| 1. |  PlayStation | 549,477 | Dustin vs. PlayStation - Joe the Fan | 1:14 |
| 2. | Classic Game Room | 197,669 | Classic Game Room HD - MLB 09 THE SHOW for PS3 review pt2 | 7:21 |
| 3. | MrLux | 119,359 | MLB 09 The Show - Seattle Mariners Cliff Lee Sampler | 4:45 |
| 4. | Skopin | 68,078 | MLB 09 the Show 1995 Cleveland Indians gameplay pt1 | 9:55 |
| 5. | MarlinsBaseball | 34,718 | MLB 09: The Show (Florida Marlins Season) Final Standings + Postseason Results | 2:46 |
| 6. | brenton | 26,239 | charging the mound in mlb 09 the show | 0:19 |
| 7. | MSUHitman | 24,969 | Pujols can field also MLB The Show 09 | 0:08 |
| 8. | GamePlayStation | 17,873 | MLB 09: The Show -- Gameplay (PS2) | 8:43 |
| 9. | igcompany | 10,799 | MLB 09: The Show - PS2 Gameplay (4K60fps) | 14:51 |
| 10. | Error1355 | 8,409 | MLB 09: The Show - Glitch - Player Glides to the Base | 0:19 |
| 11. | Timmii Gaming Channel | 8,225 | MLB 09 The Show - PS3 2009 (2009 Best vs Worst Team PIT vs BOS) | 2:03:08 |
| 12. | IGN | 7,599 | MLB '09: The Show PlayStation 3 Gameplay - | 1:03 |
| 13. | davidb69 | 4,846 | Episode 91 PS3 MLB 09 the show Road to MLB the show 20 | 1:00:17 |
| 14. | Jose The Sports Gamer | 3,907 | MLB 09 The Show PS3 Gameplay 2019 Washington Nationals Franchise Mode Ep.7 | 1:38:18 |
| 15. | 30-30 Club - Baseball Video Game Encyclopedia | 3,556 | MLB 09 The Show (PSP) - Gameplay | 1:05:34 |
| 16. | PS2SPORTSINFOSTATION | 3,446 | MLB 09: The Show PS3 Visual Review of Menu Options and Gameplay Demo | 0:00 |
| 17. | Sports Gaming Universe | 2,937 | MLB 09 The Show Minnesota Twins Classic Team Montage (Mauer & Morneau in the Metrodome!) MLB 09 | 10:17 |
| 18. | Jose Virgen | 2,820 | MLB09 The Show glitch, robbed of a HR | 1:36 |
| 19. | Kasabe | 2,778 | Methadone Mambo (M. Mambo) [MLB 09 The Show Version] - Zodiac Death Valley | 4:01 |
| 20. | Gyvi World | 2,442 | WELCOME TO THE LAZER SHOW | 28:06 |
| 21. | Pichu London Sports | 2,436 | MLB 09 The Show [PSP] | Sports Game Ballparks 🏟 ⚾️ | 48:14 |
| 22. | HPC OTI | 1,607 | MLB 09 The Show RTTS Part 210 | 0:00 |
| 23. | Sunken Treasures Games | 1,513 | MLB 09 The Show - Aaron's Line Drive RBI Double to Left | 0:17 |
| 24. | Family Friendly Gaming | 707 | Backyard Baseball 09 DS Episode 19 Finale | 18:51 |
| 25. | Drink a Beer and Play a Game | 667 | Drink a Beer and Play a Game Present: A 3 Minute Review of Major League Baseball (NES) | 3:14 |
| 26. | ShowZone | 416 | Taylor Buchholz was Completely Broken in MLB 09 - Show and Tell, Episode 1 | 8:56 |
| 27. | Paranormal Video Gamer | 101 | MLB season 10 game 1 Cleveland Indians vs New York Yankees | 1:18:59 |
| 28. | Seannosaurus Rex | 78 | Detroit Tigers @ Seattle Mariners | Spring Training [#6] | MLB 09: The Show Gameplay | 1:13:41 |
| 29. | ajmarkle | 72 | ODD HELMET COLORS | MLB THE SHOW 09 #1 (PS3) | 30:23 |
| 30. | MagnoliaSamurai | 55 | Mag Sam's 100th Subscriber Extravaganza | 1:07:34 |
| 31. | TBwellss_Retro_Gaming | 20 | THE BATTER'S BOX - MLB THE SHOW 09-19 | 7:25:59 |
| 32. | Ogreatgames_com | 18 | Major League Baseball 2K9: MLB 09 MAGIC - PS2 Game #Shorts | 0:40 |
| 33. | R.B.I. Vids | 17 | Outdated Tryouts #92 MLB 09 The Show | 22:40 |
| 34. | Pat Cook | 7 | MLB The Show - RTTS - Padres SP Scoring From 2nd | 0:18 |
| 35. | JakesterIX | 1 | MLB 09: The Show JakesterIX Gameplay | 0:00 |
