RE: "Can You Judge Art Objectively"

Channel:
Canada smudboy
Subscribers:
20,000
Published on ● Video Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZND3H7W328


Duration: 1:12:33
14,229 views
710

Just Write sticks his ankles down his throat after throwing up over Kant and forgetting about Hume.

He loves strawmanning. Charming.

He also says he's going to give us multiple reasons why Objective Criticism is bad, but never does. He ends up just rambling on and not giving one solid point, or one solid argument, and gets Hume and Kant to disprove him whether he's aware of it or not.

Apparently the bomber scene in The Last Jedi is good because the bombers show us they are easily destroyed because they're big and slow, and not Y-Wings, cause lore is irrelevant. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

"Literally every choice in the artistic development of a story matters." -- Just Write

Except when it's objective conclusions based on objective observations. Because not-Y-Wings.

It's truly an amazing production of contradiction and nonsense.

Also, we've got some interludes from Harlan Ellison and J.M.S.

Also, buy some Skillshare. Seriously, the guy can't teach you writing, can't read Hume or Kant, can't understand how to make an argument, but apparently Skillshare can.

Facebook ► https://bit.ly/2KHitxP
Patreon ► https://www.patreon.com/smudboy
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/smudboy
Amazon: ► https://amzn.to/2P1PjvF
Discord: ►https://discord.gg/Yzaxfv

Remember, logic criticism of art is inferior to subjective criticism! Because...?

List of literary criticisms:
https://courses.lumenlearning.com/britlit1/chapter/literary-criticism/

Immanuel Kant – On the Aesthetic Taste
https://pressbooks.bccampus.ca/classicreadings/chapter/immanuel-kant-on-the-aesthetic-taste/

"Of the Standard of Taste" by David Hume
https://web.csulb.edu/~jvancamp/361r15.html



Other Videos By smudboy


2019-03-08Worth Reading: Deathbird Stories Part 3
2019-03-04Top 5 Upcoming RPGs of 2019
2019-03-01Smudstream: "10 Ways Bioware Can Still Save Mass Effect"
2019-03-01What makes a successful Story Based Looter Shooter?
2019-02-26Worth Reading: Deathbird Stories Part 2
2019-02-24Smudstream: "Mass Effect 5: 10 Perfect Ways Bioware Can Save The Franchise"
2019-02-2226 Problems with Star Wars: The Last Jedi in the first 12 minutes you might have missed (Part 1)
2019-02-18Worth Reading: Deathbird Stories Part 1
2019-02-16Smudstream: "Conviction – An Anthem Trailer From Neill Blomkamp"
2019-02-14Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: Plot Analysis Part 7
2019-02-13RE: "Can You Judge Art Objectively"
2019-02-09Smudstream: "Anthemxtravaganza"
2019-02-01Smudstream: "Anthem The Golden Colossus Gameplay PC Ultra Graphics"
2019-01-27Smudstream: "ANTHEM Story: All Cutscenes in the VIP Demo [BioWare 2019]"
2019-01-26Smudstream: "Is Anakin a Mary Sue?"
2019-01-22Smudstream: "*NEW* ANTHEM GAMEPLAY! Underwater! Boss Fights! Interceptor & Colossus! | Freeplay"
2019-01-19Smudstream: "This Is Anthem | Gameplay Series, Part 1: Story, Progression, and Customization"
2019-01-12Smudstream: "Solo Deserves A Sequel: An Underrated Film Walkthrough"
2019-01-05Smudstream: "Why Evangelion's Horrible Ending is Actually Amazing"
2019-01-01Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: Plot Analysis Part 6
2018-12-29Smudstream: "Why Mass Effect 3's Ending is Perfect"


Tags:
Just Write
Hume
Kant
Aesthetics
Objective
Objective Observations
Objective Critique
Objective Criticism
The Last Jedi
Star Wars
Patrick Willems
Logic
Criticism
Literary Criticism
Subjective Criticism