| 1. |  ZlimBratSki | 2,632 | This Is Mind-Blowing! - Nightmare Reaper Review | 14:03 |
| 2. | MEGA the micro | 2,241 | NIGHTMARE REAPER – Pulpy Pixel Fun - Complete Review (Spoiler-Free) | 5:48 |
| 3. |  Hidden Machine | 1,557 | The Definitive Roguelite Boomer Looter Shooter | Nightmare Reaper (full release) Review | 14:36 |
| 4. | Griefing Satori | 839 | Nightmare Reaper Review (Early Access): Boomer Shooter At Its Finest | 16:10 |
| 5. |  SwitchStars | 726 | Retro Roguelike Action! Nightmare Reaper | (Nintendo Switch) | Live Stream | 2:14:32 |
| 6. | Joe, The Alternative Gamer | 646 | Nightmare Reaper Is Awesome (And Kind Underrated!) | 8:26 |
| 7. |  Hyacsho | 610 | Nightmare Reaper gave me the Rabbit Encounter! 🐇 | 0:37 |
| 8. |  gameblur-v2.0 | 552 | Nightmare Reaper - Review (PC) | 8:35 |
| 9. | Ruby Ranger | 297 | Nightmare Reaper / The Dream Slayer | 30:26 |
| 10. | Solo Jonathan | 255 | Fun in Dreamland | Nightmare Reaper Review | 6:32 |
| 11. | Switch Heads | 210 | Nightmare Reaper Review Nintendo Switch Steam PC | 7:16 |
| 12. | Game Wisdom | 210 | Nightmare Reaper is a Modern Retro Grab Bag of Gameplay | Nightmare Reaper Review | 8:39 |
| 13. |  dirtygiveaway | 174 | Nightmare Reaper Review: Beefer Boys present an Early Access Catch-Up | 1:38:24 |
| 14. | Thiago Cantalupo | 171 | NIGHTMARE REAPER//REVIEW//ANALISE// Meus pensamentos sobre. | 9:34 |
| 15. | Shawn K The King | 145 | Nightmare Reaper Review / First Impression (Playstation 5) | 24:37 |
| 16. | DRUNK ASS GAMING | 135 | CJ Reviews: Nightmare Reaper | 9:42 |
| 17. | The Critic Teacher 📝 | 130 | Nightmare Reaper - Game Review | 9:22 |
| 18. | Barugon | 122 | #31 Indie Review - NIGHTMARE REAPER - BOOMER SHOOTER+TERROR+ROGUELITE!!!!! | 12:53 |
| 19. | ST0RYTEL13R | 104 | Nightmare Reaper | Game Review | FPS Osmosis Jones | 8:02 |
| 20. | Rushed Reviews | 71 | Nightmare Reaper Review (Switch) | 0:47 |
| 21. | Steveburto | 43 | Nightmare Reaper | Quick Review: The new Standard for Boomer Shooters | 5:08 |
| 22. | GRIMREAPERSAGE | 27 | Nightmare Reaper Short Review | 1:00 |
| 23. | Dillon & Ali | 20 | Nightmare Reaper Review on a RTX 3050 | 12:01 |
| 24. | Killer J Gaming 2 The Sequel Retired | 14 | RMG Rebooted EP 693 Nightmare Reaper Switch Game Review | 11:56 |
| 25. | Five Five | 5 | Nightmare Reaper review score 10 out of 10 PS4 | 14:56 |
| 26. | Adam Dayton | 2 | Fragments of Silicon Reviews: Nightmare Reaper | 23:46 |
