| 1. |  PewDiePie | WARNING: THIS PONY GAME WILL RUIN YOUR CHILDHOOD! (Pony Island) | 15,921 | |
| 2. |  jacksepticeye | WHAT THE HELL IS THIS GAME?? | Pony Island #1 | 15,137 | |
| 3. |  Markiplier | IMMA FIRIN MAH LAZER!! | Pony Island - Part 1 | 9,068 | |
| 4. |  Amixem | CE JEU N'EST PAS CE QUE TU CROIS. | 6,470 | |
| 5. | jacksepticeye | WELCOME BACK TO HELL!! | Pony Island #2 | 5,928 | |
| 6. | Markiplier | BATTLING THROUGH HELL | Pony Island - Part 3 (ENDING) | 5,303 | |
| 7. | Markiplier | ARE WE DEAD...? | Pony Island - Part 2 | 4,213 | |
| 8. | GTLive | Pony Island: HORSIES From HELL! (Part 1) | 4,204 | |
| 9. | iHasCupquake | PONY ISLAND NEEDS MORE PONIES | 3,206 | |
| 10. |  Mandzio | CO TO ZA POWALONA GRA! O CO TU CHODZI! (Pony Island #1) | 2,494 | |
| 11. |  Corrupted | Dieses Spiel klaut deine Seele | Let's Play Pony Island (Deutsch/German) | 1,983 | Let's Play |
| 12. | GTLive | Pony Island: ESCAPE from HECK! (Part 2) | 1,948 | |
| 13. |  iTownGamePlay *Terror&Diversión* | NADA ES LO QUE PARECE - Pony Island | iTownGamePlay | 1,707 | |
| 14. |  GodOfCoffee | Asi es Pony Island en el 2020 | Toda la Historia en 10 Minutos | 1,697 | |
| 15. | Nico Core Games | este juego no rompe la cuarta pared, LA DESTRUYE - PONY ISLAND | 1,455 | |
| 16. |  플레임TV | ※소름 주의※ 이건 포니가 뛰노는 그런 게임이 아니다 - 포니 아일랜드 [플레임] | 1,424 | |
| 17. | Karolek | CHCE UCIEC Z PONY ISLAND ! ( Pony Island #1 ) | 1,197 | |
| 18. | tvgry | SZATAŃSKA creepypasta! Klątwa gry Pony Island [tvgry.pl] | 1,167 | |
| 19. | Mr. Fruit | IT'S NOT WHAT YOU THINK : Pony Island Let's Play Gameplay [Part 1] | 1,151 | Let's Play |
| 20. | Mandzio | ROZWIĄZANIE WSZYSTKICH TAJEMNIC! (Pony Island #5) | 1,149 | |
| 21. | ManlyBadassHero | Sacrifices Must Be Made - Don't Draw A Bad Hand In A Horror Card Game Created By Pony Island Creator | 1,073 | |
| 22. | Gronkh | Äh... WAS PASSIERT HIER? | Pony Island #001 | Gronkh | 1,052 | Let's Play |
| 23. | Jesse Cox | Fan Friday!! - Pony Island | 994 | |
| 24. | Forever Nenaa | If you QUIT this Game, YOUR PET DIES!! | BitBuddy [EMOTIONAL DAMAGE] | 948 | |
| 25. | Mandzio | WRESZCIE DOSTAJEMY SIĘ DO WESOŁEGO ŚWIATA KUCYKÓW! (Pony Island #4) | 944 | |
| 26. | Mandzio | KUCYKI STRZELAJĄCE LASERAMI! WTF? (Pony Island #2) | 930 | |
| 27. | Mandzio | MANDZIO POKAZUJE JAK ZNISZCZYĆ GRĘ (Pony Island #3) | 908 | |
| 28. | maudado | Süßes Killer-Pony「Pony Island」 | 846 | |
| 29. | ProJared Plays! | NOT WHAT I EXPECTED | Pony Island | ProJared Plays | 816 | Let's Play |
| 30. | Czoklet! | TO NIE JEST GRA O Ḳ̸͗U̴̼̅C̴̱̒Y̴̩͗K̵̺̃A̷̙͑C̵̤̈́H̷͍͋ *nie oglądaj* | 784 | |
| 31. | GameGrumps | Technical Difficulties on Pony Island | 767 | |
| 32. | Farod Games | UN JEU TRÈS MYSTÉRIEUX... - Pony Island 🦄 | 729 | |
| 33. | Nico Core Games | este juego no pulveriza la cuarta pared, la VOLATILIZA - PONY ISLAND FINAL | 703 | |
