| 1. | 2023 MLB Season Los Angeles Dodgers Vs Chicago Cubs MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,807 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 2. | 2023 MLB Season New York Mets Vs Oakland Athletics MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,427 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 3. | 2023 MLB Season Kansas City Royals Vs Minnesota Twins MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,395 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 4. | 2023 MLB Season Colorado Rockies Vs Los Angeles Dodgers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,320 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 5. | 2023 MLB Season Expansion Era Boomers Vs Mid-Century Groundbreakers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,298 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 6. | 2023 MLB Season Chicago White Sox Vs Pittsburgh Pirates MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,286 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 7. | 2023 MLB Season Kansas City Royals Vs Minnesota Twins MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,231 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 8. | 2023 MLB Season Baltimore Orioles Vs Detroit Tigers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,228 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 9. | 2023 MLB Season San Francisco Giants Vs New York Yankees MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,197 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 10. | 2023 MLB Season Cincinnati Reds Vs Philadelphia Phillies MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,153 | Let's Play | MLB The Show 23
|
| 11. | 2023 MLB Season Oakland Athletics Vs Seattle Mariners MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 1,138 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 12. | 2023 MLB Season Texas Rangers Vs Kansas City Royals MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 993 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 13. | 2023 MLB Season Arizona Diamondbacks Vs St. Louis Cardinals MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 953 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 14. | 2023 MLB Season Miami Marlins Vs Cleveland Guardians MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 900 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 15. | 2023 MLB Season Detroit Tigers Vs Houston Astros MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 879 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 16. | 2023 MLB Season Milwaukee Brewers Vs Toronto Blue Jays MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 858 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 17. | 2023 MLB Season San Diego Padres Vs Atlanta Braves MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 855 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 18. | 2023 MLB Season Long Ball Beasts Vs Mid-Century Groundbreakers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 786 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 19. | 2023 MLB Season Boston Red Sox Vs Tampa Bay Rays MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 724 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 20. | 2023 MLB Season Philadelphia Phillies Vs Atlanta Braves MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 709 | Let's Play | MLB The Show 23
|
| 21. | 2023 MLB Season San Diego Padres Vs Atlanta Braves MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 615 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 22. | 2023 MLB Season New York Mets Vs Oakland Athletics MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 546 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 23. | 2023 MLB Season Cincinnati Reds Vs Philadelphia Phillies MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 525 | Let's Play | MLB The Show 23
|
| 24. | 2023 MLB Season Chicago White Sox Vs Pittsburgh Pirates MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 449 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 25. | 2023 MLB Season Oakland Athletics Vs Seattle Mariners MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 411 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 26. | 2023 MLB Season Expansion Era Boomers Vs Mid-Century Groundbreakers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 376 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 27. | 2023 MLB Season Los Angeles Dodgers Vs Chicago Cubs MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 362 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 28. | 2023 MLB Season Colorado Rockies Vs Los Angeles Dodgers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 342 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 29. | 2023 MLB Season Washington Nationals Vs Los Angeles Angels MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 275 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 30. | 2023 MLB Season San Francisco Giants Vs New York Yankees MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 252 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 31. | 2023 MLB Season Philadelphia Phillies Vs Atlanta Braves MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 217 | Let's Play | MLB The Show 23
|
| 32. | 2023 MLB Season Miami Marlins Vs Cleveland Guardians MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 185 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 33. | 2023 MLB Season San Francisco Giants Vs New York Yankees MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 179 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 34. | 2023 MLB Season Milwaukee Brewers Vs Toronto Blue Jays MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 123 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 35. | 2023 MLB Season Baltimore Orioles Vs Detroit Tigers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 109 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 36. | 2023 MLB Season Arizona Diamondbacks Vs St. Louis Cardinals MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 96 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 37. | 2023 MLB Season Miami Marlins Vs Cleveland Guardians MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 90 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 38. | 2023 MLB Season Boston Red Sox Vs Tampa Bay Rays MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 87 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 39. | 2023 MLB Season Colorado Rockies Vs Los Angeles Dodgers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 69 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 40. | MLB The Show 23 Introduction | 69 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 41. | 2023 MLB Season Expansion Era Boomers Vs Mid-Century Groundbreakers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 64 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 42. | 2023 MLB Season Texas Rangers Vs Kansas City Royals MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 59 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 43. | 2023 MLB Season Boston Red Sox Vs Tampa Bay Rays MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 52 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 44. | 2023 MLB Season Arizona Diamondbacks Vs St. Louis Cardinals MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 49 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 45. | 2023 MLB Season Milwaukee Brewers Vs Toronto Blue Jays MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 46 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 46. | 2023 MLB Season Long Ball Beasts Vs Mid-Century Groundbreakers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 38 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 47. | 2023 MLB Season Oakland Athletics Vs Seattle Mariners MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 36 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 48. | 2023 MLB Season San Diego Padres Vs Atlanta Braves MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 35 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 49. | 2023 MLB Season Detroit Tigers Vs Houston Astros MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 35 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 50. | 2023 MLB Season Baltimore Orioles Vs Detroit Tigers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 35 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 51. | 2023 MLB Season New York Mets Vs Oakland Athletics MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 33 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 52. | 2023 MLB Season Long Ball Beasts Vs Mid-Century Groundbreakers MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 31 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 53. | 2023 MLB Season Los Angeles Dodgers Vs Chicago Cubs MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 29 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 54. | 2023 MLB Season Philadelphia Phillies Vs Atlanta Braves MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 29 | Let's Play | MLB The Show 23
|
| 55. | 2023 MLB Season Kansas City Royals Vs Minnesota Twins MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 28 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 56. | 2023 MLB Season Washington Nationals Vs Los Angeles Angels MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 26 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 57. | 2023 MLB Season Cincinnati Reds Vs Philadelphia Phillies MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 22 | Let's Play | MLB The Show 23
|
| 58. | 2023 MLB Season Chicago White Sox Vs Pittsburgh Pirates MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 21 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 59. | MLB The Show 23 Introduction | 17 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
| 60. | 2023 MLB Season Texas Rangers Vs Kansas City Royals MLB The Show 23 Simulation | 17 | Show | MLB The Show 23
|
