| 1. |  Cryaotic | 637,561 | Cry Plays: Penumbra: Black Plague (Part 17) (Final) | 18:38 |
| 2. | Markiplier | 504,959 | Slender: Prison | 22:16 |
| 3. | FrozenFoxy | 71,290 | Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague - Part 22 | 22:11 |
| 4. | LovelyCheesePizza | 27,245 | Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague (Blind) (Part 32) | 10:06 |
| 5. | The PewDiePie Archive | 6,406 | Penumbra Black Plague - Part 1 - Lets Play Playthrough Walkthrough ( Deleted PewDiePie Video ) | 16:48 |
| 6. | Lotus Prince | 5,188 | Lotus Prince Let's Play: Penumbra Black Plague - Part 6 | 35:41 |
| 7. | WeaselZone | 4,964 | WEIRD PUZZLES - Penumbra: Black Plague - Part 13 - Playthrough / Let's Play | 20:12 |
| 8. | Distortion2 | 3,911 | Penumbra Black Plague Playthrough (#2) | 4:35:15 |
| 9. | ThravRande | 2,695 | Let's Play! Penumbra: Black Plague Part 20 Raining More Men | 10:30 |
| 10. | chk brk | 1,581 | Penumbra: Black Plague Playthrough Part 7 - Philip, the IT Guy [Blind, Hard, HD] | 23:30 |
| 11. | Caretaker | 1,323 | Caretaker Plays - Penumbra: Black Plague Finale | 40:01 |
| 12. | deatheven13 | 1,020 | Let's Play Penumbra Black Plague 11 - Ooh, Detective Novels! | 14:33 |
| 13. | Travis Whitsitt | 843 | Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague Part 3: Ending | 1:07:41 |
| 14. | Funky G | 831 | Let's Play Penumbra Black Plague (BLIND) Part 7: FINALE | 1:09:22 |
| 15. | Hooded Villager | 730 | It's Finally Over! Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague Part - 14 [FINAL] | 39:36 |
| 16. | Midnight Researcher | 639 | Penumbra Black Plague | Game Playthrough | 3:17:29 |
| 17. | SquishyTheTitan | 558 | Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague | Part 7 | WILLEM! YOU'RE AN ASSHAT! | 11:24 |
| 18. | GaroShadowscale Furry | 320 | Penumbra: Black Plague FULL GAMEPLAY Let's Play First Playthrough Walkthrough part 2 FINAL | 3:11:34 |
| 19. | thecoalbox | 303 | Penumbra Black Plague - Dead Guys :( Part 2 Playthrough | 10:53 |
| 20. | Boy Lag | 273 | Boy Plays Penumbra Black Plague - Part 18 - Listening | 18:51 |
| 21. | Vyna Gaming Nut | 193 | Lets play Penumbra Black Plague part 24 Final part | 27:27 |
| 22. | Anatomy of Fear Gaming | 154 | Penumbra Ep. 2: Black Plague (2008) - Full Playthrough (w/Commentary) | 2:50:13 |
| 23. | KatzNoir | 152 | Dad!? DAAAAADDDDD! | Penumbra: Black Plague - Part Three | 35:31 |
| 24. | SharkyHat | 108 | Penumbra: Black Plague [#6] (Sharky Plays) | 17:31 |
| 25. | Evelise | 74 | Penumbra : Black Plague | Full Game Playthrough (No Commentary) (Penumbra 2) | 3:06:20 |
| 26. | iTzMylee | 63 | DID WE DIE?! | Penumbra: Black Plague FINAL | 36:44 |
| 27. | ThePyrokin | 53 | Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague with Pyro: S6 P1: The Means To An End. | 25:20 |
| 28. | Horcalong | 45 | Penumbra: Black Plague First Playthrough Part 1 | 2:16:59 |
| 29. | Frieda Nox VODS | 41 | Penumbra: Black Plague First Playthrough (Pt. 2) | 3:45:41 |
| 30. | pyukumeru | 34 | 【Penumbra: Black Plague】Scary naked old guys | 5:55 |
| 31. | GothChild | 26 | Horror Duo with waifu - Penumbra Black Plague Complete Playthrough (Hard difficulty) | 4:34:02 |
| 32. | Neiko | 25 | Let's Play Penumbra: Black Plague, with cousin commentary! Part 3 | 1:50:35 |
| 33. | Ateriese Live | 23 | Ateriese Plays Penumbra: Black Plague - Part 7 | 30:02 |
| 34. | Absintian | 21 | Penumbra Trilogy | Clarence in my Mental Warehouse | 13 | 35:32 |
| 35. | devaliante_plays | 8 | You Had Me at "Burn It All Down" || Penumbra: Black Plague Ep. 11 FINAL || deValiante Plays | 36:27 |
| 36. | Mega Gaming | 5 | Alien Hive Mind - Penumbra: Black Plague part Final | 27:29 |
| 37. | Hazeblade Archives | 3 | Hazeblade Plays Penumbra: Black Plague! | 4:35:35 |
