| 1. | Ohtani on the Dodgers MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Dodgers vs St Louis Cardinals | 254 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 2. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Texas Rangers vs Houston Astros Game 4 ALCS | 242 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 3. | MLB The Show 23 New York Yankees vs New York Mets July 26 2023 | 182 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 4. | MLB The Show 23 World Series Arizona Diamondbacks vs Texas Rangers Game 5 | 167 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 5. | MLB The Show 23 Arizona Diamondbacks vs Cincinnati Reds August 25 2023 | 150 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 6. | MLB The Show 23 Miami Marlins vs Los Angeles Dodgers | 133 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 7. | MLB The Show 23 New York Yankees vs Philadelphia Phillies April 3 2023 | 133 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 8. | MLB The Show 23 San Diego Padres vs Chicago Cubs (June 4 2023) | 121 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 9. | MLB The Show 23 Texas Rangers vs Los Angeles Dodgers | 119 | | MLB The Show 23
|
| 10. | MLB The Show 23 Atlanta Braves vs Los Angeles Angels (July 31 2023) | 118 | | MLB The Show 23
|
| 11. | MLB The Show 23 Tampa Bay Rays vs Los Angeles Dodgers May 27 2023 | 117 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 12. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Texas Rangers vs Houston Astros Game 3 ALCS | 113 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 13. | MLB The Show 23 Miami Marlins vs Philadelphia Phillies July 8 2023 | 113 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 14. | MLB The Show 23 Oakland Athletics vs Texas Rangers August 7 2023 | 100 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 15. | MLB The Show 23 Texas Rangers vs Los Angeles Angels August 14 2023 | 99 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 16. | MLB The Show 23 Houston Astros vs San Francisco Giants May 1 2023 | 99 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 17. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Dodgers vs Detroit Tigers Sept 18 2023 | 97 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 18. | MLB The Show 23 Texas Rangers vs New York Yankees April 28 2023 | 87 | | MLB The Show 23
|
| 19. | MLB The Show 23 San Diego Padres vs Los Angeles Dodgers August 4 2023 | 85 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 20. | MLB The Show 23 Chicago Cubs vs Los Angeles Dodgers (April 21 2023) | 84 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 21. | Angels vs Astros MLB The Show 23 | 83 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 22. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Philadelphia Phillies vs Atlanta Braves Game 3 NLDS | 83 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 23. | MLB The Show 23 San Diego Padres vs Texas Rangers July 29 2023 | 83 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 24. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Dodgers vs Houston Astros June 23 2023 | 82 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 25. | MLB The Show 23 Arizona Diamondbacks vs San Francisco Giants Sept 19 2023 | 78 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 26. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Dodgers vs Los Angeles Angels July 7 2023 | 77 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 27. | MLB The Show 23 Colorado Rockies vs Los Angeles Angels June 24 2023 | 76 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 28. | MLB The Show 23 San Francisco Giants vs Arizona Diamondbacks August 1 2023 | 76 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 29. | MLB The Show 23 Houston Astros vs New York Yankees | 76 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 30. | MLB The Show 23 New York Mets vs Los Angeles Dodgers July 14 2023 | 74 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 31. | MLB The Show 23 Boston Red Sox vs Los Angeles Dodgers August 25 2023 | 73 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 32. | MLB The Show 23 Washington Nationals vs Cincinnati Reds | 72 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 33. | MLB The Show 23 Puerto Rico vs Pittsburgh Pirates Diamond Dynasty | 70 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 34. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Houston Astros vs Texas Rangers Game 1 ALCS | 68 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 35. | MLB The Show 23 Philadelphia Phillies vs Los Angeles Dodgers (June 9 2023) | 64 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 36. | MLB The Show 23 New York Mets vs Cleveland Guardians | 63 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 37. | MLB The Show 23 Detroit Tigers vs Los Angeles Angels July 27 2023 | 62 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 38. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Houston Astros vs Texas Rangers Game 2 ALCS | 51 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 39. | Padres vs Phillies July 14 MLB The Show 23 | 50 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 40. | MLB The Show 23 Milwaukee Brewers vs San Diego Padres (August 25 2023) | 50 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 41. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Angels vs San Francisco Giants August 9 2023 | 50 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 42. | MLB The Show 23 Texas Rangers vs New York Yankees (April 29 2023) | 50 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 43. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Angels vs New York Yankees July 19 2023 | 49 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 44. | MLB The Show 23 Cincinnati Reds vs Arizona Diamondbacks (July 21 2023) | 48 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 45. | Dodgers vs Mets MLB The Show 23 | 47 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 46. | MLB The Show 23 New York Mets vs New York Yankees June 13 2023 | 46 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 47. | Walk off Homer MLB The Show 23 | 46 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 48. | MLB The Show 23 New York Yankees vs Texas Rangers June 25 2023 | 45 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 49. | MLB The Show 23 Tampa Bay Rays vs Detroit Tigers (march 30 2023) | 44 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 50. | MLB The Show 23 New York Mets vs Seattle Mariners | 43 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 51. | MLB The Show 23 Miami Marlins vs New York Mets (march 30 2023) | 42 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 52. