| 1. |  Arlo | The Paper Mario You've Been Waiting For | Bug Fables Review (SWITCH) | 3,277 | Review |
| 2. | IGN | Paper Mario: The Origami King Review | 1,727 | Review |
| 3. | Arlo | Nintendo in 2020: THE REVIEW | 1,060 | Review |
| 4. | HyperCharge | Paper Mario Is Dead - Nintendrone | 946 | Review |
| 5. | Spawn Wave | Paper Mario Reviews + Hellblade 2 Causes Debate Online & A Sudden Shakeup Hits Gaming | News Wave | 861 | Review |
| 6. | GameXplain | Is Bug Fables the "Paper Mario" We've Been Waiting For? - REVIEW (Switch) | 706 | Review |
| 7. | Lute | Paper Mario Is Wonderful | 550 | Review |
| 8. | Taki Udon | Challenger Approaching! - OneGx1 Wii/GC Emulation Test | 546 | Review |
| 9. | ConnerTheWaffle | 10 NINTENDO SWITCH eShop Games REVIEWS! - ConnerTheWaffle | 418 | Review |
| 10. |  Lady Decade | THE LOST SUPER MARIO RPG 2 - The Game Before Paper Mario !? - Nintendo 64 History Documentary | 323 | Review |
| 11. | Resonant Arc | Paper Mario 64 Review | 268 | Review |
| 12. | GameXplain | Nintendo Celebrates the New Year With YOUR 2021 Switch Stats In Review! | 185 | Review |
| 13. | wiiviewr | Paper Mario Review (VC) | 153 | Review |
| 14. | The Red Guy | Paper Mario | Red Review | 131 | Review |
| 15. | BowserPower | Mario Plush Collection - BowserPower 2022 | 125 | Review |
| 16. | wiiviewr | Power Rangers Samurai Review (Wii) | 124 | Review |
| 17. | Tech With Sean | ED64 Plus Review - Nintendo 64 Flashcart | 111 | Review |
| 18. | CGRundertow | CGRundertow PAPER MARIO for Nintendo 64 Video Game Review | 106 | Review |
| 19. | Davidvinc RPGs | Bug Fables Review - Paper Mario's Spiritual Successor! | 81 | Review |
| 20. | BowserPower | Baby Mario's Magic Remote! | 74 | Review |
| 21. |  ZXMany | Why Paper Mario 64 is an amazing Nintendo 64 game | 71 | Review |
| 22. | Pariah695 | Paper Mario - Review | 70 | Review |
| 23. | NovaLightSky | A Perfect Game in Every Way | Paper Mario Review | 65 | Review |
| 24. | ZyroXZ2 | Paper Mario (Wii U VC Review) | 56 | Review |
| 25. | BowserPower | Kamek the Gamer! | 54 | Review |
| 26. | BowserPower | Mario's Midlife Crisis! | 54 | Review |
| 27. | BowserPower | Bowser Attacks Part 2! | 49 | Review |
| 28. | The Red Guy | When is a review too long? | Red Discussion | 47 | Review |
| 29. | BowserPower | Bowser Junior Plays Hide and Seek! | 44 | Review |
| 30. | gameguy682 | Paper Mario (N64/Wii Virtual Console) Review | 41 | Review |
| 31. | mgalchemist | Retro Review - Paper Mario (N64) | 33 | Review |
| 32. | Azurè Sky | Paper Mario VC Review | 33 | Review |
| 33. | Morjax Plays | Paper Mario Explained Using only the 1,000 Most-Used English Words: ELI2 Review | 32 | Review |
| 34. | HyperCharge | Paper Mario - Uncivil Synopsis | 31 | Review |
| 35. | SwitchWatch | Bug Fables Nintendo Switch Review - PAPER MARIO with BUGS!? | 30 | Review |
| 36. | Pizza Handhelds | Paper Mario 64 HD Mupen64Plus Texture Setup Steam Deck Review Nintendo 64 | 30 | Review |
