| 1. |  Markiplier | 1,145,681 | I See You | 17:53 |
| 2. |  SomeOrdinaryGamers | 441,146 | Haunted Gaming - Imscared: A Pixelated Nightmare (FULL PLAYTHROUGH) | 28:42 |
| 3. | Cryaotic | 383,862 | Cry Plays: Imscared - A Pixelated Nightmare | 7:04 |
| 4. | John Wolfe | 168,914 | ImScared - A Pixelated Nightmare - Full Playthrough - Indie Horror Game | 28:48 |
| 5. | MrKravin | 41,844 | iseeyou - Free Indie Horror Game (Full Playthrough) | 24:02 |
| 6. | Draxr | 14,952 | Cry Plays: Indie Games 2011 Edition | 38:52 |
| 7. | Neco The Sergal | 1,812 | New Horror from Ivan Of IMSCARED Fame? | Lala is Bound | 31:09 |
| 8. | Alavas | 213 | Let's Play: I'm Scared - A Pixelated Nightmare | We're both terrified! | 26:45 |
| 9. | RichterBelmont12 | 167 | Let's Play Imscared A Pixelated Nightmare (Lower Your Volume) | 15:35 |
| 10. | ThePaSch | 137 | ThePaSch Plays: Imscared - A Pixelated Nightmare | 25:23 |
| 11. |  loveGIANT | 105 | Let's play first-time: Imscared - A pixelated nightmare (German) (Facecam) | 30:25 |
| 12. | bradye21 plays... | 100 | Let's Play Imscared: A Pixelated Nightmare -1- Tornado Warning! | 5:41 |
| 13. | VGamingJunkieVT | 76 | The 4th Wall Isn't Safe - I'm Scared Pixelated Nightmare Let's Play | 15:32 |
| 14. |  Smackers | 68 | Imscared: A Pixelated Nightmare - Let's Play! - PART 3: Creepy Conclusion | 12:18 |
| 15. | Total3clipseGaming | 58 | George Plays: imscared ep.3 FINISHING THE GAME OF TAG | 7:42 |
| 16. |  Rich Gaming | 42 | THE END!? | IMSCARED - Part 1 | 18:16 |
| 17. | ZirCreepsAlot | 35 | ZirCreepsAlot Plays: Imscared - A Pixelated Nightmare {Part 2} (Final) | 8:09 |
| 18. | Zenhorse | 9 | Let's Play Tag! | 24:32 |
| 19. | KOGplays | 8 | PIX-WIN! dr b plays a pixelated nightmare p3 | 9:32 |
