| 1. |  BuzzFeed LATAM | Un exjefe de la mafia juega 'Mafia 2' | BuzzFeed Multiplayer en español | 91,898 | Review |
| 2. |  BuzzFeed Multiplayer | Ex-Hitman Reacts To Mafia 2 Deaths | 21,668 | Review |
| 3. |  Black Joshi | That's How MAFIA 2™ Works | 23,846 | Review |
| 4. | Hollow | Mafia 2: Definitive Edition - THE REMASTER IS HERE! | 10,235 | Review |
| 5. |  Voxel | Análise/Review – Máfia 2: Definitive edition | 4,183 | Review |
| 6. |  Monsieur Toc | Test MAFIA II: DEFINITIVE EDITION - Un retour RATÉ ? 🍝 Review + Gameplay FR | 3,831 | Review |
| 7. |  ColourShedProductions | Mafia II review - ColourShed | 3,493 | Review |
| 8. |  GameStar | Mafia 2 - Test / Review von GameStar (Gameplay) | 3,313 | Review |
| 9. |  Games 2 Egypt | مراجعة Mafia II: Definitive Edition | 3,240 | Review |
| 10. | GameSpot | GameSpot Reviews - Mafia II Review | 2,993 | Review |
| 11. | Larry Lawton | Larry Lawton Reviews Mafia 2 as Played by TmarTn2 | 275 | | 2,817 | Review |
| 12. | SxyBiscuit | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Review | A Classic Remastered | 2,785 | Review |
| 13. | PC Games | Mafia 2: Definitive Edition | REVIEW | Ein Angebot, das man nicht ablehnen kann? | 2,715 | Review |
| 14. | Larry Lawton | Mafia 2 Review by Jewel Thief Larry Lawton - Played by TmarTn2 - Part 2 | 281 | | 2,476 | Review |
| 15. | 2kliksphilip | Mafia 2 Review | 2,368 | Review |
| 16. |  GamingBolt | Mafia 2: Definitive Edition Review - A Lazy Remaster | 2,265 | Review |
| 17. | ArnaldoDK | Trilogia Mafia - Review das Edições Definitivas (I, II e III) | 1,056 | Review |
| 18. | Zeitgeist Game Review | Mafia 2 Review | 1,049 | Review |
| 19. |  Denis Major | Две лучших "Мафии" — впечатления от Mafia 1&2: Definitive Edition | 705 | Review |
| 20. | CGRundertow | CGR Undertow - MAFIA II for Xbox 360 Video Game Review | 593 | Review |
| 21. | Skvala Gaming | Mafia 2- XBOX 360 POV Gameplay Test, Impression, Review | 590 | Review |
| 22. |  Efsane Oyunlar Burada | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition & Stairway To Heaven Bölüm 14 REVIEW | 455 | Review |
| 23. | GameTrailers | Mafia 2 Review | 424 | Review |
| 24. | Gaming Pastime | Mafia II: Definitive Edition for PC Video Review | 366 | Review |
| 25. | Gamer at Malayali | Mafia 2 : Critical Review in Malayalam l Gamer@Malayali | 345 | Review |
| 26. | Mafia Game Videos | Mafia 2 Carmageddon Mod! - (Funny Moments w/ Mods) | 338 | Review |
| 27. | Joe, The Alternative Gamer | "An Underrated Series" Mafia 2 Retrospective Review (Game Development, Story Summary, Game Analysis) | 297 | Review |
| 28. | triodepunch | TRIO DE PUNCH reseña MAFIA 2 review | 266 | Review |
| 29. | UltimateChance | Mafia 2 - Review | 258 | Review |
| 30. |  Parliamo di Videogiochi | [PC][360][PS3] Mafia II | Review [parliamodivideogiochi.it] | 257 | Review |
| 31. | locosporelpodcast | Mafia II analisis review | 251 | Review |
| 32. | BTbenTR | What The HELL Happened With MAFIA 2 Definitive Edition (Mafia 2 Review) | 223 | Review |
| 33. | NamokaR GaminG WorlD | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition - Game Review in Hindi | #NamokarGaming | 222 | Review |
