[8] Bill C-11 is Law. Here's What Happens Next
9I apparently recorded my first 'Drew Wilson was right' directly on YouTube. If you want the context, check out the latter portion of video 3 where I accurately predict that Bill C-11 will become law without the critical fixes needed.
As you may have heard by now, Bill C-11 has become law. This without any protections of user generated content and users who want their recommendations. Hilariously, supporters of the bill started falling over themselves to try and push for the regulation of social media and user generated content. If you want the source of the quotes in the video, you can find them all in my report here: https://www.freezenet.ca/as-ink-dries-on-bill-c-11-lobbyists-start-demanding-the-regulation-of-user-generated-content/
So, the next question then becomes, what happens next now that freedom of expression has basically been abolished? Well, things start getting more difficult for the government if you can believe it.
First, the government has to put forth the policy direction to the CRTC (easy, the government controls everything on that front).
Second, the CRTC will get to conduct "consultations" in an environment that will likely heavily favour the powers that be including the culture elite (also easy).
Third, the CRTC has to set things up to start regulating the internet. That's not an exaggeration, they are well and truly trying to get the resources to start regulating, effectively, the entire internet. Good luck with that fools errand (medium difficulty because they might score some wins along the way, but this will always be, at best, a very touch and go proposition).
Fourth, the government has to deal with trade retaliation from the US government and US businesses. The centre of this will be CUSMA because there is a very clear cut case that Bill C-11 discriminates against US businesses (hard, though I'm sure the Canadian government will try to figure out how to worm its way out of this. Prospects are low for this, though.)
Fifth, and finally, the government has to content with lawsuits. There are plenty of angles to challenge Bill C-11 in court. This might include the platforms ability to operate in Canada as well as a number of other angles. The most important of these angles is, of course, the constitutional angle. For that, you'd have to argue that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms end where the internet begins. I think it would be the biggest legal shock of them all if the government actually wins on that argument. For that reason, it's where my money is in terms of where Bill C-11 crashes and burns (Nearly impossible. We could see a massive upset in this step, but the odds of government success seems really really low from my perspective at this stage)
So, all this and more in this latest update. Things are bleak right now for freedom of expression in Canada, but as bad as things are now, there is reason for optimism. What's more, things won't be changing overnight. These stages will take months, if not, years. So, enjoy an unregulated YouTube while you still can.
00:00 Sometimes, I Hate Being Right
00:12 Bill C-11 is Now Law
00:50 My Prediction Was Accurate
01:28 Lobbyists Call for Regulating User Generated Content
05:00 Hope That My Predictions Continue to Be Accurate
05:20 Things Start getting Difficult for the Government
05:30 Step 1: Policy Directive (Easy)
06:20 Step 2: CRTC Consultations (Easy)
07:14 Step 3: CRTC Implementing the Regulation of the Internet (Medium)
08:04 Step 4: US Challenges Bill C-11/Trade Retaliation (Hard)
08:44 Step 5: Constitutional and Other Court Challenges (Government is Screwed)
10:29 This Will Take Months, if Not, Years
11:00 Things Aren't Going to Change Over Night!
11:44 Outro
Don't forget, if you like what you see, you can drop us a like and subscribe. This lets us know that you approve of what we are doing here. You can also directly support us at https://www.patreon.com/freezenet. Alternatively, you can simply buy us a Ko-Fi here: https://ko-fi.com/freezenet. Every little bit of support helps us create more cool videos like the one you see above.