| 1. |  PushingUpRoses | This is the Best Video Game I've Played In A Long Time | 882 | Review |
| 2. | IGN | Return to Monkey Island Review | 380 | Review |
| 3. |  PC Games | Return to Monkey Island | REVIEW | Da scheiden sich die Geister(piraten) - Test ohne Spoiler! | 256 | Review |
| 4. | IGN | Monkey Island Updates Stop After Online Abuse - IGN Daily Fix | 220 | Review |
| 5. |  SwitchUp | Return To Monkey Island Nintendo Switch Review! | 213 | Review |
| 6. | onaretrotip | Return to Monkey Island - A Return to Glory? | REVIEW | 173 | Review |
| 7. | Nintendo Life | Return to Monkey Island Nintendo Switch Review - Is It Worth It? | 119 | Review |
| 8. |  Jopovania | Lo Bueno y lo Malo de RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND - La Review de Jopo | 118 | Review |
| 9. | Gamesground | Das Ende einer Legende? Return to Monkey Island Review / Test | 107 | Review |
| 10. | GameSpot | Return To Monkey Island Review | 88 | Review |
| 11. |  GamingBolt | Return To Monkey Island Review - The Final Verdict | 85 | Review |
| 12. | PC Gamer | Return to Monkey Island Review | PC Gamer | 67 | Review |
| 13. | GamersGlobal | Return to Monkey Island im Test: Ein Nostalgie-Fest (Switch, Review, German) | 65 | Review |
| 14. | MrJamesGames | Return to Monkey Island Review (Deutsch) 2022 | Gummi oder Stahl? | 62 | Review |
| 15. | Couch Coop | 'Nostalgia Wowzah' Return To Monkey Island Review | 48 | Review |
| 16. | Consequences | Return to Monkey Island First Impressions Review (A Mighty No-Spoiler Look) | 36 | Review |
| 17. |  Gamekings | Return to Monkey Island Review: Kopen, budgetbak of slopen? | 31 | Review |
| 18. | heise & c't | Altes Genre, neuer Charme! | "Return to Monkey Island" im Test | 31 | Review |
| 19. | CohhCarnage | CohhCarnage's Thoughts On Return To Monkey Island | 31 | Review |
| 20. |  Escalera Offbeat | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND: "¿ha sido todo lo que esperaba?" | Review | 27 | Review |
| 21. | GamesRadar | Return to Monkey Island Review | 27 | Review |
| 22. | Un Gamer Madrileño | PRIMER ANALISIS RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND Gameplay Resumen Review Return to Monkey Island Final | 23 | Review |
| 23. | Eryuyu “El Manicomio de Eryuyu” | VOLVEMOS a MONKEY ISLAND 30 AÑOS DESPUES - RETURN to MONKEY ISLAND Gameplay Español | 23 | Review |
| 24. | wiiviewr | Return to Monkey Island Review (Nintendo Switch) | 21 | Review |
| 25. |  PsyDogs 250 | Return to Monkey Island Review | 19 | Review |
| 26. | Orkenspalter TV | Return to Monkey Island: Was ist jetzt eigentlich das Geheimnis? Review mit Mháire und Nico | 19 | Review |
| 27. |  Deckard Games | Return to Monkey Island - Review | 14 | Review |
| 28. |  TechPlay | Return to Monkey Island // review | 10 | Review |
| 29. | Adventure Game Hotspot | The Best Point and Click Adventure Games of 2022 | 9 | Review |
| 30. | Napyet Gaming | Ron Gilbert's Monkey Island Trilogy - Retrospective & Review | 9 | Review |
| 31. |  ABC Gamer | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND is a Return to Form – PLAY OR PASS | 9 | Review |
| 32. | SHOOK EARTH MEDIA | A Lucasarts CLASSIC is BACK! Return to Monkey Island Review! | 9 | Review |
| 33. | Joserra y sus cosicas | Return to Monkey Island - Review | 8 | Review |
| 34. |  Justpauseit | Return to Monkey Island | Review | Test | Nintendo Switch | PS5 | 8 | Review |
| 35. | MakaStory | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND - VUELVE LA AVENTURA LEGENDARIA - ANALISIS - GAMEPLAY - REVIEW | 8 | Review |
| 36. |  Talon Gaming | Return To Monkey Island - The Nostalgia runs rampant!! | 7 | Review |
| 37. |  GamersPackIL | Return to Monkey Island review / ביקורת | 7 | Review |
| 38. |  jexux | Return To Monkey Island Una Secuela Ahora Para Android【 Review 】 | 6 | Review |
| 39. | Split-Screen | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND - REVIEW | 5 | Review |
| 40. | IGN China | IGN 9分,《重返猴島》遊戲評測 Return to Monkey Island Review | 5 | Review |
| 41. | 游戏的乐趣 | 重返猴岛 / 重返猴島 Return to Monkey Island Gameplay | 4 | Review |
| 42. | Destructoid | Return to Monkey Island Review | 4 | Review |
| 43. | Hazzer | Should you Return to Monkey Island? | A subjective review | 4 | Review |
| 44. | Bower's Game Corner | Return To Monkey Island 1 Hour Review. An AMAZING First Impression 😯 🙊 🏝 | 4 | Review |
| 45. | Amir Satvat | Review Of Return to Monkey Island In 25 Points | 3 | Review |
| 46. | Games-Mag | Return to Monkey Island | Nintendo Switch | REVIEW | 3 | Review |
| 47. |  Studio 47G (Studio47G) | Return to Monkey Island | Gameplay Review (PS5) | Game of the Year 2022 | Game Award 2022 | 2 | Review |
| 48. |  Retro Eric | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND VALE A PENA? ANÁLISE - REVIEW | 2 | Review |
| 49. | Pixel Bandits | Return to Monkey Island Review | 2 | Review |
| 50. | waveewave | Return To Monkey Island is a classic - LIGHT SPOILERS | 2 | Review |
| 51. | cub | Return to Monkey Island Is Pretty Good… Even as a Newcomer! [PC] | 2 | Review |
| 52. |  Escape Game Show | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND - KAKO DA POSTANETE PIRAT [PC RECENZIJA] | 2 | Review |
| 53. | Mojos SpieleOlymp | Return to Monkey Island Review deutsch | 2 | Review |
| 54. | Starved For Time | Return to Monkey Island review. Is it good? | 2 | Review |
| 55. | Napyet Gaming | Is RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND Any Good? (Review) | 2 | Review |
| 56. | elreino.net | 🏴☠️ RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND es nostálgico, contradictorio y DIVERTIDO 🐵 ANÁLISIS RESEÑA SWITCH PC | 1 | Review |
| 57. | Uns Caras Que Jogam | RETURN TO MONKEY ISLAND VALE A PENA? ANÁLISE/CRÍTICA PT-BR [REVIEW EXPRESSO] | 1 | Review |
| 58. | El Holandes Errante | Return to Monkey Island - Review - Análisis - Gameplay del juego en Steam 🤔 Merece la pena??? | 1 | Review |
