| 1. |  SuperDerek RPGs | Shadow Hearts Review! (PS2) The Game Collection! | 182 | Review |
| 2. |  Rafa On Crack | Koudelka | La precuela de Shadow Hearts | Review | 109 | Review |
| 3. | Trans Witch Reviews | Koudelka: An Analysis of the PS1's Best Hidden Treasure | 93 | Review |
| 4. |  BioPhoenix | BioPhoenix Game Reviews: Shadow Hearts 1 & 2 (PS2) | 83 | Review |
| 5. | AntiHeroDrink | Shadow Hearts Review | 45 | Review |
| 6. | UltimateFloyd1 | Pick My Next Review #3 (Shadow Hearts Wins) | 37 | Review |
| 7. | BioPhoenix | Shadow Farts Review | 27 | Review |
| 8. |  Fuzzy Key | Shadow Hearts Review | 24 | Review |
| 9. | Low Rank Hunter | PS2 Review: Shadow Hearts | 22 | Review |
| 10. | Retro Video Game Pickups | Jeep Thrills PS2 Review | 18 | Review |
| 11. | The Button Mappers | Game Talk "Phoenix Edition" ft.@BioPhoenixReviews | Gaming Podcast | 14 | Review |
| 12. |  Venoix | Shadow Hearts PS2 Review | 8 | Review |
| 13. | Rob L | Shadow Hearts 1 Review | 5 | Review |
| 14. | UltimateFloyd1 | Shadow Hearts Review (PS2) | 5 | Review |
| 15. | cor955 | Cor Reviews Shadow Hearts | 2 | Review |
| 16. |  The Quest Log | Was Shadow Hearts A Good or Bad RPG? | PS2 Retrospective Review | [Side Quests] | 1 | Review |
| 17. | Jaqub Ajmal | Not what I expected - Shadow Hearts Nostalgia Free Review | 1 | Review |
| 18. | House of Video Games | PSM2 reviews: "Shadow Hearts" (PS2) | 1 | Review |
| 19. | TheGamingArchaeologist | Shadow Hearts Retro Review | 1 | Review |
