| 1. | Update Video | 63 | Vlog |
|
| 2. | The NWO Starrcade Peak PPV - WCW Starrcade 1996 Review Reaction | 18 | Review |
|
| 3. | Santa's Deadly Christmas Eve Intake- Santa Food Theory Reaction | 18 | |
|
| 4. | Sonic 3 Trailer Reaction | 17 | | Sonic the Hedgehog 3
|
| 5. | Ase's CBB Remix of Sonic Mario & Groot - Cartoon Beatbox Battles Match Ups Reaction | 16 | |
|
| 6. | Looking at Old School Commercials - Nostalgia Critic Commercials Reaction | 15 | |
|
| 7. | Sleepover Battle Royale in Minecraft - Aphmau Minecraft Sleepover Reaction | 15 | | Minecraft
|
| 8. | Caddicarus vs 200% Crash Bash Reaction | 14 | |
|
| 9. | The Biggest Video Game Fails of 2022 - Top Ten 2022 Fails Reaction | 13 | |
|
| 10. | Meggy Deals with Treacherous Hero in Western Simulation - SMG4 Movie: WESTERN SPAGHETTI Reaction | 12 | |
|
| 11. | Ask Mario Ep 23 Reaction | 12 | | Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
|
| 12. | Mario Explores the Strange World of Mobile Ads - Mario Reacts To Cursed Mobile Game Ads Reaction | 12 | |
|
| 13. | Peach Joins Ask Mario Crew Movie Discussion w/Special Guests - Ask Mario Ep 21 Reaction | 11 | Discussion | Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
|
| 14. | Returning to Mario's First Q&A- Ask Mario Episode 1 Reaction Redux | 10 | Show |
|
| 15. | Strider Helps Critic with Spongebob's First Movie - The Spongebob Movie Nostalgia Critic Reaction | 10 | |
|
| 16. | Mario Takes on Japanese Wackiness - Mario Does Japanese Gameshows Reaction | 10 | Show |
|
| 17. | Breaking Mr. Puzzles Perfect Show - SMG4 Movie: PUZZLEVISION Reaction | 10 | Show |
|
| 18. | Strider Exposes Nintendo's Biggest Screwups - 10 Worst Nintendo Failures Reaction | 10 | |
|
| 19. | Caddy Plays UK Banned Games - The Forbidden World of BANNED Games Reaction | 10 | |
|
| 20. | Mario Many Flights to Space with Memes - Mario Reacts To Nintendo Memes 3 Reaction | 9 | |
|
| 21. | The Birth of Team Triple S - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 2 Reaction ReDux | 9 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 22. | Peach and Daisy Join in Amiibo QNA Break - Ask Mario Ep 17 Reaction | 9 | |
|
| 23. | Boyfriend Gets Help Against Sonic.exe - Triple Trouble WITH LYRICS Reaction | 9 | |
|
| 24. | THE BOYS. Reaction | 9 | |
|
| 25. | Junior Joins Ask Mario for Bowser's Fury - Ask Mario Ep 11 Reaction Redux | 9 | | Super Mario 3D World Bowser's Fury
|
| 26. | Caddy Burns through Kinect Games - Caddicarus Kinect Games Reaction | 9 | |
|
| 27. | Caddy Takes on the Spyro Franchise for 1 Million - Caddicarus Spyro Franchise Reaction Livestream | 9 | |
|
| 28. | Team Dark Disney Moments and Rouge's Smooth Steal - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 16 Reaction | 8 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 29. | RecD RAMBLEY REVIEW Music Video Reaction | 8 | Review |
|
| 30. | Aphmau Has REALISTIC BODY In Minecraft! Reaction | 8 | | Minecraft
|
| 31. | Knuckles and Amy Join the Twitter Takeover Fun - Sonic Twitter Takeover #6 Reaction Redux | 8 | | Sonic the Hedgehog
|
| 32. | Caddy Revisiting the Horror Games that Defined Youtube - Caddicarus Viral Horror Games Reaction | 8 | |
|
| 33. | Fawful's Favorite Paldean Pokémon - Top Ten Generation 9 Pokémon Reaction | 8 | | Pokémon Scarlet and Violet
|
| 34. | Deadly Minecraft Laugh Battle - 50 Ways to Die in Minecraft Part 15 Reaction | 8 | | Minecraft
|
| 35. | Crazy Frank Miller's Bad Superhero - The Spirit Nostalgia Critic Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 36. | Tag Teaming With VC on Tom and Jerry - Top 11 Tom and Jerry Episodes Nostalgia Critic Reaction | 7 | Show |
|
