| 1. |  Ashkatom | 2:57:17 | Pony Island | [Full Game] | 2:57:17 |
| 2. | Bezies Gaming | 2:56:09 | The Game Awards 2023 I Beziesgaming Reacts | 2:56:09 |
| 3. | Tonbuba VODs | 2:37:33 | Found a super wholesome lovely game with some bugs [AUS] [18+] 17/06/2022 | 2:37:33 |
| 4. | Wiccy | 2:22:19 | [AUS Vtuber] Wiccy playing Pony Island. [1/1] [END] | 2:22:19 |
| 5. | Mapocolops | 2:21:15 | The Pony Island Experience | Full Blind Playthrough | 2:21:15 |
| 6. | Daimono Streams | 2:13:50 | Wierd Weekends! Pony Island (PC) Part 3 (FINAL) - FREEDOM FOR ALL! | 36:57 |
| 7. | Daget Streams | 2:08:52 | Daget Plays: Pony Island (Part 6) | 17:34 |
| 8. | Rhapsody | 2:02:39 | Let's Play Pony Island: Uninstall - Episode 6 [FINALE] | 12:08 |
| 9. | Toon Key | 1:56:03 | Pony Island Part 6 :Final | 28:09 |
| 10. | rayjchrist | 1:55:52 | Pony Island Blind Playthrough Part 3 (Final) | 28:03 |
| 11. | Fox Plays | 1:31:55 | The End - Pony Island part 3 - Fox Plays | 29:11 |
| 12. | FingerRocks11 | 1:27:28 | Top 5 - Reasons why I love Pony Island | 0:53 |
| 13. | tinyPandaBot | 1:24:26 | Army of Ponies || PONY ISLAND Gameplay 3 Fin | 23:46 |
| 14. | xJuliettex | 1:17:15 | Pony Island Is The WEIRDEST Game I've Ever Played | 1:17:15 |
| 15. | Each To Their Own | 1:10:37 | The 2023 Game Awards Were Wrong | ETTO's Catch Up 068 | 1:10:37 |
| 16. | The Clumsy King | 59:31 | 3ͪ̑ͥ̄̒̀ͯ̈́ͮ͂ͭ͝҉̷̯͇̯̻̮̦̦̟͎͚͓͇̮̲͎̫ | 17:17 |
| 17. | MystFro | 44:11 | HUGE DEMON BATTLE!! | Pony Island #3 | 25:19 |
| 18. | Fynnpire | 39:15 | Pony Island Puzzle Game #2 - RPG ADVENTURE MODE & WINGS - Pony Island Weird Puzzle | 22:47 |
| 19. | D1DLC | 33:15 | D1DLC Plays: Pony Island Part 2 | 22:48 |
| 20. | CHG - AUSSIE GAMING | 22:45 | HEROES AND PONIES - The Budget #1 | 22:45 |
| 21. | UPC | 16:08 | Pony Island (Gameplay) | 16:08 |
| 22. | MiniBetrayal | 15:55 | MiniBetrayal Plays: Pony Island | 15:55 |
| 23. | GetTanked | 15:07 | HOW TO SELL YOUR SOUL - EightBit Plays Pony Island Gameplay Walkthrough Part 2 | 8:44 |
| 24. | TheWarship | 13:07 | THIS IS FINE. | Pony Island #1 | 13:07 |
| 25. | tr1ppa | 10:48 | Pony Island Gameplay [PC/60FPS/1080p] | 10:48 |
| 26. | R E T R O F A L L | 8:02 | PONY ISLAND // The First 8 Minutes | 8:02 |
| 27. | ABC Gamer | 7:50 | Pony Island - Review | 7:50 |
| 28. | TheRealGMat | 4:25 | Playsterbation - Pony Island | 4:25 |
| 29. | ImWithRedShirt | 4:01 | Best of Pony Island | 4:01 |
