| 1. | ProbablyJacob | The Halloween 2018 Special | 686 | Review |
| 2. | GameSpot | GameSpot Reviews - Costume Quest Review | 153 | Review |
| 3. | CGRundertow | CGR Undertow - COSTUME QUEST for Xbox 360 Video Game Review | 80 | Review |
| 4. | Bytejacker | Bytejacker - AWESOME Indie Halloween Game - Costume Quest Review | 80 | Review |
| 5. |  Андроид Андройдыч | Costume Quest - Приключение с элементами РПГ на Android(Обзор/Review) | 57 | Review |
| 6. | CGRundertow | CGR Undertow - COSTUME QUEST: GRUBBINS ON ICE DLC for Xbox 360 Video Game Review | 56 | Review |
| 7. |  Parliamo di Videogiochi | [360][PS3] Stacking | Review [parliamodivideogiochi.it] | 35 | Review |
| 8. | Parliamo di Videogiochi | [360] Costume Quest | Review | 35 | Review |
| 9. |  Cosmosis | Trick or Treat!! - Costume Quest | Cosmosis | 28 | Review |
| 10. | Recommended Playing | Costume Quest Review - Steam (Recommended Playing) | 26 | Review |
| 11. | UltimateChance | Costume Quest - Review | 25 | Review |
| 12. | StephsTooDef | Costume Quest Review (PSN/XBLA) | 25 | Review |
| 13. | PrinceFlannel | PrinceFlannel Reviews - Costume Quest | 23 | Review |
| 14. | Should You Play It? | Costume Quest | REVIEW & GAMEPLAY - Should you play it? | 19 | Review |
| 15. | Game & Gig | Non-scary Halloween Vibes | Costume Quest | One-Minute Game Review | 18 | Review |
| 16. | SuperkenGaming | Costume Quest Review [PS3, Xbox 360, & PC] | 17 | Review |
| 17. | Totally Tubular Jonathan | Costume Quest 1 & 2 Review: A Wholesome Halloween | 14 | Review |
| 18. |  Random Encounter | Random Encounter #17 (fo'real) - Teil 2/2 - Costume Quest & Scott Pilgrim vs. the World Review | 13 | Review |
| 19. | Random Encounter | Random Encounter #27 - Teil 2/2 - Games for Windows Live, Costume Quest Review / Test | 13 | Review |
| 20. | Locke Vincent | Costume Quest Review | Halloween Horror | 10 | Review |
| 21. | GameTrailers | Costume Quest - GameTrailers Review Pod | 10 | Review |
| 22. |  AlMoDi - обзоры игр и техники | Costume Quest review - clear without words. Обзор Costume Quest - понятно и без слов :) AlMoDi | 8 | Review |
| 23. | The Escapist | Costume Quest: Grubbins on Ice Review | 8 | Review |
| 24. | Kalice | Why You Should Play Costume Quest [Review] | 7 | Review |
| 25. | Darkening Demise | Costume Quest, Just Play It | Demise Reviews | 7 | Review |
| 26. | Adam the Fanatic | The Fanatic Reviews: Costume Quest - A Halloween-themed RPG by Double Fine Productions | 7 | Review |
| 27. | Yessik Ziiiq | Costume Quest Review | 6 | Review |
| 28. | Block's Gaming Reviews | Costume Quest - Horror Game Review | 6 | Review |
| 29. |  SuperGnome | Отжимаем конфеты в игре costume quest | 5 | Review |
| 30. |  Atecep | Costume Quest - Mini Review | 6 | Review |
| 31. | TWK REVIEWS | Costume Quest 1 and 2 || TWK Reviews Episode 45 | 4 | Review |
| 32. | Dadacity | Grandpa Reviews Costume Quest | 4 | Review |
| 33. |  MogAnarchy | Mog Anarchy Reviews: Costume Quest | 3 | Review |
| 34. | 4-8Productions | 4-8Reviews - Costume Quest | 3 | Review |
| 35. | Clayton Games | Costume Quest | Review & How to Play | 3 | Review |
| 36. | Big_Adam_2050 | [Costume Quest] - The Review. | 2 | Review |
| 37. | Icynato | Costume Quest: A Review | 2 | Review |
| 38. |  El Holandes Errante | Costume Quest - Gameplay Castellano - Review | 2 | Review |
| 39. |  The Cheapness Review | STACKING Review | 2 | Review |
| 40. | Tiger Castle | Costume Quest (PS3) | Tiger Castle Reviews RPGs | 2 | Review |
| 41. | Beefy Thiefy | Spook-Tacular 4 - Costume Quest | 1 | Review |
| 42. | The Cheapness Review | COSTUME QUEST Review | 1 | Review |
| 43. | TrashThingz Reviews | Costume quest 1 vs 2 Review | 1 | Review |
| 44. | ReviewZoneHD | PS3 Costume Quest Review -- ReviewZoneHD | 1 | Review |
| 45. | HEROREAPER | Costume Quest PS3 Review, 13 Days of Halloween. | 1 | Review |
| 46. | DchanZockt | #3 COSTUME QUEST: GRUBBINS ON ICE | Tagesmotto: VIVA REPUGIA! + MONSTERS TV-Review | [Deutsch] [HD] | 0 | Review |
| 47. | ZBspriggan | Costume Quest - Thursday | Halloween Vibrations (Wishlist review later) | 0 | Review |
| 48. | Saloz94 | In My Opinion-Costume Quest Series S Ramble Review | 0 | Review |
| 49. | The Cheapness Review | STACKING Review in 60 Seconds #shorts | 0 | Review |
| 50. | Jlink Master Archive | Costume Quest Steam REVIEW | 0 | Review |
| 51. | The Cheapness Review | COSTUME QUEST Review in 60 Seconds #shorts | 3 | Review |
| 52. | The Loud Siblings Fan A.K.A. Mr. J.T. | CGR Undertow - COSTUME QUEST for XBOX 360 Video Game Review | 0 | Review |
| 53. | Ghost Incorporated | Costume Quest - Quick Review | 0 | Review |
| 54. | ShabbyGurl | COSTUME QUEST for Xbox 360 Video Game Review | 0 | Review |
| 55. | ChoaslegionKaeru | Mini-Review - Costume Quest #shorts #videogames #costumequest #twitch | 0 | Review |
| 56. | Dose of Nerd Acumen | Costume Quest, Review (retro DNA) #tbt #fbf | 0 | Review |
| 57. | ShabbyGurl | COSTUME QUEST GRUBBINS ON ICE DLC for Xbox 360 Video Game Review | 0 | Review |
