Peer Review and the NeurIPS Experiment | Two Minute Papers #84

Channel:
Hungary Two Minute Papers
Subscribers:
1,720,000
Published on ● Video Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a1z6GXj8QK8


Category:
Review
Duration: 4:46
3,590 views
150

What is peer review and how is it done? How can we check the validity of a paper? And more importantly, how can we be sure that the peer review process is fair and consistent? We'll talk about these things and how the NIPS experiment addresses them.

____________________

The NIPS experiment:
http://blog.mrtz.org/2014/12/15/the-nips-experiment.html
http://www.kdnuggets.com/2016/05/embrace-random-acceptance-borderline-papers.html

The showcased earlier episode video:
Artistic Manipulation of Caustics - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-0KJtk07YU

A New Publishing Model in Computer Science by Yann LeCun:
http://yann.lecun.com/ex/pamphlets/publishing-models.html

WE WOULD LIKE TO THANK OUR GENEROUS PATREON SUPPORTERS WHO MAKE TWO MINUTE PAPERS POSSIBLE:
David Jaenisch, Sunil Kim, Julian Josephs, Daniel John Benton, Dave Rushton-Smith, Benjamin Kang.
https://www.patreon.com/TwoMinutePapers

We also thank Experiment for sponsoring our series. - https://experiment.com/

The thumbnail background image was created by Quinn Dombrowski (the color of the pen was changed) - https://flic.kr/p/8HRJoc
The blind man icon was created by Scott de Jonge - http://www.flaticon.com/free-icon/blind-man-silhouette_8711

Subscribe if you would like to see more of these! - http://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=keeroyz

Splash screen/thumbnail design: Felícia Fehér - http://felicia.hu

Károly Zsolnai-Fehér's links:
Facebook → https://www.facebook.com/TwoMinutePapers/
Twitter → https://twitter.com/karoly_zsolnai
Web → https://cg.tuwien.ac.at/~zsolnai/



Other Videos By Two Minute Papers


2016-09-16Estimating Matrix Rank With Neural Networks | Two Minute Papers #94
2016-09-12WaveNet by Google DeepMind | Two Minute Papers #93
2016-09-06Automatic Hair Modeling from One Image | Two Minute Papers #92
2016-09-01StyLit, Illumination-Guided Artistic Style Transfer | Two Minute Papers #91
2016-08-29Interactive Hair-Solid Simulations | Two Minute Papers #90
2016-08-253D Printing With Filigree Patterns | Two Minute Papers #89
2016-08-17Neural Material Synthesis | Two Minute Papers #88
2016-08-14On the Complexity of Two Minute Papers | Two Minute Papers #87
2016-08-11What is an Autoencoder? | Two Minute Papers #86
2016-08-08The Science of Medal Predictions (2016 Rio Olympics Edition) | Two Minute Papers #85
2016-08-03Peer Review and the NeurIPS Experiment | Two Minute Papers #84
2016-07-31Task-based Animation of Virtual Characters | Two Minute Papers #83
2016-07-29What is Optimization? + Learning Gradient Descent | Two Minute Papers #82
2016-07-25Bundlefusion: 3D Scenes from 2D Videos | Two Minute Papers #81
2016-07-20Photorealistic Images from Drawings | Two Minute Papers #80
2016-07-17Visually Indicated Sounds | Two Minute Papers #79
2016-07-13Time Varying Textures | Two Minute Papers #78
2016-07-05Fermat Spirals for Layered 3D Printing | Two Minute Papers #77
2016-06-26Procedural Yarn Models for Cloth Rendering | Two Minute Papers #76
2016-06-22What Can We Learn From Deep Learning Programs? | Two Minute Papers #75
2016-06-19Hallucinating Images With Deep Learning | Two Minute Papers #74


Tags:
two minute papers
A New Publishing Model in Computer Science
nips experiment
neural informations processing systems
nips machine learning
peer review
single blind review
double blind review
the nips experiment
paper review
academic review
paper rejected
paper rejection
minor revision
major revision
conditional acceptance
nips
machine learning nips review
nips review
academic peer review
nips reviews
the nips experiments
is peer review flawed