| 34. | جيماتوجرافى - Gamatography | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition مراجعة و تقييم | 209 | Review |
| 35. | Skycaptin5 | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Xbox Series X Gameplay Review | 198 | Review |
| 36. |  JKB | Mafia 2 Review | 182 | Review |
| 37. | Game On | Mafia 2 preview & Limbo review | 180 | Review |
| 38. |  Gamekings | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Review – Kopen, budgetbak of slopen? | 180 | Review |
| 39. | Skycaptin5 | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Xbox One X Gameplay Review | 99 | Review |
| 40. | GeauxBurns | Mafia II: Definitive Edition Review | 97 | Review |
| 41. |  Koontang GamerZ | [รีวิว] คุ้มค่าแก่การซื้อราคาเกือบ 1000 ไหม??? | Mafia II: Definitive Edition (Review) | 95 | Review |
| 42. |  GameX TV | Mafia II Review | 89 | Review |
| 43. | HappyTriggerFinger | Happy Reacts To The Biggest Plot Twist In Mafia 2 | 85 | Review |
| 44. | GoddamnitBoone | MAFIA 2 | Should You Buy | Mafia 2 Review PC Gameplay | 78 | Review |
| 45. |  MFGAMING | Mafia II: Definitive Edition - Review Mafioso! | 77 | Review |
| 46. | Rawiioli | Mafia 2 PS3 German Review | 77 | Review |
| 47. | PC Games Hardware | Mafia 3 Review / Test - Atmosphärische Gangster-Action | 75 | Review |
| 48. | Combative 117 | Why MAFIA 2 is so ICONIC? | 72 | Review |
| 49. | SCREEN STARS | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition: PS4 Review | 70 | Review |
| 50. | Nyxson | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Review // Is It Worth It in 2023?! | 70 | Review |
| 51. | Play Games (Photography Gamer) | Mafia II: Definitive Edition - Review | 68 | Review |
| 52. | MaxPowerPlay | Mafia II Definitive Edition Review | A Disappointing Remaster | Xbox PS4 | 67 | Review |
| 53. | WideAsFcuk | Mafia II | 21:9 Review [2560x1080/60fps/Ultrawide] | 67 | Review |
| 54. | noobtoobarmy | Plankton Reviews Mafia (PC) | 65 | Review |
| 55. | Brave | MAFIA II : Definitive Edition İnceleme (Review) | 78 | Review |
| 56. | Firstplay.ro | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Remaster Review aka Ciorba Reincalzita (Limba Romana) | 64 | Review |
| 57. | Canal do Ed | MAFIA II DEFINITIVE ED. (REVIEW) — JOE E VITO ESTÃO DE VOLTA! | 58 | Review |
| 58. | 19 Stanley | MAFIA 2 Made Man Pack DLC review for PC user | 57 | Review |
| 59. |  Honest Game Review | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition - Honest Review (Spoiler Free) | 54 | Review |
| 60. | BenchART | Mafia II / 2 Definitive Edition | MX130/GT 940MX | 2GB GDDR5 | Performance Review | 53 | Review |
| 61. | WarriorDan- Game Reviews and Let's Plays | Is Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Worth Buying? [Mafia 2 Definitive Edition review] | 50 | Review |
| 62. | TonyASh | НОВАЯ ИСТОРИЯ НОВОГО МАФИОЗИ - MAFIA 2 | 46 | Review |
| 63. | Fortifun Gaming | THE SAD FALL OF MAFIA SERIES | 46 | Review |
| 64. | PvtHudson | Mafia 2 - Review | 44 | Review |
| 65. | Calzee | Should You Play Mafia II: Definitive Edition In 2023? | 54 | Review |
