAL MIDNIGHT GAMEPLAY | 2,143 | |
| 16. | NormalDifficulty | Why I Hate Horror Game Basements - Stream Moments # 203 | 2,119 | |
| 17. | MattyMIZE | Fatal Midnight Jumpscare #gaming #horrorgaming #scarygames | 2,061 | |
| 18. | SSJB ELI | I can call the police On People In This Horror Game! | 1,943 | |
| 19. | Ratchett 2.0 | I ALMOST S*** ON MYSELF | Don't Play This Game | FATAL MIDNIGHT | 1,814 | |
| 20. | SupremeFreshman | MY SISTER IS TRYING TO END ME…Fatal Midnight | 1,533 | |
| 21. | MigsXL | PEEKABOO JUMPSCARE!! *LOUD WARNING* #FatalMidnight #horrorgaming #shorts #migsxl | 1,503 | |
| 22. | NormalDifficulty | When You Think You're Safe in a Horror Game - Stream Moments # 218 | 1,465 | |
| 23. | HaTheGamer | You Have To Be Ready for Anything! | 1,380 | |
| 24. | GoodyLuck | WHY HE SOUND LIKE THAT!💀#horrorgaming | 1,314 | |
| 25. | Tony AC Gaming | This boy need to get check real bad - Fatal Midnight indie horror game | 1,236 | |
| 26. | Tony AC Gaming | I can't believe what I just seen - Incoherence indie horror game | 1,209 | |
| 27. | Jay's Horror Gaming | Scariest Game of 2023 on Itch.io | Horror Game | 1,133 | Let's Play |
| 28. | NormalDifficulty | This Horror Game is "Amazing" - Stream Moments # 206 | 1,122 | |
| 29. | HaTheGamer | Cross, Bible... Gun? | 967 | |
| 30. | GoodyLuck | MOVE OR DIE!💀#horrorgaming | 966 | |
| 31. | GoodyLuck | Not The AI Voice💀#horrorgaming | 957 | |
| 32. | GoodyLuck | LET ME SLEEP!😤#horrorgaming | 938 | |
| 33. | Forkzilla | Goodbye Sister #shorts #horrorgaming | 793 | |
| 34. | Twallsx4 | MY GUY WENT INSANE | Fatal Midnight | 723 | |
| 35. | INERTIA | Inertia Plays Fatal Midnight | 681 | Let's Play |
| 36. | Trapabank | MY SISTER IS POSSESSED…CRAZY PLOT TWIST | Fatal midnight | 675 | |
| 37. | GoodyLuck | IS THAT MY SISTER!?👻#horrorgaming | 652 | |
| 38. | Monakage | Most TERRIFYING Game I've Ever Played | 581 | |
| 39. | JustObie | She heard tha WHOLE plan | 577 | |
| 40. | A.X. Horror | 5 Minutes of Pure Terror: Fatal Midnight Gameplay #indiecreepy, #horror, #shortshorror, | 504 | |
| 41. | The Black Jiraiya | I PLAYED 2 OF THE SCARIEST GAMES FROM THE DARK WEB! | 488 | |
| 42. | Zinmiedo | ESTE JUEGO SE ROBO MI ESPIRITU | 473 | |
| 43. | Reddoliche2 | A horror game where you take care of your sick sister.. | 465 | |
| 44. | JustObie | I dont have a title for this one #shorts #fatalmidnight #wfio | 451 | |
| 45. | ezez game | FATAL MIDNIGHT | Horror Game | (Jumpscare Warning!) | 436 | |
| 46. | Nard The Gamer | MY SISTER IS CURSED! | Fatal Midnight Full Let’s Play | #fyp #fy #fypシ #horrorgaming | 427 | Let's Play |
| 47. | RegisBlack233 | my girl got sturdy then bounced #gaming #horrorgaming #fatalmidnight | 420 | |
| 48. | Ties That Bind Gaming | Fatal Midnight | Highlights from Full Playthrough with No Commentary Gameplay | PC | 420 | Let's Play |
| 49. | Nard The Gamer | MY SISTER IS CURSED! | Fatal Midnight Full Let’s Play | #fyp #fy #fypシ #horrorgaming | 410 | Let's Play |
| 50. | RegisBlack233 | she scared me twice #horrorgaming #gaming #fatalmidnight | 409 | |
| 51. | Ties That Bind Gaming | Fatal Midnight | More Highlights from Full Playthrough with No Commentary Gameplay | PC | 409 | Let's Play |
| 52. | HaTheGamer | I Had Questions! | 401 | |
| 53. | PineAhPool | Fatal Midnight: Getting #Scared by Stepsister - #shorts | 394 | |
| 54. | HaTheGamer | Don't Leave The Milk Out! | 385 | |
| 55. | Zlance1993 | Could my Sister Be Saved? | Fatal Midnight | 365 | |
| 56. | Pecan | We 360 No Scoped a Ghost... - Fatal Midnight | 342 | |
| 57. | DonMahLuvinLandry | THIS WAS NOT JUMPSCARE OF THE YEAR. THIS WAS JUMPSCARE OF THE CENTURY!! | Fatal Midnight [FULL GAME] | 316 | |