| 37. | Toad joins the Qna Madness - Ask Mario Ep 19 Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 38. | Classic Callback in Emerald Shrine - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 38 Reaction | 7 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 39. | Psychotic Twist Commercials - Nostalgia Critic Kingdom of the Commercials Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 40. | Shiloh and Bros Rainbow Friends Chapter 1 Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 41. | Bowser goes on a Luigi Rant and Sings with Mario in Tandem - Ask Mario Ep 5 Reaction Redux | 7 | |
|
| 42. | Killer Winnie wants Revenge - Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey (2023) KILL COUNT Reaction | 7 | | Winnie-the-Pooh's book writing speedrunner
|
| 43. | Sonic Forces Wrap Up QnA - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 27 Reaction | 7 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 44. | Guardian of the Earth vs Toxic Orcs - History of Power Rangers Wild Force Reaction | 7 | | Power Rangers Wild Force
|
| 45. | Going Back to the Old Castle - SMG4: Let’s Go Visit Peach! Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 46. | The Home Alone Movie That Falls Flat - Nostalgia Critic Home Sweet home Alone Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 47. | The Film That Revitalized Horror - Scream Kill Count Recount Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 48. | The Muppet's Take on Classic Christmas Story - Nostalgia Critic Muppet Christmas Carol Reaction | 7 | | Christmas Carol
|
| 49. | German Rats Invade Nutcracker for Shocks - Nostalgia Critic Nutcracker in 3D Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 50. | Mario Reacts to Illegal Nintendo Memes Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 51. | Solving How to Break the Curse of Demise - Legend of Zelda Game Theory Reaction | 7 | | The Legend of Zelda
|
| 52. | Hanging Out at Chaotix HQ - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 18 Reaction | 7 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 53. | Josh's Video Game Crushes - Top Ten Gaming Crushes Reaction | 7 | |
|
| 54. | Cereal Saga and Gum Love Affair - Nostalgia Critic Commercials H20 Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 55. | Bethesda's Lack of Changes - Top Ten Bethesda Fails Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 56. | Indigo Park Game Theory Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 57. | Don Bluth Torments Critic - Nostalgia Critic Conquest of the Commercials Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 58. | The Mightiest Brawling Death Battle- All Might vs Might Guy Death Battle Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 59. | SMG4 Loses Himself in the Perfect Video - SMG4 Movie: IT'S GOTTA BE PERFECT Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 60. | Meggy's Bizarre Ride to the Wild West - SMG4: Ready to Ride? Reaction | 6 | | The Wild West
|
| 61. | SCP-914 What Did YOU Put In It?! Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 62. | REMASTERED64: Mario's Road Trip Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 63. | The Start of the Comapny Fails Countdowns - Top Ten Worst EA FAILS Reaction Redux | 6 | |
|
| 64. | Nostalgia Critic Foodfight Review Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 65. | The Return of CBB - Shadow vs Vegeta Cartoon Beatbox Battle Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 66. | Solving the Questions in The PizzaPlex Ruins - Fnaf Ruin Game Theory Reaction | 6 | | Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach
|
| 67. | OP Curse Sorcerer Sensei Takes on Control Demon - Gojo vs Makima Death Battle Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 68. | Mario Sees SMG4 and Horrible Singing- Ask Mario Ep 12 Reaction Redux | 6 | |
|
| 69. | Apollo Justice Livestream#7: Reviewing the Past to Stop The Devil's Plan | 6 | Review | Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney
|
| 70. | Mario Deals with Nuclear Mutations - Super Mario Bros. but the floor is Radioactive Waste Reaction | 6 | | Super Mario Bros.
