| 1. | What If Wubbox and Rare Wubbox were on Psychic Island (Ft. Raw Zebra) | 3,566 | |
|
| 2. | Tinkerer Island | Full Song | 2,622 | |
|
| 3. | Magical Madness | Full Song | 1,488 | |
|
| 4. | What If Bone Island had Air instead of Bone | 1,434 | |
|
| 5. | Wublin Island | Cover | 1,200 | |
|
| 6. | What If: Fire Oasis had Earth Instead of Water | 1,009 | |
|
| 7. | What If Monculus was on Ethereal Island | ANIMATED | ft. @GHOSTYMPA | 930 | |
|
| 8. | Amber Island | Cover | 916 | |
|
| 9. | What If Faerie Island had Water instead of Faerie | 786 | |
|
| 10. | Making an MSM Island Out of Random Monsters | 748 | |
|
| 11. | What If: Fire Haven was a Quint Island (Full Song) | 736 | |
|
| 12. | Fire Oasis | Cover | 735 | |
|
| 13. | Plant Island | Cover | 733 | |
|
| 14. | What If Psychic Island had Cold instead of Psychic | 701 | |
|
| 15. | Amber Island Wave 13 | Cover | 688 | |
|
| 16. | Seasonal Shanty | Cover | 684 | |
|
| 17. | What If: Ethereal Workshop Had the Original Ethereals | 614 | |
|
| 18. | What If: Fire Haven had Water Instead of Air | 589 | |
|
| 19. | Earth Island | Cover | 588 | |
|
| 20. | Amber Island Wave 11 | Cover | 576 | |
|
| 21. | What If: Cave Island was played by Bone Island Monsters | 570 | |
|
| 22. | What If: Amber Island had Fire Magicals (Ft. @Mint_loll) | 559 | |
|
| 23. | Amber Island | What If (Ft. Raw Zebra) | 558 | |
|
| 24. | What If: Party Island was played by Light Island Monsters | 555 | |
|
| 25. | Space Island | Cover | 537 | |
|
| 26. | Jungle Island | Full Song | 519 | |
|
| 27. | Ethereal Workshop | Cover (Update 1) | 512 | |
|
| 28. | Mythical Island | Cover | 511 | |
|
| 29. | Cave Island | Cover | 509 | |
|
| 30. | What If: Fire Oasis was a Quint Island (Full Song) | 486 | |
|
| 31. | What If Light Island had Earth instead of Light (#MSM10MAGICAL) | 466 | |
|
| 32. | What If: Seasonal Shanty Sounded Like a Sea Shanty | 465 | |
|
| 33. | Amber Island Wave 6 | Cover | 457 | |
|
| 34. | Cold Island | Cover | 455 | |
|
| 35. | Amber Island | Prediction (Wave 4) | 449 | |
|
| 36. | What If: Space Island was played by Psychic Island Monsters | 442 | |
|
| 37. | Magical Sanctum | Cover | 434 | |
|
| 38. | Tinkerer Island | Rack of Liquoir | 431 | |
|
| 39. | Ethereal Workshop | Update 1 Prediction | 418 | |
|
| 40. | Ethereal Workshop | Cover (Update 2) | 402 | |
|
| 41. | Celestial Island | Cover | 401 | |
|
| 42. | What If: Dark Island had Fire Instead of Dark | 395 | |
|
| 43. | What If: Cloud Island was played by Faerie Island Monsters | 392 | |
|
| 44. | What If: The Tinkerer Monsters were on Magical Nexus | 374 | |
|
| 45. | Ethereal Workshop | Cover (Update 4) | 369 | |
|
| 46. | Ethereal Workshop | Cover (Update 3) | 349 | |
|
| 47. | Tinkerer Island | The Tinkerer | 324 | |
|
| 48. | What If: Ethereal Workshop Had the Original Ethereals | Full Song | 321 | |
|
| 49. | Desolate Drift | Full Song | 319 | |
|
| 50. | Tinkerer Island | Update 1 (8/15) | 316 | |
|
| 51. | Ethereal Workshop | Cover (Update 5) | 312 | |
|
| 52. | Water Island | Cover | 307 | |
|
| 53. | Psychic Island | Cover | 295 | |
|
| 54. | Tribal Island | Cover | 292 | |
|
| 55. | What If: The Other Mythicals Were on Monstriana's Arcanum | 291 | |
|
| 56. | Starhenge | Cover | 282 | |
|
| 57. | Tinkerer Island | Gobbleygourd | 279 | |
|
| 58. | Fire Haven | Cover | 277 | |
|
| 59. | #msmpyp2024 | JakeTheDrake's Entry | 273 | |
|
| 60. | Ethereal Island | Cover | 271 | |
|
| 61. | Cavernous Cove | Kurmit ANIMATED (Ft. Professor Toot) | 268 | |
|
| 62. | Bone Island | Cover | 262 | |
|
| 63. | What If Punkleton on Season Shanty sounded like the original | 255 | |
|
| 64. | Ethereal Workshop | Cover (Full Song) | 248 | |
|
| 65. | Shugabush Island | Cover | 248 | |
|
| 66. | Mythical Island | Prediction | 243 | |
|
| 67. | Celestial Tomb | Othermuther | 242 | |
|
| 68. | Ancient Anomaly | Full Song | 236 | |
|
| 69. | Amber Island Wave 8 | Cover | 232 | |
|
| 70. | Amber Island | Remix | 230 | |
|
| 71. | Light Island but it is Better (in my opinion) | 229 | |
|
| 72. | Ethereal Workshop Wave 5 | Remix | 223 | |
|
| 73. | Light Island | Kurmit | (real) | 222 | |
|
| 74. | Dark Island | Cover / Remake | 219 | |
|
| 75. | so basically i modded MSM in Steam | 217 | |
|
| 76. | Tinkerer Island | Sindrok | 213 | |
|
| 77. | Celestial Tomb | Torrt | 210 | |
|
| 78. | Magical Nexus | Acapella Cover | 208 | |
|
| 79. | Tinkerer Island | Voudoul | 208 | |
|
| 80. | #CreateACryptidContest entry | 205 | |
|
| 81. | Ghost Kurmit | #eerielandscapecollab entry | 205 | |
|
| 82. | Fire Oasis | Mimic and Wubbox Prediction | 200 | |
|
| 83. | Magical Nexus | Cover | 200 | |
|
| 84. | They Call Me JakeTheDrake | Original Song | 194 | |
|
| 85. | Celestial Tomb | Vibrane | 193 | |
|
| 86. | Tinkerer Island | Folliustruc | 185 | |
|
| 87. | What If: the Psychic Magicals were on Space Island | 183 | |
|
| 88. | Amber Island Wave 3 | Cover | 183 | |
|
| 89. | Bone Island | Remix | 182 | |
|
| 90. | Light Island | Cover | 181 | |
|
| 91. | Celestial Tomb | Biidea | 181 | |
|
| 92. | What If: the Adult Celestials Had Their Own Song | 180 | |
|
| 93. | Seasonal Shanty | Cover | Update 6 | 180 | |
|
| 94. | Celestial Tomb | Fosssyle | 180 | |
|
| 95. | Magical Sanctum | Remix | 179 | |
|
| 96. | Tinkerer Island | Aractick | 177 | |
|
| 97. | What If: Fire Haven was a Quint Island (Individuals) | 172 | |
|
| 98. | What If: Mimic Was on Tribal Island | 171 | |
|
| 99. | Celestial Tomb | Loodvigg | 171 | |
|
| 100. | What If: Gnarls was on Jungle Island (Ft. @Mint_loll and @Ramenationss) | 171 | |
|
