| 1. |  Xegethra | 64,051 | Lego Island - PC - Pepper Roni Playthrough - Part 3 - [With Commentary] | 14:20 |
| 2. | Anthony Edmonds | 17,279 | Let's Play LEGO Island - Episode 7 - Finishing Up | 25:16 |
| 3. |  MrCliftron | 12,870 | Let's Play: Lego Island - Part 6 - That was a Really Tiny Island | 18:33 |
| 4. | moose2 | 12,055 | LEGO Island | Full Pepper Playthrough | 2:12:43 |
| 5. | cs188creations | 5,978 | Livestream Archive 7-24-16 | cs188 Plays: Lego Island | 4:06:45 |
| 6. |  LetsplayGenius1 | 4,447 | Let's Play Abenteuer auf der Lego Insel (german/100%) - Part 9: Der letzte Stein... | 12:21 |
| 7. | kleenertom | 4,379 | Lets Play Abenteuer auf der Legoinsel [Deutsch-100%] Part 1 Aller Anfang ist Schwer =) | 12:26 |
| 8. | Peter Knetter | 2,835 | Lego Alpha Team PC Game | 0:56 |
| 9. | Mr. Nutt | 2,794 | Let's Play Mini: Lego Island | 55:18 |
| 10. | TheKieranator | 2,428 | Reacting to My First Let's Play | 3 Year Anniversary Special! | 18:33 |
| 11. | Heavy Metal Gamer Show | 2,089 | Heavy Metal Gamer Plays: LEGO Island REDUX - Episode 1 | 12:38 |
| 12. | BENergizer1 | 1,870 | Let's Play Lego Island! Part 4: Just the Bricks, Ma'am | 16:33 |
| 13. | D | 1,794 | Lego School Skills Quickplay | 15:36 |
| 14. | deathstalker667 | 540 | Let's Play LEGO Island (Blind) - Part 2 - If You Select The, You Go. | 2:38:54 |
| 15. | Lilbumblebear | 392 | Lego Island Full Gameplay | 2:01:40 |
| 16. | Headhunter Gaming | 216 | Hunter Plays: Lego Island [In Memoriam] | 45:59 |
| 17. | Retro Jank | 200 | Beating The Brickster | LEGO Island 1997 | Casual Friday | 90's PC Game Gameplay, Let's Play | 42:04 |
| 18. | Backntime | 125 | Backntime Plays Lego Island - EPISODE 2 | 9:34 |
| 19. | W̶͍̥̟͕͜͝o̶̭̪̹̲͐̾o̷̪̠̟͓̓ | 65 | W̶͍̥̟͕͜͝o̶̭̪̹̲͐̾o̷̪̠̟͓̓ Plays... LEGO Island [No Commentary] | 31:04 |
| 20. | LaZodiac | 38 | Zodi Plays: Lego Island | 36:41 |
| 21. | LinkXNess Stream-Uploads | 25 | Der Alphabeticon - Part 1 - Abenteuer auf der Lego Insel | 39:36 |
| 22. | BakaBroski | 13 | Lego Island - Full Playthrough | 1:39:05 |
| 23. |  Retro80sMan | 13 | Croc and LEGO Island 25th Anniversary Stream | 5:00:13 |
| 24. | 𝐛𝐞𝐚𝐧𝐲𝐛𝐨𝐲𝐳𝐳 𝟐 | 6 | beanycast: lego island | 2:04:17 |