|
| 71. | Sonic's Redemption or Pitiful Rebellion - Sonic Forces Blessed or Messed Reaction | 6 | | Sonic Forces
|
| 72. | Red Team vs Mega Mecha Heavy - The Bolted Behemoth [SFM] Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 73. | Amanda the Adventurer 2 Demo Gameplay | 6 | | Amanda the Adventurer 2
|
| 74. | Tailsko Takes her First Dive into Deviantart - Tails and Tailsko VS DeviantArt Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 75. | Luigi Steals the Show for Singing and Bowser's Fear Revealed - Ask Mario Ep 4 Reaction Redux | 6 | Show |
|
| 76. | Meggy Deals with a Crisis - SMG4: We Interrupt This Broadcast Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 77. | Team Sonic's First Team182 Q&A - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 1 Reaction ReDux | 6 | |
|
| 78. | Tales of Vesperia Livestream #5 : Tension Builds in Dangrhest | 6 | | Tales of Vesperia
|
| 79. | Mario.EXE Trys To Steal Boyfriends Soul - GAME OVER WITH LYRICS Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 80. | Nostalgia Critic A Christmas Carol Review Reaction | 6 | Review | Christmas Carol
|
| 81. | Soundboard Extravaganza in Golf It - Vanoss Golf It Reaction | 6 | | Golf It!
|
| 82. | Cosmo Joins the ATSH Christmas Party- Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 48 Reaction | 6 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 83. | The Italian Bootleg Titanic Film - Nostalgia Critic Titanic: The Legend Goes on Reaction | 6 | | Nostalgia
|
| 84. | Cowardly OP Cartoon Dog Battle - Scooby-Doo VS Courage the Cowardly Dog Death Battle Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 85. | Among Us on the Ark | Tails and Cosmo: Don't I Know You? (Ep34) Reaction | 6 | |
|
| 86. | Kirby's Return to Dream Land Deluxe Livestream #2: Recovering the Remaining Starcutter Pieces | 5 | | Kirby and the Forgotten Land
|
| 87. | Sage Joins ASTH for Christmas Inquiries - Ask the Sonic Heroes Chaoscord Ep 2 Reaction | 5 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 88. | Silver and Amy See There Fanart and Chao Daddy Silver - Silver and Amy VS DeviantArt Reaction | 5 | | Sonic the Hedgehog
|
| 89. | Scary Monsters Stuck in Boring Plot - Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark Nostalgia Critic Reaction | 5 | |
|
| 90. | SMG4 Mr. Puzzles Clubhouse Reaction | 5 | |
|
| 91. | The Boss Battles with Multiple People at Once - Top Ten Squad Bosses Reaction | 5 | |
|
| 92. | Popular Games that Lost Fans Over the Years - Top Ten Games That Fell From Grace Reaction | 5 | | Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
|
| 93. | Caddy's Wallet Cries from Bandicoot Merch - Caddicarus Crash Bandicoot Merchandise Reaction | 5 | | Crash Bandicoot
|
| 94. | Aph and Friends Returns for More One Block Chaos -10 Friends DIE On ONE BLOCK In Minecraft! Reaction | 5 | | Minecraft
|
| 95. | Computer Become the Final Boss - Top Ten AI Bosses Reaction | 5 | |
|
| 96. | James's First Taste of the FNAF Franchise - Five Nights at Freddys (2023) KILL COUNT Reaction | 5 | | Five Nights at Freddy's
|
| 97. | Josh Scorcher Top Ten Remasters Reaction | 5 | |
|
| 98. | Green Scorpion Top Ten Video Game Demons Reaction | 5 | |
|
| 99. | Surprise Proposal in Awkward Villain Holiday - Ask the Sonic Heroes Ep 40 Reaction | 5 | | Sonic Heroes
|
| 100. | Minecraft Mod Makes Everyone Thiccc - Aphmau Thicc Minecraft Reaction | 5 | | Minecraft
|
