| 1. |  Pagey | Multiple Superman Return, Multiverse Batman and More! - Crisis on Infinite Earths Complete Recap | 53,599 | |
| 2. | PixelShaun | Was The Superman Returns Game REALLY That Bad? | 45,828 | |
| 3. | Pagey | Smallville Superman Returns for Crisis Confirmed! What Does THIS Mean? | 32,334 | |
| 4. | B4Brandoss | Superman's BEST Video Game (It Still Sucks) | 21,688 | |
| 5. | Pagey | Future Flash Teaser! Future Green Arrow is VITAL? Kingdom Come Superman Return? - The Flash Season 8 | 19,219 | |
| 6. | Pagey | Supergirl 2x22 FINALE Trailer Breakdown! - Superman Returns! | 18,927 | |
| 7. | Mary Cherry | First Time Watching Superman Returns: is it the most underrated #Superman movie? | 16,899 | |
| 8. | Pagey | NEW Superboy vs Luthor's Gang! Superman Returns! - Superman and Lois 4x04 Trailer Breakdown! | 13,086 | |
| 9. | Pagey | Superman Returns! HUGE Changes Revealed! - Superman and Lois 4x04 Review! | 12,358 | |
| 10. | iVoltex | This Superman OPEN WORLD Game Is TRULY PERFECT | 3,693 | |
| 11. | Fortress of Solitude | SUPERMAN RETURNS | DCEASED: War of The Undead Gods #1 IN-DEPTH REVIEW & STORYTIME | 2,437 | Review |
| 12. | Fortress of Solitude | INJUSTICE SUPERMAN RETURNS - Adventures of Superman #2 Quick Review | 1,931 | Review |
| 13. | Fortress of Solitude | INJUSTICE SUPERMAN RETURNS | Adventures of Superman: Jon Kent #2 Review + Storytime | 1,780 | Review |
| 14. | Fortress of Solitude | Superman Returns & Cancelled Movies | Superman in Media Part 10 | 1,440 | Review |
| 15. | Fortress of Solitude | Superman Returns | Nightwing: The New Order #5 Review | 845 | Review |
| 16. | Uncle Chunt | Superman Returns to Crush Car | 796 | |
| 17. | NeoPass - Your Pass to Gaming | Superman's Dilemma: Save Civilians or Catch the Villain First? | 774 | |
| 18. | Fortress of Solitude | Superman Returns | Injustice 2 #43-44 Review | 772 | Review |
| 19. | PixelShaun | Remembering Superman Returns PS2 | 707 | |
| 20. | Fortress of Solitude | Superman #14 Review [Red Son Superman Returns!] | 703 | Review |
| 21. | NeoPass - Your Pass to Gaming | Will Superman Ever Get the Game He Deserves? | 516 | |
| 22. | Uncle Chunt | Superman Returns - Chunt of Steel #1 (Xbox 360) | 492 | |
| 23. | TheEgyptianGamerGeek | Superman Returns + JL 2017 DVD Unboxing | 316 | |
| 24. | NeoPass - Your Pass to Gaming | Why Superman STILL Has No Game… | 189 | |
| 25. | OLNEnigmaStJimmy | Superman Returns Playthrough Pt 3 (Bizarro Final Battle, Overkhast & Mongul Battles) | 167 | |
| 26. | OLNEnigmaStJimmy | Superman Returns Playthrough Pt 2 (Giant Metallo & Bizarro Battles) | 118 | |
| 27. | OLNEnigmaStJimmy | Superman Returns Playthrough Pt 1 The Man Of Steel (Superman) | 111 | |
| 28. | HJ's Corner | Superman Returns (Gametrailers Review) (PC/Xbox/Gamecube/PS2) | 61 | Review |
| 29. | OLNEnigmaStJimmy | Superman Returns Playthrough Pt 4 (The Ending) | 36 | |
| 30. | Explosion Network | Superman Returns (2006) | Superman Rewatch | 9 | |
| 31. | Searching For Other Players | Superman Returns (2006) - 'Behind The Scenes' | 0 | |