| 37. | dabhdude | SML The Perfect Plan Review (feat. Yoshi Player) | 30 | Review |
| 38. | RubinNischara | Das merkwürdigste Paper Mario Review ever | 30 | Review |
| 39. | KazooCat | Paper Mario: The Genre Journey | 28 | Review |
| 40. | Games Cage | The Rest Of 2020 For Nintendo (June Review & the Future) | 24 | Review |
| 41. | Woopah Troopah | The Best Nintendo Direct In YEARS?!? - 6-21-2023 Nintedo Direct, A Woopah's Review | 24 | Review |
| 42. | BradleyNews11 | Stick it to the Man Wii U Review! - Nintendo Review Zone! | 23 | Review |
| 43. |  Knackiger N1K | Ein überraschend nicer Prolog - Paper Mario Prolog Review | 20 | Review |
| 44. | Raymond Strazdas | Nintendo Switch Lite 5 YEARS LATER - Is It Still Worth Buying in 2024? | 20 | Review |
| 45. | FourFaceButtons | Paper Mario (2000) Review | 17 | Review |
| 46. | Jay Reviews | Jay Reviews 10th Anniversary Thanks!! | 17 | Review |
| 47. | LuigiFan1 aka Star | MUGEN Siguel & LuigiFan1 vs Cosmic Clone BestGamerReview & Shadow BestGamerReview + Extra | 15 | Review |
| 48. | RubinNischara | Let's Play Paper Mario - Review | 14 | Review |
| 49. | ScionVyse | Paper Mario Retrospective and Review - ScionVyse | 13 | Review |
| 50. | MALICEDOLL79 | PAPER MARIO THE ORIGAMI KING RENT OR BUY GAME REVIEW | 13 | Review |
| 51. | Chr0mePisto1a | PAPER MARIO (N64) UNBOXING AND REVIEW [4K] | 13 | Review |
| 52. | Yuusha | Xena 64 - Unlikely Review | 13 | Review |
| 53. | Definitive50 | Paper Mario Review - Definitive 50 N64 Game #9 | 12 | Review |
| 54. | King Gudea | Paper Mario 64 - A Retrospective Review | 12 | Review |
| 55. | Anita's Gaming Sanctuary | Paper Mario 64 (Nintendo Switch Online) FIRST LOOK! 👀 | 11 | Review |
| 56. |  Lawson Experience | Lawson Review #9.- Paper Mario 64 (Español) - ¿El sucesor espiritual de Super Mario RPG? | 11 | Review |
| 57. | Wolf Lebrega | ¿Te Recomiendo Jugar Paper Mario? | Review | 10 | Review |
| 58. |  TVGTeacher | Nintendo Switch Review of Damsel | 10 | Review |
| 59. | Izzy-Doodle! | "Paper Mario" (N64) Long-form Review -- Drew Doodle! (Paper Mario Retrospective 1/3) | 9 | Review |
| 60. | Brandt 2698 | What Makes Paper Mario So Great (ft. Naty) | 9 | Review |
| 61. | Gamer 27 | Paper Mario VS Archie Sonic - Reviewed in 105 Seconds | 9 | Review |
| 62. | Milesluigi | Super Mario Infinity 2: The Cursed Gem: Review by MilesLuigi | 9 | Review |
| 63. | GoldenDudez | March Madness 2019! Best Video Game 1st Round Part 4 | 9 | Review |
| 64. | VGx7 | Paper Mario Review | 8 | Review |
| 65. | The Famicast | Paper Mario | Retro Review | Nintendo 64 | 8 | Review |
| 66. | Lachie LN | A Paper Mario 64 Review Before You Play Thousand-Year-Door | 8 | Review |
| 67. | VictoryNYC | TOONAMI Game Review: Paper Mario (2001) | 8 | Review |
| 68. |  TEC | Paper Mario The Origami King Análisis/Review: ¿Vale la pena comprarlo? | 8 | Review |
| 69. | Luggician | Who Cares About Review Scores? | 8 | Review |