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Dodgers vs Atlanta Braves August 31 2023 | 39 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 53. | White Sox vs Braves July 14 MLB The Show 23 | 39 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 54. | MLB The Show 23 Diamond Dynasty Miami Marlins vs Dominican Republic | 39 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 55. | Twins vs Athletics July 16 MLB The Show 23 pt1 | 38 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 56. | MLB The Show 23 Home Run Derby pt 2 | 37 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 57. | MLB The Show 23 San Diego Padres vs Los Angeles Dodgers August 5 2023 | 37 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 58. | Rockies vs Yankees MLB The Show 23 | 36 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 59. | MLB The Show 23 Philadelphia Phillies vs New York Mets | 35 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 60. | MLB The Show 23 Chicago White Sox vs San Francisco Giants April 3 2023 | 34 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 61. | MLB The Show 23 Puerto Rico vs Miami Marlins Diamond Dynasty | 34 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 62. | MLB The Show 23 St Louis Cardinals vs Atlanta Braves April 3 2023 | 33 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 63. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Milwaukee Brewers vs Arizona Diamondbacks Game 2 NL Wild Card | 33 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 64. | MLB The Show 23 Cincinnati Reds vs San Diego Padres | 32 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 65. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Philadelphia Phillies vs Atlanta Braves Game 4 NLDS | 31 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 66. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Philadelphia Phillies vs Arizona Diamondbacks Game 7 NLCS | 31 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 67. | MLB The Show 23 Kansas City Royals vs Toronto Blue Jays April 3 2023 | 31 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 68. | MLB The Show 23 Seattle All Star Game | 30 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 69. | MLB The Show 23 Miami Marlins vs New York Mets march 31 2023 | 30 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 70. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Houston Astros vs Minnesota Twins Game 2 ALDS | 30 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 71. | MLB The Show 23 Seattle Mariners vs Cleveland Guardians (march 30 2023) | 30 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 72. | MLB The Show 23 Miami Marlins vs Minnesota Twins April 3 2023 | 29 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 73. | Giants vs Pirates July 14 MLB The Show 23 | 29 | | MLB The Show 23
|
| 74. | MLB The Show 23 San Francisco Giants vs Texas Rangers August 12 2023 | 29 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 75. | MLB The Show 23 Chicago Cubs vs Los Angeles Dodgers | 28 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 76. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Los Angeles Dodgers vs Arizona Diamondbacks Game 2 NLDS | 28 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 77. | MLB The Show 23 Cincinnati Reds vs Los Angeles Dodgers June 6 2023 | 27 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 78. | MLB The Show 23 Washington Nationals vs Tampa Bay Rays April 5 2023 | 27 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 79. | MLB The Show 23 Houston Astros vs Los Angeles Angels August 11 2023 | 27 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 80. | MLB The Show 23 Diamond Dynasty Dominican Republic vs Texas Rangers | 27 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 81. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Angels vs Chicago White Sox June 27 2023 | 27 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 82. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Angels vs Los Angeles Dodgers June 21 2023 | 26 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 83. | MLB The Show 23 Texas Rangers vs Baltimore Orioles April 3 2023 | 26 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 84. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Houston Astros vs Texas Rangers Game 7 ALCS | 25 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 85. | Red Sox vs Cubs July 16 MLB The Show 23 | 25 | | MLB The Show 23
|
| 86. | MLB The Show 23 Miami Marlins vs New York Mets April 1 2023 | 24 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 87. | MLB The Show 23 Texas Rangers vs Philadelphia Phillies April 1 2023 | 24 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 88. | MLB The Show 23 Criollos de Caguas vs Los Angeles Dodgers Diamond Dynasty | 24 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 89. | MLB The Show 23 Postseason Philadelphia Phillies vs Miami Marlins Game 1 NL Wild Card | 24 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 90. | MLB The Show 23 Japan vs Chicago White Sox Diamond Dynasty | 24 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 91. | MLB The Show 23 Oakland Athletics vs Los Angeles Angels (march 30 2023) | 23 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 92. | MLB The Show 23 Houston Astros vs New York Mets | 23 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 93. | MLB The Show 23 Atlanta Braves vs New York Mets August 23 2023 | 23 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 94. | MLB The Show 23 Oakland Athletics vs Cleveland Guardians April 3 2023 | 23 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 95. | MLB The Show 23 Washington Nationals vs Tampa Bay Rays April 3 2023 | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 96. | MLB The Show 23 Washington Nationals vs Atlanta Braves march 30 2023 | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 97. | MLB The Show 23 Cincinnati Reds vs Chicago Cubs | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 98. | MLB The Show 23 St. Louis Cardinals vs Los Angeles Angels may 3 2023 | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 99. | MLB The Show 23 Cincinnati Reds vs Pittsburgh Pirates march 30 2023 | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 100. | MLB The Show 23 Los Angeles Angels vs Boston Red Sox | 20 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
