| 1. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (4) - Women and Cattle, Wild Horses Tamed Passions | 51,595 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 2. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (8) - Hanging Bonnie McFarlane, Treasure Rank 4 | 29,231 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 3. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (42) - Rare Weapons, American Lobbyist, Bear One Another's Burdens | 19,078 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 4. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (7) - The Burning, Survivalist Rank 3, | 14,348 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 5. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (6) - Old Swindler Blues | 10,412 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 6. | Undead Nightmare 100% (10) - Filth and Other Entertainment | 9,951 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 7. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (9) - Bounty Hunting | 9,944 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 8. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (10) - Exhuming and Other Fine Hobbies | 9,548 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 9. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (11) - Liars Cheats and Other Proud Americans | 8,953 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 10. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (29) - Funny Man #4, Reyes' Rebels Outfit Scrap #5 | 7,930 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 11. | Undead Nightmare 100% (01) - Love in the Time of Plague, Blackwater | 7,496 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 12. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (22) - Lucky In Love, Outfit Scraps | 5,992 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 13. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (54) - Pestilence, Old Friends New Problems, Sharpshooter Rank 9 | 5,449 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 14. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (20) - Landon Ricketts Rides Again | 5,397 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 15. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (30) - Mexican Caesar | 5,356 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 16. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (50) - The Wronged Woman #2, At Home with Dutch, The Prohibitionist | 5,346 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 17. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (53) - And You Will Know The Truth, The Outlaw's Return | 4,631 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 18. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (37) - Father Abraham, Love is the Opiate #2 | 4,460 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 19. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (23) - The Mexican Wagon Train | 4,426 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 20. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (40) - An Appointed Time | 4,072 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 21. | Red Dead Redemption 100% (38) - Captain De Santa's Downfall | 4,028 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 22. | Undead Nightmare 100% (14) - American Imperialism, Undead Hunter 2-3, Sharpshooter Rank 4 | 2,271 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 23. | Undead Nightmare 100% (19) - Biographies and Lies, El Matadero, Torquemada | 1,790 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
| 24. | Undead Nightmare 100% (16) - Tesoro Azul, Chuparosa | 1,689 | | Red Dead Redemption
|