| 34. |  MattShea | NOT ABOUT PONIES - Pony Island | 666 | |
| 35. | Nico Core Games | ESTE JUEGO NO DESTRUYE LA CUARTA PARED, LA DESINTEGRA - Pony Island #2 | 656 | |
| 36. | Maximilian Dood | MAX REACTS: The Game Awards 2023 - Full Presentation | 650 | |
| 37. | Jesse Cox | Fan Friday Followup!! - Pony Island Secrets!!! | 632 | |
| 38. | Call Me Kevin | This game completely changes as you play it | 624 | |
| 39. | Nico Core Games | ESTE JUEGO NO DESINTEGRA LA CUARTA PARED, LA PULVERIZA - Pony Island #3 | 593 | |
| 40. | Jesse Cox | Fan Friday Follow Up! - Pony Island (part 2) | 583 | |
| 41. | Gronkh | WAZZEFAKK!!?? | Pony Island #008 | Gronkh | 581 | Let's Play |
| 42. | Mr. Fruit | THE FINALE : Pony Island Ending Let's Play Gameplay [Part 3] | 572 | Let's Play |
| 43. | Czoklet! | ZOSTAŁEM KUCYKIEM W 3̷̡͉̺͊ Ḑ̶̗̜̊̓ *koniec gry?* | 529 | |
| 44. |  Febatista | PONY ISLAND ! A MALDIÇÃO ? WTF | 515 | |
| 45. | Karolek | OPĘTAŁO MNIE NA SYLWESTRA ! ( Pony Island #2 ) | 515 | |
| 46. | Mr. Fruit | SATAN STRIKES BACK : Pony Island Let's Play Gameplay [Part 2] | 511 | Let's Play |
| 47. | Karolek | CO TU SIE DZIEJE ! WTF ! (Pony Island #4) | 503 | |
| 48. |  SuperHorrorBro | Pony Island - The Story Explained | 486 | |
| 49. | Stephanie Sterling | PONY ISLAND - Diablo Ex Machina | 482 | |
| 50. | Corrupted | Pony Island - 6 Jahre später | 479 | Let's Play |
| 51. | The Yogscast | OneShot - Pony Island | 471 | |
| 52. | Vinesauce: The Full Sauce | [Vinesauce] Vinny - Pony Island (part 1) | 470 | |
| 53. | 온다람 | 동전 대신 영혼을 넣어야 하는 악마의 게임기 [포니 아일랜드] | 466 | |
| 54. | Gronkh | Pew Pew!! I HAZ LAZERTS!! | Pony Island #002 | Gronkh | 465 | Let's Play |
| 55. |  Necros | Pony Island - Эту игру придумал дьявол! | 452 | |
| 56. | Super Bunnyhop | Review: Pony Island | 445 | |
| 57. |  Luigikid Gaming | Ḥ̺̝̣E̷̞̘̔̾ͪ̂Ĺ҉̘͕̫̝P̷̯̗͈̱̯̋͊͑̓̈́ͅ M͎̖̹̬͚̑͌̂͆̾Ē̶̲͚̓!͂͢ THIS GAME IS POSSESSED BY A DEMON! | 437 | |
| 58. | Czoklet! | O NIE, TYLKO NIE M̴̠͠O̵͚̅T̶̗͝Y̷̗̑L̵͎̅K̵͈̈I̴̩͛ !!! *przerażające* | 435 | |
| 59. | ManlyBadassHero | Pony Island - SECRET ENDING, ACT 3 (ALL TICKETS) Manly Let's Play Pt.3 | 431 | Let's Play |
| 60. | ChilledChaos | Welcome to HELL, Mortal! (Pony Island) | 405 | |
| 61. | Insectorat | ЧТО НАХОДИТСЯ МЕЖДУ АДОМ И РАЕМ? ПОЛНЫЙ СЮЖЕТ PONY ISLAND | 392 | |
| 62. | John Wolfe | PONY ISLAND - Full Playthrough - Game About Ponies | 389 | Let's Play |
| 63. | big juicy | This Game Is NOT About Ponies - Pony Island 🦄 | 389 | |
| 64. | Dooms | Pony Island - LE DIABLE EST DANS LE JEU ! | 378 | |
| 65. | Staszek iGRAszkowski | Pony Island PL #2 - Gramy! | My Little Lama | 374 | |
| 66. | Gronkh | BOSSgegner | Pony Island #003 | Gronkh | 363 | Let's Play |
| 67. | alexelcapo | PONY ISLAND [PI] | 361 | |
