| 1. | MLB Week 1 NYY vs BAL | 3:23:26 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 2. | MLB ALDS NYY vs LAA Game 2 | 2:52:24 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 3. | MLB Week 12 SEA vs NYY | 2:33:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 4. | MLB World Series ARI vs NYY Game 5 | 2:27:14 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 5. | MLB Week 14 NYY vs BOS | 2:17:16 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 6. | MLB Wild Card Game NYY vs TOR | 2:16:16 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 7. | MLB Week 19 NYY vs KC | 2:00:57 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 8. | MLB Week 20 NYY vs CHW | 1:59:28 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 9. | MLB Week 4 NYY vs OAK | 1:55:36 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 10. | MLB Week 9 NYY vs TOR | 1:55:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 11. | MLB ALCS BOS vs NYY Game 4 | 1:47:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 12. | MLB Week 21 TOR vs NYY | 1:46:18 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 13. | MLB All Star Game | 1:38:56 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 14. | MLB ALCS BOS vs NYY Game 3 | 1:37:54 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 15. | MLB ALCS BOS vs NYY Game 5 | 1:33:56 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 16. | MLB ALCS NYY vs BOS Game 1 | 1:33:39 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 17. | MLB ALCS NYY vs BOS Game 2 | 1:31:07 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 18. | MLB ALDS NYY vs LAA Game 1 | 1:29:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 19. | MLB Week 16 CHC vs NYY | 1:28:46 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 20. | MLB World Series NYY vs ARI Game 2 | 1:25:09 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 21. | MLB ALDS NYY vs LAA Game 5 | 1:24:56 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 22. | MLB Week 23 TB vs NYY | 1:23:56 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 23. | MLB Week 18 LAA vs NYY | 1:23:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 24. | MLB ALDS LAA vs NYY Game 4 | 1:19:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 25. | MLB Week 8 CLE vs NYY | 1:15:14 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 26. | MLB Week 22 HOU vs NYY | 1:15:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 27. | MLB Week 11 NYY vs MIL | 1:13:58 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 28. | MLB ALCS NYY vs BOS Game 7 | 1:13:06 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 29. | MLB Week 3 BAL vs NYY | 1:04:34 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 30. | MLB Week 5 NYY vs TEX | 1:03:42 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 31. | MLB Week 2 NYY vs TB | 1:03:24 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 32. | MLB Week 6 CIN vs NYY | 1:03:14 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 33. | MLB Week 7 NYY vs DET | 59:20 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 34. | MLB Week 11 NYY vs MIL | 10:02 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 35. | MLB Week 18 LAA vs NYY | 9:08 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 36. | MLB Week 20 NYY vs CHW | 7:04 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 37. | MLB Week 1 NYY vs BAL | 2:02 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 38. | MLB Week 17 NYY vs STL | 1:56 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 39. | MLB Week 1 NYY vs BAL | 1:54 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 40. | MLB ALCS BOS vs NYY Game 4 | 0:22 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 41. | MLB World Series NYY vs ARZ | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 42. | MLB Week 7 NYY vs DET | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 43. | PS5 MLB Season Game 19 NYY VS TOR | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 44. | PS5 MLB Season Game 149 BOS VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 45. | PS5 MLB Season Game 12 MIA VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 46. | PS5 MLB Season Game 137 STL VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 47. | PS5 MLB Season Game 52 SEA VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 48. | PS5 MLB Season Game 39 HOU VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 49. | PS5 MLB Season Game 39 HOU VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 50. | PS5 MLB Season Game 99 TB VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 51. | PS5 MLB Season Game 45 NYY VS MIN | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 52. | PS5 MLB Season Game 26 OAK VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 53. | PS5 MLB Season Game 77 BAL VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 54. | PS5 MLB Season Game 45 NYY VS MIN | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 55. | PS5 MLB Season Game 118 TEX VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 56. | PS5 MLB Season Game 60 NYY VS SF | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 57. | PS5 MLB Season Game 137 STL VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 58. | PS5 MLB Season Game 48 CWS VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 59. | PS5 MLB Season Game 69 NYY VS KC | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 60. | PS5 MLB Season Game 43 NYY VS MIN | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 61. | PS5 MLB Season Game 65 LAD VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 62. | PS5 MLB World Series Game 1 NYY VS PIT | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 63. | PS5 MLB Season Game 35 DET VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 64. | PS5 MLB Season Game 44 NYY VS MIN | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 65. | PS5 MLB Season Game 41 NYY VS TB | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 66. | PS5 MLB Season Game 42 NYY VS TB | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 67. | PS5 MLB Season Game 56 NYY VS LAA | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 68. | PS5 MLB Season Game 26 OAK VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 69. | PS5 MLB Season Game 135 STL VS NYY | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 70. | PS5 MLB Season Game 42 NYY VS TB | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
| 71. | PS5 MLB Season Game 58 NYY VS LAA | 0:00 | | MLB The Show 20
|
