Is the universe really infinite? | George Ellis and David Deutsch

Subscribers:
276,000
Published on ● Video Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1R52EbwfOmc



Duration: 3:43
10,912 views
215


David Deutsch defends infinity against George Ellis

Watch the full debate at https://iai.tv/video/the-edge-of-the-universe?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=description

The idea of infinity may make us feel a little giddy, yet we refer to it frequently as if it is understood. Mathematicians claim Georg Cantor cracked the puzzle in the 19th century and enabled us to understand and handle infinities. But is this perhaps a profound mistake? The writer Jorge Luis Borges argued 'infinity is a concept that corrupts and upsets all others'. And now some physicists are arguing infinity is the greatest crisis facing physics, claiming that it generates nonsensical answers in quantum mechanics and undermines all prediction in cosmology. Should we seek to remove infinity from accounts of the universe and rely on the finite alone? Or is infinity a key insight into the character of the universe, however difficult it may be for us to comprehend?

#DoesInfinityExist #PhysicsUniverse #CosmologyInfinity

Oxford maverick physicist David Deutsch, leading cosmology theorist George Ellis and theoretical physicist and origin of life expert Sara Walker debate whether the notion of infinity is a key insight into the character of the universe, a mathematical artefact, or simply nonsense. Hosted by the renowned public intellectual, writer and producer Robert Lawrence Kuhn.

To discover more talks, debates, interviews and academies with the world's leading speakers visit https://iai.tv/subscribe?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=the-edge-of-the-universe-head-to-head

The Institute of Art and Ideas features videos and articles from cutting edge thinkers discussing the ideas that are shaping the world, from metaphysics to string theory, technology to democracy, aesthetics to genetics. Subscribe today!

For debates and talks: https://iai.tv
For articles: https://iai.tv/articles
For courses: https://iai.tv/iai-academy/courses




Other Videos By The Institute of Art and Ideas


2023-01-03How to use philosophy for a better life | Rebecca Roache
2022-12-29Best of our 2022 content! | Slavoj Žižek, Roger Penrose, Sabine Hossenfelder, Ruth Chang...
2022-12-27Should we free ourselves of objects? | Paul Dolan, Mary-Ann Ochota and Steve Taylor
2022-12-24Is our search for an objective morality misguided? | Short Pitch | Slavoj Žižek
2022-12-22The dangers of separating art from beauty | Julian Spalding
2022-12-20Exploring the world behind bars | Andy West
2022-12-17Is it possible to know ourselves? | Iain McGilchrist, Bence Nanay, Betty Sue Flowers, and more
2022-12-16@bernardokastrup | The Subjective Experience #shorts
2022-12-15Exploring the dark side of physics | John Ellis
2022-12-13Can art uncover the essence of the world? | Janne Teller, Isy Suttie, James Tartaglia, Paul Muldoon
2022-12-10Is the universe really infinite? | George Ellis and David Deutsch
2022-12-09#SabineHossenfelder #StandardModel #physics #shorts
2022-12-09Is our society too divisive? | Ella Whelan, Paul Dolan, Myriam François
2022-12-06Lost in language | Hilary Lawson, Barry C. Smith, and Maria Balaska
2022-12-02Is the biological self a delusion? | JohnJoe McFadden, Ane Ogbe and Peter Brodin
2022-12-02#KimberleCrenshaw #shorts #intersectionality #discrimination
2022-12-01Can science crack the mystery of consciousness? | Bernardo Kastrup, Carlo Rovelli, and more
2022-11-29The future of money | Vince Cable and Linda Yueh
2022-11-26Where sceptics fail | Alex O'Connor
2022-11-25The future of transhumanism | Anders Sandberg, Slavoj Žižek, Nicky Ashwell, David Pearce and more
2022-11-24#MaryJaneRubestein #pantheism #shorts



Tags:
learning
education
debate
lecture
IAItv
institute of art and ideas
IAI
closer to truth
david deutsch
quantum physics
george ellis cosmology
george ellis
universe
infinity
does infinity exist
physics infinity
infinite universe
is the universe really infinite
infinity debate
robert lawrence kuhn
george ellis stephen hawking
cosmology
cosmology infinity
quantum mechanics
quantum theory infinity
the edge of the universe
quantum physics debate