| 58. | Slye | CAUGHT MY SISTER THRILLER WALKING DOWNSTAIRS - Fatal Midnight | 315 | |
| 59. | Daily Game Test | FATAL MIDNIGHT Horror Game Demo Gameplay | 298 | |
| 60. | GeninMyles | OK, I think this was the loudest I've ever screamed. | Fatal Midnight - Short Indie Horror Game | 291 | Let's Play |
| 61. | CorpsebombKeef | What You See Isn't Real (Fatal Midnight) Scary Indie Horror Game | 289 | |
| 62. | Luminesnake | I MURDERED MY SISTER! | FATAL MIDNIGHT | 285 | |
| 63. | HaTheGamer | Would You Go In | 254 | |
| 64. | Chesh | THERE IS SOMETHING SERIOUSLY WRONG WITH MY SISTER | Fatal Midnight | 253 | |
| 65. | DonMahLuvinLandry | MY SISTER GOT POSSESSED BY A DEMON AND CHOKE SLAMMED ME TO HELL!! | Fatal Midnight | 252 | |
| 66. | Zinmiedo | 2 JUEGOS DONDE TEMOS QUE APOSTAR Nuestra VIDA PARA PODER SALIR… | 236 | |
| 67. | AdamsGēmu | THIS IS BY FAR THE MOST SCARIEST JUMPSCARE EVER! || Fatal Midnight | 234 | |
| 68. | UnHoLyV3Ng3aNc3 | FATAL MIDNIGHT | FULL GAME (NO COMMENTARY) | 228 | |
| 69. | GoodyLuck | PANCAKE PARTY!😛#horrorgaming | 222 | |
| 70. | DJB | Fatal Midnight Is TOO SCARY #fatalmidnight #shorts | 207 | |
| 71. | mordekye | recorded live on twitch :) #fatalmidnight #fatalmidnightgame | 205 | |
| 72. | AdamsGēmu | BIGGEST JUMPSCARE EVER!! THE SCARIEST GAME. #fatalmidnight #JUMPSCARE #shorts | 192 | |
| 73. | PapiGrayBeard | Fatal Midnight - Stay Still Woman #shorts #shortvideo #indiegames #horrorgaming #jumpscare | 187 | |
| 74. | Tray73ven | THIS GAME F*** UP MY MENTAL BAD!! | Fatal Midnight | 186 | |
| 75. | RicketyGames | POSSESSION RUNS IN THE FAMILY | Fatal Midnight - Full Game | 183 | |
| 76. | SmooveQuxd | FATAL MIDNIGHT🌑🩸 | 179 | |
| 77. | RegisBlack233 | Probably The Scariest Game I've Played in a While! [Fatal Midnight] | 174 | |
| 78. | Knudsen Games | A Horror Game With a SHOTGUN... Fatal Midnight | 172 | |
| 79. | The Black Jiraiya | The scariest dark web horror games! #Shorts | 170 | |
| 80. | Boloutech | Fatal Midnight ❌😮 جِن افتاده توی خانوادم | 167 | |
| 81. | TREHOUDINI 〽️ | I Never Seen A Jumpscare Like THIS !!...... | Fatal Midnight | 159 | |
| 82. | Smexch | Way Too Scary for Me | FATAL MIDNIGHT | 154 | |
| 83. | Long Gone | A Horror Writer Plays Fatal Midnight #letsplay #indiegame | 153 | Let's Play |
| 84. | Koopa Troupe | Fatal Midnight is TERRIFYING #koopatroupe #horrorgaming #fatalmidnight | 152 | |
| 85. | M1KEo7 | Fatal Midnight - When a babysitting job turns into a nightmare | 151 | |
| 86. | Inter Gaming | This game☠️ Fatal Midnight | Horror game | Gameplay | 147 | |
| 87. | PotatoRig | One of he Scariest Game - Fatal Midnight #shors #horrorstories | 147 | |
| 88. | ProofreadFire | Fatal Midnight: MY HEART IS GOING TO EXPLODE! | 142 | |
| 89. | bleat | I think something might be wrong with my sister... | Fatal Midnight | 139 | |
| 90. | Atomic1422 | MY SISTER'S GONE CRAZY!!! | FATAL MIDNIGHT | 137 | |
| 91. | Smellz ARCHIVE | I HAVE NEVER BEEN THIS SCARED...| Fatal Midnight | Itchio Horror Game | 136 | |
| 92. | Kuya Sunset | Something HORRIBLE Happened to my Sister - Fatal Midnight | 136 | |
| 93. | JuuustJenn | Listen.. I don't need this... [ Fatal Midnight ] #horrorgaming #indiehorror #jumpscare | 134 | |
| 94. | BunniiMxrie | Let's Have A Little Chat Sis | Fatal Midnight | 133 | |
| 95. | Blakeevk | My Sisters Strange Behavior Leads To Fatal Midnight | 128 | |
| 96. | Ishin 442 | Fatal Midnight : My Sisters Possession ( Indie Horror Game ) | 126 | |
| 97. | Neon Dark Gaming | Something is SERIOUSLY WRONG With Our Sister | FATAL MIDNIGHT | 124 | |
| 98. | GoodyLuck | WHAT A PLOT TWIST!😱#horrorgaming | 124 | |
| 99. | Loud Flavor | My Sister Is POSSESSED! | Fatal Midnight | 122 | |
| 100. | HaTheGamer | Why Is This Flashlight So Big | 120 | |