| 70. | Clincolnmccloudplushchannel | Talking Loud season 2 episode 9: Toad's opinion on 2 new loud House episodes, Paper Mario review | 7 | Review |
| 71. | HackySmack | Nintendo Switch Pro Rumors are Back! Switch Pro or Switch 2? | 7 | Review |
| 72. | Knackiger N1K | trocken, trockener, Dry Dry Ruins - Paper Mario Kapitel 2 Review | 7 | Review |
| 73. | MisterWii | Paper Mario N64 Review Mr Wii Reviews Episode 4 (4K Resolution) | 7 | Review |
| 74. | Balonator | Paper Mario 64 Review | How Good Is It? | Balonator | 6 | Review |
| 75. | Deep Voice Gaming | Paper Mario Review | 6 | Review |
| 76. | HiJello | Paper Mario 64 - A Real Page Turner | HiJello Original | 6 | Review |
| 77. | Thats Entertainment | Paper Mario Lost Gems Review - That's Entertainment | 6 | Review |
| 78. | Papi Polite | My Paper Mario 64 REVIEW! | 6 | Review |
| 79. | UK KRAUT GAMING | Lockdown pick ups and power A switch controller review | 5 | Review |
| 80. | Dinosnore | One Minute Retro Review: Paper Mario (N64) #Shorts | 5 | Review |
| 81. | VGx7 | Everything You Want Nothing You Need 20 - Ian Went On Vacation | 5 | Review |
| 82. | CSDX | Paper Mario | A Timeless Classic? | Praise Appraisal | 5 | Review |
| 83. | Anita's Gaming Sanctuary | What Is Even Happening? 🤪 - Paper Mario 64 (Switch) (Ep. 8) | 5 | Review |
| 84. | Jyggy | PRESS F FOR HERBERT!! | Paper Mario: Series Review #4 | 5 | Review |
| 85. | Paper King | Food Review - Tayce T (GONE WRONG) #papermario | 5 | Review |
| 86. | LP's LPs | The Sequel That Fell Flat | 5 | Review |
| 87. | LuigiFan1 aka Star | MUGEN Request #936 Wario, Super Waluigi, Giant BestGamerReview & Silver Luigi vs Team LuigiFan1.exe | 5 | Review |
| 88. | Azura Game Club | Paper Mario (N64) Review [Gems From the Backlog] -JZNES | 5 | Review |
| 89. | Games Past Their Prime | Games Past Their Prime - Paper Mario Review | 4 | Review |
| 90. | RPGaymer | Bug Fables Review | Games Like Paper Mario | 4 | Review |
| 91. | Lord Shmup | Red Bow - Nintendo Switch Review | 4 | Review |
| 92. | Sir_Liam The Legend | PAPER MARIO THE ORIGAMI KING FIRST IMPRESSIONS | SWITCH REVIEW | MY FIRST PAPER MARIO GAME EVER!?!?! | 4 | Review |
| 93. | Rocket Sloth | Paper Mario Review in 2018 - Classic Nintendo 64 NINTENDUARY | 4 | Review |
| 94. | Knackiger N1K | Das charmanteste Kapitel - Paper Mario Kapitel 3 Review | 3 | Review |
| 95. | DuoReview | Paper Mario (N64) Review | 3 | Review |
| 96. | Anita's Gaming Sanctuary | Our New Favorite EXPLODING Pink Bomb 💣 - Paper Mario 64 (Switch) (Ep. 6) | 3 | Review |
| 97. |  Split-Screen | Born of Bread - Inspiração em Paper Mario | 3 | Review |
| 98. | Marcor255 | Paper Mario 64 Review - Is It As Good As They Say? | 3 | Review |
| 99. | TWK REVIEWS | Paper Mario 64 (TWK Reviews Episode 29) | 3 | Review |
| 100. | TheDominusIgnis | An Underrated Indie Multiplayer Game - Dragon Drop Review (PC) - TheDominusIgnis (VGCember) | 3 | Review |
