57th Platinum:π Until Dawn. (Trophy Tip for buggy trophy "Scream Too!" in description)
057th Platinum:π Until Dawn. Trophy Tip for buggy trophy "Scream Too!": Just like for the collectables in this game, the way the game tracks (or, in cases like this, doesn't track) and saves the "Butterfly Effect" pages is all kinds of buggy and messed up. When a miscellaneous trophy such as Scream Too! is tied to a specific Butterfly Effect page, that trophy will not pop at the end of the chapter, even though you have correctly completed the requirements of the corresponding Butterfly Effect page, if that page did not save correctly. In the case of Scream Too!, it should read: "Mike hacked off his own fingers...Mike no longer had a useable machete." If it says this, the trophy will pop at the end of the chapter. Unfortunately, just because you amputated Mike's fingers and therefore no longer have a useable machete, that doesn't necessarily mean that the Butterfly Effect page saved correctly, (i.e., it may still incorrectly say "Mike still had a useable machete.") If this happens, as it did to me three times, your options are unfortunately to continue on, which is recommended, as overwriting your save file can mess up any game-spanning trophies you are going for, or, if you already have these trophies, to select the chapter from episode select. There is no foolproof way to get the Butterfly Effect pages or collectables in this game to save correctly every time and sadly there is quite a bit of incorrect information around about this.