| 66. | GenkinoDE | Mafia 2: Definitive Edition - Wirklich ein Remaster? (PS4) || Video Test / Review (Deutsch) | 42 | Review |
| 67. | Marhun | Maifa 2: Обзор Вырезанного дома #shortsvideo | 55 | Review |
| 68. | Technical Mukul | Mafia 2 Gameplay Review On HP Pavilion Gaming 15 । Ryzen 5 3550h । Nvidia Gtx 1650 | 40 | Review |
| 69. | Old Review | ÇİMLERİN LANETİ - MAFIA II | 39 | Review |
| 70. | STARLORDxLUCIFER STUDIOES | Mafia II - Part 1 - The Beginning|Mafia 2: 10 YEARS LATER..damn its still good and running. | 38 | Review |
| 71. |  RedTieGuy | MAFIA 2 DEFINITIVE EDITION - REVIEW DISCUSSION | Good story, poor performance [2020] | 38 | Review |
| 72. | GeauxBurns | Mafia II Review | 37 | Review |
| 73. | HalfBlindGamer | Mafia II - Video Review | 36 | Review |
| 74. | Podcast Now PLUS | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition Review - Honest Thoughts And Criticism | 34 | Review |
| 75. | Recommended Playing | Mafia 2 Review - Steam (Recommended Playing) | 34 | Review |
| 76. | AlphaSkull | Mafia II Hindi Review. | 34 | Review |
| 77. | SamueltehG33k | "Mafia 2 has the best story of all time" -Whitythereviewer (UltimateChance) | 33 | Review |
| 78. | TonyASh | Mafia 2 - Хороша как ни крути | Прохождение №2 | 33 | Review |
| 79. | Geek Citadel | Geek Citadel Reviews - Mafia 2 | 32 | Review |
| 80. | Reviewing Grifter | Mafia II Definitive Edition - PS4 Pro Game Review | 32 | Review |
| 81. | Михаил Super | [Mods] Mafia II - TANK (Review) | 30 | Review |
| 82. |  Watch Games | AMD RADEON HD 7000 SERIES 1 GB TEST IN 5 GAMES ON INTEL CORE i5 3470 3RD GENERATION | 30 | Review |
| 83. |  Engin Gaming | Mafia - 2 Chapter 4 'Murphy's Law' | 27 | Review |
| 84. | TheRealKhade | THAT HAD TO HURT! | 27 | Review |
| 85. | BenchART | Mafia II / 2 Definitive Edition | GTX 1650 Super | Performance Review | 26 | Review |
| 86. |  Makkfeju | Mafia 2 ENB series graphic mod review (HUN) / bemutató | 25 | Review |
| 87. | WKHANZ GAMING | MAFIA 2 2020 GAMEPLAY PART 1 STORY MODE (DESI REVIEW) HD1080P | 25 | Review |
| 88. | Engin Gaming | Mafia 2 - Chapter 2 HOME SWEET HOM ।। Engin Gaming | 24 | Review |
| 89. | GameXpirit | Mafia 2 Review || Español [HD] | 23 | Review |
| 90. | Atratzu | Atratzu Reviews: Mafia II review - Yo Ho, Yo Ho, a Scaletta life for me? | 23 | Review |
| 91. | Games To Go | Mafia 2: Definitive Edition Review | Good Game, Bad Port | 23 | Review |
| 92. | Troidy Gaming | Mafia 2 Review - In Case You Missed It | 22 | Review |
| 93. | Zxenus | Is Mafia 2 Definitive Edition still worth playing in 2023? (Game Review) | 70 | Review |
| 94. | Games Benchmarks & Beyond | Why Mafia II is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED | Short Review with AI Voice over. #mafia2 #aivoiceover | 22 | Review |
| 95. | Jaco | Mafia 2 but you only play as Joe Barbaro... | 24 | Review |
| 96. | Kurmaev Play | Вся правда о Mafia 2: Definitive Edition | 21 | Review |
| 97. | Naffin | Mafia 2: The Terrible Review | 21 | Review |
| 98. |  TheLabVideoGameTV | Mafia II (PC) - Review | 21 | Review |
| 99. | AJTS ⚜️ | Mafia 2 Definitive Edition In 2023… Is It Worth It? | 30 | Review |
| 100. | Kyle Sullivan | Mafia II Review! | 20 | Review |
