| 1. |  Channel Awesome | Superman Returns - Nostalgia Critic | 725,504 | Review |
| 2. | Channel Awesome | Superman Returns - First Viewing | 152,753 | Review |
| 3. | SEAN LONG | Superman Returns Hot Toys Jor-El Movie Masterpiece 1/6 Scale Collectible Figure Review | 35,937 | Review |
| 4. | FastFoodToyReviews | 2006 SUPERMAN RETURNS set of 8 BURGER KING MOVIE COLLECTIBLES VIDEO REVIEW | 27,789 | Review |
| 5. | Drink a Beer and Play a Game | DBPG: Superman Returns Review (Xbox 360) | 17,561 | Review |
| 6. | Steve Shives | Movie Review: Superman Returns | 13,954 | Review |
| 7. | Emer Prevost | "Superman Returns" Reaction & Review | 12,372 | Review |
| 8. | Mandatory | CINEMA OF STEEL Pt 8- Superman Returns Review | 9,088 | Review |
| 9. | P1SM | Superman Returns (PS2) Review - P1SM | 8,589 | Review |
| 10. | HN Entertainment | Dark Knight 3: The Master Race #3 "Superman Returns" Recap/Review | 5,062 | Review |
| 11. | theNewBee Reviews | Superman Returns Movie Review | 4,833 | Review |
| 12. | Animated Heroes | Medicom Toy No. 150 DC Superman: Return of Superman Action Figure Review MAFEX | 3,852 | Review |
| 13. | Happy Pursuits | Return Of The King & Steel Justice BMS Toys (Kingdom Come/Superman Returns) Action Figure Review | 3,852 | Review |
| 14. | JWUniverse | Superman Returns (2006) Movie Review by JWU | 3,048 | Review |
| 15. | dHunter's Reviews | McFarlane DC Multiverse Superman & Krypto The Superdog Death Return Mullet 90's Action Figure Review | 2,832 | Review |
| 16. | Joseph Sparks | "Superman Returns" Movie Review | 2,777 | Review |
| 17. | Happy Pursuits | MashUp: KINGDOM COME & Superman Returns QUICK LOOK Action Figure Review | 1,857 | Review |
| 18. | Super HeroNexus (SuperHeroNexus) | Major New Superman Return And Red Energy Explained Superman #19 DC Rebirth (Superman Reborn Part 3) | 1,500 | Review |
| 19. | BAMPictures | Superman Returns Movie Review | 1,232 | Review |
| 20. | The Dude | Superman Returns (2006) - Movie Rant/Review | 1,189 | Review |
| 21. | Malcolm Cooper | The Movie Wizard of Oz - Superman Returns (2006) Review | 1,130 | Review |
| 22. | Radagon | Time Travel Reviews: Superman Returns | 867 | Review |
| 23. | Frederick Lopez | Superman Returns (2006) Retrospective Review | 516 | Review |
| 24. | G4ZDTechTV | X-Play Classic - Superman Returns Review | 446 | Review |
| 25. | CriticalRedemption | Superman Returns Movie Review | 161 | Review |
| 26. | Talkative Karl | Superman Returns Spoiler Review | 137 | Review |
| 27. | Bigg Cam | SUPERMAN RETURNS (2006) MOVIE REVIEW | DC REWATCH | 117 | Review |
| 28. | Benny Wan Strikes Back | Superman Returns (2006) - Movie Review | 81 | Review |
| 29. | Unique Movie Review | Superman Returns Full Movie Review And Facts / Brandon Routh / Kate Bosworth | 80 | Review |
| 30. | Malcolm Cooper | The Movie Wizard of Oz - Superman Returns (2006) Review | 64 | Review |
| 31. | RevanJJ | Superman Triple Feature Review - The BEST SUPERMAN! | 55 | Review |
| 32. | Tevya Smolka | Action comics #1055 Cyborg Superman returns review | 49 | Review |
| 33. | TheSkullKlown | Superman Returns Review | 46 | Review |
| 34. | The MAA Show | Superman Returns Review with Lois Lane RANT | 41 | Review |
| 35. | W2M Network | On Trial: Superman Returns Review | 36 | Review |
| 36. | CaptainAshSpearow | Superman Returns (2006) Review | 33 | Review |
| 37. | Oreo Brewer | #984 Superman Returns: The Prequels 2006 | 32 | Review |
| 38. | Slimguy172 | Superman Returns Review | 21 | Review |
| 39. | The Kaged Review | Superman Returns Movie Review | 18 | Review |
| 40. | MrKARproductions | Superman Returns (2006) Movie Review | 5 | Review |
| 41. | RetroLand | Movie reviews: Superman returns. | 4 | Review |
