| 1. |  Nikoheart | 4:09:02 | What a lovely Pony Island I'm about to venture in | 4:09:02 |
| 2. | AribethPlaysGames | 4:07:00 | Pony Island Full PC Playthrough ~ No Commentary ~ Full Stream | 4:07:00 |
| 3. | BuntaMortis | 2:59:29 | NOTHING Is What It Seems | Pony Island | Full Playthrough | 2:59:29 |
| 4. | Phoenix Nat | 2:53:21 | Pony Island - I cried with laughter for 3 hours playing this weird and wonderful game [FULL GAME] | 2:53:21 |
| 5. | Yewb | 2:46:28 | Pony Island - Blind Let's Play - Episode 5: Baphomet | 32:06 |
| 6. | PalicoPadge | 2:31:04 | Padge Plays! Indie Edition - Pony Island (2016 - Daniel Mullins Games) - Pony Island Gameplay Part 5 | 37:11 |
| 7. | MaelstromALPHA | 2:29:47 | «MaelstromALPHA» Pony Island | 2:29:47 |
| 8. | bod699 | 2:29:44 | My Playthrough of Pony Island [Twitch Highlight] | 2:29:44 |
| 9. | Broughy's Random Bits, Let's Plays & Streams | 2:27:46 | Pony Island - Part 5 - Playthrough/Let's Play | 25:56 |
| 10. | DisTurBed2236 | 2:21:11 | Pony Island - Full First Ever Playthrough | 2:21:11 |
| 11. | WebmistressL | 2:17:37 | Grind Baby, Grind! - L Plays Pony Island Extra | 2:53 |
| 12. | HexTree | 2:08:40 | Pony Island - Blind Let's Play | 2:08:40 |
| 13. | Rational Gamers | 2:04:05 | Let's Play Pony Island Ep 6 - The Final Boss!! | 10:21 |
| 14. | Edit:Ed | 2:00:27 | Let's Play Pony Island: (#4) - THE ASMODICKUS DECEPTION | 30:54 |
| 15. | Astrabee | 1:54:05 | Kyle Plays Pony Island (Full Playthrough) | 1:54:05 |
| 16. | SuperHorrorBro | 1:43:56 | BitBuddy - A Short Game From the Creator of Inscryption & Pony Island (Playthrough) | 14:49 |
| 17. | ScottishGeeks | 1:34:35 | Asmodeus.exe is a dick | Pony Island Final Episode | 33:56 |
| 18. | YagmanX | 1:29:29 | Let's Play Pony Island | DON'T TRUST THIS DEMON GAME! [Full Playthrough] | 1:29:29 |
| 19. | MGP - Games, Movies, TV & Comics | 44:15 | PAB's Picks - Pony Island | 44:15 |
| 20. | Silverlance 24 | 22:05 | Silverlance Plays - Pony Island - Hacking with my brownie powers | 22:05 |
| 21. | Randomise User: The Best Indie Games | 20:01 | Be the Volcano and BURN EVERYONE! | Eruption game demo gameplay | 8:29 |