| 68. | SuperHorrorBro | This Pony Themed Videogame is Cursed || Pony Island (Full Playthrough) | 358 | Let's Play |
| 69. | Karolek | KAROLEK HAKUJE YOUTUBE ! ( Pony Island #3 ) | 355 | |
| 70. | 대도서관TV (buzzbean11) | 포니 아일랜드] 대도서관 공포게임 실황 1화 (Pony Island) | 353 | |
| 71. | MrKravin | Pony Island - All Tickets Ending: Secret Boss Fight & Ending! (No commentary) | 351 | |
| 72. | Człowiek Drzewo | Pony Island Soundtrack - Escape | 342 | |
| 73. | iTownGamePlay *Terror&Diversión* | Dejarán de GUSTARTE los PONIS después de VER ESTO - Pony Island (Horror Game) #1 | 338 | |
| 74. | YaBoyRoshi Gaming | The Game Awards w/ Roshi! | 333 | |
| 75. | Gronkh | NEUER CONTENT, neue Version | Pony Island #005 | Gronkh | 331 | Let's Play |
| 76. | Scorpro | تو این گیم شیطان چای دبش ریخت تو دهنم و من تک شاخ شدم 😂 Pony Island (1) | 323 | |
| 77. | lucahjin | WTS Saturday - Pony Island! :D | 320 | |
| 78. | Gronkh | Wer WAR ich? | Pony Island [004] | Gronkh | 319 | Let's Play |
| 79. | ZackScottGames | Pony Island - Gameplay Walkthrough Part 1 - Intro and Act I (PC Indie Game) | 319 | Walkthrough |
| 80. | Aliensrock | From The Makers Of Inscryption - Pony Island! | 312 | |
| 81. | Gronkh | ES IST JESUS!! | Pony Island #006 | Gronkh | 304 | Let's Play |
| 82. | Vinesauce: The Full Sauce | [Vinesauce] Vinny - Pony Island (part 2) | 296 | |
| 83. | SUNBA선바 | 정말 토악질 나오는 게임! 포니아일랜드 / 기분나쁜 추리게임 나는 그 남자를 죽이지 않았다. [선바스트리밍 #97] | 289 | |
| 84. | SuperHorrorBro | BitBuddy - A Short Game From the Creator of Inscryption & Pony Island (Playthrough) | 276 | Let's Play |
| 85. | Necros | Pony Island - Эпичная концовка | 272 | |
| 86. | SomeOrdinaryGamers | Pony Island... With Satan! | 262 | |
| 87. | CavemanFilms | THE DEVIL'S TRAP!! Pony Island! | 262 | |
| 88. | lucahjin | Pony Island! :D Part 2 - Debugging a Demon! | 262 | |
| 89. | Nitro Rad | Pony Island - Nitro Rad | 260 | |
| 90. | Dooms | Pony Island #4 - JE DÉTESTE CE JÉSUS (du jeu) ! | 258 | |
| 91. | Scorpro | با همون شاخم کردم تو حلق رییس چای دبش و شرکت تعطیل شد 👳♂️💪🍷 Pony Island (2) | 258 | |
| 92. | Czoklet! | CHYBA NIE POWINNO MNIE TU B̴͙̕Ẏ̵̯Ć̸͉̿... *ostatni poziom?* | 256 | |
| 93. | Staszek iGRAszkowski | Pony Island PL #1 - Gramy! | KUCYKI! Kucyki...? WTF?! | 245 | |
| 94. | 대타맨 | 악마의 게임기를 플레이하려면 영혼을 넣어야 한다.. 포니 아일랜드 | 241 | |
| 95. | RageGamingVideos | Pony Island - This is a Thing! | 240 | |
| 96. | ManlyBadassHero | Pony Island - My Little Satan, ACT 1 (ALL TICKETS) Manly Let's Play Pt.1 | 239 | Let's Play |
| 97. | Necros | Прохождение Pony Island - Читер от Бога #2 | 237 | |
| 98. | Hell Play! | ИГРОВОЙ АВТОМАТ ДЬЯВОЛА - Pony Island #1 | 236 | |
| 99. |  Su amiguillo Soac | Okey.... esto no lo vi venir | Pony Island ¿Fin? | 236 | |
| 100. | Gronkh | UNDELETE.EXE | Pony Island #007 | Gronkh | 234 | Let's Play |
